Catholic bishop Philip Tartaglia hasn’t even taken up his new post as Archbishop of Glasgow yet, but he’s already facing calls for his resignation. It’s emerged that in a recent speech (11 April) at a religious conference at Oxford University he accused society of being “very quiet” about “the relationship between the physical and mental health of gay men”. He went on to suggest that the premature death of Labour MP David Cairns last year was partly due to his homosexuality.
Tartaglia said (fast forward to 1:03:29 for the comments):
If what I have heard is true about the relationship between the physical and mental health of gay men, if it is true, then society is being very quiet about it.
Recently in Scotland, there was a gay Catholic MP who died at the age of 44 or so, and nobody said anything, and why should his body just shut down at that age?
Obviously he could have had a disease that would have killed anybody.
But you seem to hear so many stories about anger at ‘hurtful and ignorant’ comments, this kind of thing, but society won’t address it.
In fact, as was reported at the time of his death, Cairns died of pancreatitis, an illness that, like all others, afflicts homosexuals and heterosexuals alike (although perhaps Tartaglia, a la Brass Eye, distinguishes between “good aids” and “bad aids”). The suggestion from Tartaglia, a vociferous opponent of gay marriage, appears to be that “being gay can kill you”. In his defence, Tartaglia would point out that he was responding to a question about the recent suicide of a gay author in the US. But to move from this to suggest that Cairns’s death was due to anything other than pancreatitis is as bizarre as it is insulting.
One is reminded of Daily Mail columnist Jan Moir’s notorious column on the death of Stephen Gately, in which she wrote:
Healthy and fit 33-year-old men do not just climb into their pyjamas and go to sleep on the sofa, never to wake up again.
Whatever the cause of death is, it is not, by any yardstick, a natural one. Let us be absolutely clear about this. All that has been established so far is that Stephen Gately was not murdered.
And I think if we are going to be honest, we would have to admit that the circumstances surrounding his death are more than a little sleazy.
Cairns’s partner, Dermot Kehoe, who was in a relationship with the former Scotland Office minister for almost 15 years, told the Scotsman:
This is genuinely very upsetting and painful for David’s family and friends.
I can’t believe that someone who claims to be a man of God and is seeking to give moral leadership should speak from such a position of ignorance.
I don’t care what his views on gay marriage are, but to bring in my dead partner to justify those views is wrong.
PoliticsHome’s Paul Waugh reports that Ed Miliband, who is in Scotland today, is also expected to respond. Let us hope so, and that Tartaglia’s grotesque comments are condemned by all parties.