Europe, what have you done for me lately?
The EU's triumph on mobile charges shows how the union benefits consumers.
By Will Straw Published 03 July 2012 13:24
The debate about whether or not Britain should have a referendum on its membership of the European Union continues to rumble on with politicians from the left and right intervening. But not a single politician has mentioned a new piece of European legislation which is set to reduce mobile costs for consumers in Britain and further afield.
In the last few days, most mobile phone customers will have received a text from their operator informing them that roaming charges, the cost of using data services abroad on smart phones, are falling. None will have been told that the change is due to concerted action by the European Commission rather than a benevolent decision by their mobile company.
The new rules mean that no customer can be charged more than:
• 29 euro cents (24p) a minute to make a call.
• 8 cents (7p) a minute to receive a call.
• 9 cents (8p) to send a text message.
• 70 cents a megabyte (58p) to download data or browse the internet, charged by the kilobyte used.
My operator, Orange, have done the absolute minimum and brought their charges down from the extortionate rate of £2.55 to 58p per megabyte. They still charge £8 per megabyte to roam in most countries outside the EU. Despite being forced to take this action, their website claims that “We are constantly updating our roaming services in Europe to provide the best possible business service abroad.” A likely story.
Thankfully the European Commission aims to reduce the gap between domestic and foreign call rates to virtually nothing by 2015. Indeed, Labour MEP for South East England, Peter Skinner, said in May:
“If roaming prices have not come all the way down to domestic levels by 2016, then the European Commission will be obliged to propose additional legislation to ensure that roaming charges are identical to domestic prices.”
Over the last two days several politicians have added their thoughts on Europe without drawing attention to Brussels’ triumph on mobile charges. David Cameron has confused everyone with his ‘hokey-cokey’ on an EU referendum. Despite calling for “less Europe not more Europe” in the bearpit of yesterday’s Commons debate he used his Sunday Telegraph article to say “The single market is at the heart of the case for staying in the EU … Leaving would not be in our country’s best interests”. So why not follow through with an up-to-the-minute example such as the data roaming cap?
In the same paper, Liam Fox called for a “new relationship” with the EU (rather than exit). But rather than talking up the virtues of EU membership here and now he used the past tense to claim that:
“The single market was one of the most important aims of the European Union project, yet in choosing a model based on harmonisation rather than mutual recognition it became inevitable that a body of law and regulation would be created that would potentially invite bureaucratic cost, diminished global competitiveness and even give encouragement to those who would fan the embers of national protectionism.”
On Labour’s side, Douglas Alexander wrote in yesterday’s Guardian that an EU referendum is no substitute for a European strategy. In defending the EU, he commented:
“We must be clear, the single market is not just about “free trade” as the Eurosceptics misleadingly imply. It's about far more than that: removing barriers behind the borders – and that requires common rules with a commission and court to enforce them. And where we have shared goals – from tackling climate change to cross-border crime and human trafficking – in an era of billion-person countries and trillion-pound economies – we cannot afford to give up on ways that help amplify our voice and protect our interests.”
Better but still no cigar.
The failure of politicians in the UK on all sides to make the positive case for Europe is one of the reasons why the debate about a referendum has now reached fever pitch. An ‘in/out’ referendum can be won but politicians who favour remaining in and pushing back the UKIP tide must start to make the positive case.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















30 comments
Nice article..... interesting.
Goji Goji fructe goji
This has to be a spoof article. I think mr Straw junior ought to get a proper job as a comedian. perhaps when he has stopped thinking about the "consumers"ofEurope he could give some thought to the workers and young unemployed currently residing in Greece,Ireland,Spain,Italy,Portugal.
Joy to the world! The Eu has delivered....cheaper phone calls for 1 week a year!! I was previously worried by the beauracracy ('fruit free of abnormal curvature!'), cost (£45m a day), lack of democracy (eu commissioners) etc, but never mind all that now. I now understand why Ireland was told to go back and vote again, this time correctly you naughty Irish!
Really those telecom ops should be admired for their marketing talent not their technical expertise.
Brainwashing just isn't in it!
The EU Commission is getting a pretty good drubbing but let's not forget those tariff walls that faded away into the ether.
We'd hate to have to storm those defences from outside the EU.
Hacked Off
₠800,000? Sold! To the EU! Cheap at the price. That's Straw's integrity and independence gone. But at least Kinnock fils will be getting cheaper calls when he phones home from Denmark.
my neighbor's ex-wife makes $70/hour on the laptop. She has been out of a job for 5 months but last month her paycheck was $21696 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Here's the site to read more Lazycash24 dot com
So it is more what they have done for you you than us. How embarrassing.
The first page of Europe On 387m Euros A Day (first page!):
Looking for a popular gesture, the EU reduced the cost of “roaming charges”, the inflated rate that one is charged for using one’s phone elsewhere in the EU. Because telecoms operators exist to make money, they chase the profit bubble wherever it is pushed under the wallpaper. So, most of them recouped the loss by raising the price of domestic phone calls – which we make for the 50 weeks of the year that we are not abroad elsewhere in the EU. (People who are based abroad, such as all MEPs but Belgium’s, may have viewed the decision more gratefully than others.)
The Wall Street Journal saw through the move: “The 56 per cent of European cellphone users who don’t travel outside their home countries, according to a Eurobarometer survey, will surely not be thrilled if their bills rise to accommodate those (typically wealthier) users who do travel. If someone told them their domestic phone bills were likely to go up, this EU brainchild would probably not be as popular as the [EU] Commission appears to think it is now. None of these arguments has so far swayed EU officials, whose chief obsession seems to be boosting the union’s public image.”
In effect, business travellers used to subsidise people making local calls, but now the situation is reversed – some pay-as-you-go minimum call charges went from 10p to 25p. Not quite such a victory for the ordinary consumer.
In 2008, the EU turned its attention to the fee that different networks charge one another for connecting calls, the so-called “termination charges”. The networks, particularly Vodafone, immediately warned the EU that if price caps were imposed on these charges then customer offers such as free handsets would have to be withdrawn and also that, as happens in the USA, those receiving calls might have to be charged.
From: http://tinyurl.com/6llbtpr
The simple answer to the question posed in the title is ........'bunged my pet think tank €800,000.'
Don't you think you should be declaring this too?
And KA-POWW!! Real World 1 - FreeLoaders 0.
Thanks for the info, interesting, so basically Will is just another paid mouthpiece. Who would of thought it ?
Yup, IPPR is yet another suckler at the teat of the almighty EU boondoggle
"Brussels’ triumph on mobile charges"!! - tractor production up again!!
lol
I can only assume from reading this garbage that young Master Straw is angling for a well paid and pernsioned Brussels post, like so many other talentless members of the Labour Young Nomenklatura. (See Kinnock Junior etc)
Politicians on all sides are being very deliberately disingenuous when they talk about the EU. They have been for decades now. On the one hand, they know that leaving it is not a realistic option therefore will always fall short of calling outright for us to exit the EU. On the otherhand, being eurosceptic and always insulting towards the EU is an excellent vote winner - it makes them look tough by playing on our primitve dislike for all things foreign.
What they all should do is to finally address us as adults. Then maybe there could be some constructive polices towards to EU that we could all support.
And you have a towering intellect Dub Dub because you disagree with us and agree with Jack's lad and the ever reliable willoyen?
That's such a lazy comment, care to remind us how many years since the EU accounts have been signed off?
What is it about the EU debate that attracts so many idiots into comment sections?
Ask yourself how would an idiot know when he's come across other idiots !
Few are that interested in the internal workings of an institutionally corrupt, bureaucratic, undemocratic and financially failing still born entity that goes by the name of the European Union. It's time to give the British people that vote and let them decide their own future. What is it about the democratic process that Euro-fascists find so terrifying?
I must say Douglas Alexander lost me when he got to the "tackling climate change" bit, my mind just went off, starting thinking about what i was going to have for dinner tonight.
Wow, that has sealed it, I'm now converted. Let me know when you hit the bottom, with this new revelation of the never ending joys of the E.U you must be close! Doh
Think about all those poor fish and not the barrel !
So forty years of the Common Market/EEC/EU and at last they have forced a reduction in 'roaming charges' on mobile phones.
The excitement and anticipation that precedes my deliberation as to whether it is now worthwhile me buying such a device can only be imagined.
Any chance of them getting to grips with democracy and an end to corruption, or will I have to wait until 2052 before they get around to it?
I can only presume this absolute rubbish was written by Jack's boy?
Why doesn't he try and get a proper job?
LOL
so 'they' (typical euroscared gloss) should get to grips with democracy and corruption, eh? bit rich isn't it, coming from, I presume, a Brit, a citizen of one of the least democratic member states, and one that is a spectacular success at profiting from corruption.... just about seething in it, and ready to "veto" EU moves against improvement!
so you seem to be for 'out'
oh bravo! an excellent point well made. Not in any way vague or lacking in hard facts.........psssst, that was sarcasm willoyen
Bí ' do thost.
Fifth column scum alert !
The sound of a barrel being scraped.
Wonderful, Mr Straw, that's a fantastic reason for all the nations of Europe to go down the plughole and financial ruin, your mobile phone calls will be cheaper. Go and peedle such nonsense on your Left Foot Forward!