Support 100 years of independent journalism.

  1. Long reads
16 June 2003updated 24 Sep 2015 12:01pm

Much more than a straight banana

Dumb Britain, where debate is dominated by a wilfully idiotic press, just doesn't get it about Europ

By Celia Brayfield

On 31 December 2001, I was with some English friends in a bakery in a small town in France called Sauveterre-de-Bearn. The shop, near the majestic Romanesque church, is the whole nine metres of a Joanne Harris cliche, except that the proprietor was not Juliette Binoche but a Monsieur Charrier, a willowy young man whose achievements in chocolate were famed from Pau to St Vincent-de-Tyrosse.

It was the eve of Europe’s conversion to the euro, and Monsieur Charrier had created a new cake in the form of the double- crossed “e”. My friends were charmed. This was not lost on the other customers in the shop. We were watched, closely but discreetly, as we made our purchasing decision. When we finally bought the euro-cake, the clientele broke into jubilant smiles: the British were going for the euro. It was all going to be all right.

It couldn’t have happened here: little chance of a small baker in a small town; no euro, obviously; and worst of all, no grasp of European political realities by the general population.

The man on the Clapham omnibus, going home with his part-baked baguette, reduced-fat mozzarella and Greek-style yoghurt, has no real idea what the euro, let alone the European constitution, will mean for him. Dumb Britain just doesn’t get it. Having spent a year in the Bearn, I know that my neighbours’ chat about the Union is far more informed than comparable debate in Britain.

And how could debate here be informed, when it is held in newspapers that take the wilful-idiocy line on Europe, running stories on the threat from Brussels to straight bananas and smoky-bacon-flavoured crisps? Now, after decades of trivialisation, the same papers are suddenly anxious to lighten Dumb Britain’s darkness. “The end of our nation!” screamed the Sun, which, let us never forget, is owned by an Australian-American. “A blueprint for tyranny!” and “The bonfire of our freedoms!” shrieked the Daily Mail, puffing its ludicrous knit-your-own referendum. Even the Americans were shocked; they blame the Second World War. The 2 June issue of Time illustrates a report on British Europhobia with a full-page picture of an ARP warden looking out for the Luftwaffe from an East End rooftop.

Sign up for The New Statesman’s newsletters Tick the boxes of the newsletters you would like to receive. A weekly newsletter helping you fit together the pieces of the global economic slowdown. Quick and essential guide to domestic and global politics from the New Statesman's politics team. The New Statesman’s global affairs newsletter, every Monday and Friday. The best of the New Statesman, delivered to your inbox every weekday morning. The New Statesman’s weekly environment email on the politics, business and culture of the climate and nature crises - in your inbox every Thursday. Our weekly culture newsletter – from books and art to pop culture and memes – sent every Friday. A weekly round-up of some of the best articles featured in the most recent issue of the New Statesman, sent each Saturday. A newsletter showcasing the finest writing from the ideas section and the NS archive, covering political ideas, philosophy, criticism and intellectual history - sent every Wednesday. Sign up to receive information regarding NS events, subscription offers & product updates.

In Brussels, where I recently went as a guest of the European Parliament to witness the last hours of horse-trading over the final draft of the constitution, this sudden outbreak of rabies was viewed with dismay by the good Brits fighting our corner. They all agreed that the EU was far from perfect, but the constitution was being devised to make it work better. They all agreed, too, that there must be a referendum. (Though one of my media colleagues at the parliament asked how we could hold a referendum in a country whose population was 20 per cent functionally illiterate.)

Content from our partners
Transport is the core of levelling up
The forgotten crisis: How businesses can boost biodiversity
Small businesses can be the backbone of our national recovery

Among the non-British there was, at best, the kind of indulgence extended to a very old dog making a puddle on the carpet: poor thing, can’t help it. Some approached me with pitying smiles: “Of course, you don’t have a constitution of your own. This is all new to you.” Yes, they understood. Some of them.

“Why is it always a blame game?” demanded a young diplomat, who accused the British media of using Europe like a spittoon. “Why are we always talking about Europe in the third person – Brussels wants to do this, Brussels tries to do that? This is a democratic process and you are part of it. You have UK members, UK MEPs, UK staff serving a UK commissioner. Why this image of Britain as a reluctant bride?”

Key to this media blame-storm are the lies. Much of what our anti-Europe press is screaming about was a done deal that we democratically accepted when we joined. Now British journalists suddenly claim that we’re victims of a multinational conspiracy. “Stealthily, slyly, Eurocrats have devised a constitution which . . . could soon destroy Britain’s nationhood,” claimed Simon Heffer in the Daily Mail.

Huh? Stealthily? In a building the size of a supertanker, with a huge debating chamber lavishly supplied with press galleries, a website updated daily, and tonnes upon tonnes of leaflets outlining the plans for the Convention and inviting all comers to sit in on the plenary sessions? Heffer sees no leaflets. Maybe he’s overdue for a check-up at Specsavers.

Stealthy, no. Sly, not at all. Conspiracy, hardly. Just not sexy. And complicated. In every country in the Union, Europe is strictly for anoraks. The rounded contours of the European Parliament building promote a meditative state and the decor, in muted shades of taupe, beige, greige, gunmetal, charcoal, anthracite, donkey, putty, hopsack, elephant, pigeon, battleship, off-white, limewash and mushroom, tends to calm one to the point of catatonia. As Neil Kinnock says, “Dancing round the maypole is infrequent.”

But let’s be un-British for a moment. Let’s forget the style and think about the substance. Let’s dare to discover our inner anorak. What is happening here is the birth of a new kind of government. One hundred and five good and clever people are devising a political machine to be operated by 25 different – and sovereign – states. It is a long, wearying, agonised and difficult process. And, as our planet gets smaller and more acutely interdependent by the hour, it is a vital process, and absolutely worth the sweat.

Here’s another story about the British in Europe. Recently, I was driving down a road in Italy with two English expat friends who are great animal lovers. They spotted an abandoned dog in a lay-by and immediately imagined the poor animal’s pain, hunger and terror. They reframed their plans for the afternoon, and drove off to buy some food for it.

The animal, a skinny but attractive young hunting dog, was too frightened to come close, but as soon as we drove off it ran out of the undergrowth to the dish of biscuits.

As visitors to Italy will have noted, the lay-bys on arterial roads are frequently occupied by prostitutes, who make a Fellini-esque picture as they stand about on their platform sandals waiting for business. The next day, when my friends returned with more food for the dog, the lay-by was occupied by a skinny but attractive young prostitute, called Eva, from Hungary.

Eva assured us that she was happy in her work and equipped with her own passport and, rather than imagine any human pain or terror, my friend chose to believe her. Eva handed over the dog to my friends. They gave her 20 euros for it and left her in the lay-by. Then they called the vet, organised a nice soft bed for the dog (now also called Eva) and began to dine out on the tale of how they’d teamed up with the tart with a heart of gold to perform this heroic pet rescue. Morally dodgy? Sentimentally self-indulgent? Missing the big picture? Well, what can you expect of a Brit?

If our popular media are sloppy and irresponsible, our governments have made things worse by their own fears. The presentation of Europe in Britain has been a tissue of white lies, woven by one gutless government after another in the hope of not frightening the electorate.

“This is just a tidying-up exercise,” chant the Labour MEPs, singing from Peter Hain’s hymn sheet. “Let’s just be part of a free-trade area,” propose the Tories. Who are they trying to kid? This is the start of a new European age. To take the money and run is not an option. You really cannot con all the people all the time; even Dumb Britain has a certain bovine instinct for spotting spin.

Fortunately, Dumb Britain is not the only Britain. There is also Peter Mayle’s Britain, sitting in cafes in Hackney and rubbing its hands over the underpricing of European property, mortgaging its bricks and mortar to buy in to limestone and crepi. There are no reliable statistics, but informed guessers estimate that at least a million Britons now have homes in France and Spain alone. Millions more dream of driving over lemons to a place in the sun, and a whole industry, including the Daily Mail‘s property pages, is there to help them. Buy-to-let may be a busted flush in Docklands, but a little flat in Bordeaux or a ski lodge in Hungary is looking good.

Then there is Nigel’s Britain, named after my friend Nigel, a designer who lives in France. His company is registered in London, it buys leather in Cyprus, has it dyed and sewn in Hungary, and sells mostly in Milan. There are thousands like Nigel. When would they like to join the euro? The decade before yesterday.

Then there is Socrates/Erasmus Britain. Ten thousand British students studied at European universities last year – the year that this educational integration programme celebrated a union-wide total of one million participants.

Count in all these Britains, and their friends, their housemates, their siblings and their parents, and you have millions looking at the future of Europe with confidence and affection, who find Simon Heffer and his Europhobic friends an acute national embarrassment.

Deep France, by Celia Brayfield, will be published by Macmillan in May 2004