Gilad Shalit is free – now release the 164 jailed Palestinian children
Israel's crimes, including the arrest, detention and alleged torture of incarcerated children, are routinely ignored, or even excused.
By Mehdi Hasan Published 20 October 2011
At 2am on 6 July, Ahmed, a 15-year-old boy from the village of Burin, in the occupied West Bank, was up late socialising with relatives. "Suddenly, many [Israeli] soldiers stormed the house," he recalls. "We were surprised to see them. They started shouting at us and ordering us into the living room."
The teenager, who was told he was "wanted for interrogation", was blindfolded and taken to a detention centre on the outskirts of Nablus, where he says he was verbally abused, shoved and kicked, and threatened with a dog. Whenever he tried to sleep, an Israeli soldier would kick him to keep him awake. Interrogators accused Ahmed of throwing stones. He was then transferred to the Megiddo Prison in Israel, where he was strip-searched on arrival.
Ahmed's story is one of dozens of case studies collated by the charity Defence for Children International. At the time of writing, according to figures released by the Israel Prison Service, there are 164 Palestinian children aged between 12 and 17 incarcerated in Israeli jails, including 35 minors aged between 12 and 15. As many as 700 Palestinian children are prosecuted each year in Israel's military courts; more than 7,000 have been detained since 2000.
We do not know their names and we do not hear their stories. But we do know Gilad Shalit, who was captured inside Israel after a cross-border raid by Hamas in June 2006. On the morning of 18 October, the 25-year-old soldier was freed by Hamas in exchange for 1,027 Palestinian prisoners. The next day, his photo was on the front pages of the world's leading newspapers. David Cameron expressed his "joy and relief" at the release of Sergeant Shalit.
Kids first
But what of the Palestinian children who continue to languish in Israeli prison cells? Does our Prime Minister have a view on their ongoing incarceration? Will he condemn the transfer of children from the occupied West Bank to prisons inside Israel, in contravention of Article 76 of the Fourth Geneva Convention? Or the interrogation of Palestinian children in the absence of lawyers and their parents?
Above all, why hasn't the British government, and the international community, urged Israel to release these particular detainees in its thousand-for-one prisoner swap? Of the 477 Palestinian prisoners, including 27 women, freed so far in exchange for Shalit, none is a minor. "I would have released the children first," Rabbi Arik Ascherman, of the Jerusalem-based Rabbis for Human Rights, told me. "These children are often caught up in [security] sweeps, with no real evidence that they were in any way involved in violence."
Ascherman says the sentences that they usually receive are "extremely disproportionate" and a product of "kangaroo courts". The empirical evidence is on his side. According to a report by the leading Israeli human rights group B'Tselem, between 2005 and 2010, 835 Palestinian minors were tried in military courts in the West Bank on charges of stone-throwing. Only one minor was acquitted during those five years: a shockingly high conviction rate of 99.9 per cent.
Nineteen of the Palestinian minors sent to jail by Israeli military judges during this period were aged between 12 and 13. Yet, in Israel, it is against the law to imprison any child under the age of 14. Why treat Palestinian children differently from Israeli children? And if this isn't a form of apartheid, then what is?
In 2009, 100 sworn affidavits were collected by human rights lawyers from a group of imprisoned Palestinian children. They found 69 per cent of them reported being beaten and kicked; 49 per cent said they had been threatened with violence; 14 per cent were held in solitary confinement; and 12 per cent were threatened with sexual assault, including rape. One-third of the children said they had been bullied by Israeli interrogators into signing confessions written in Hebrew, not Arabic.
Unpeople
Over the past decade, however, despite the submission of 600 or so complaints against interrogators over alleged abuse and torture of Palestinian detainees, not one criminal investigation has been conducted by the Israeli authorities. Does anyone care?
The Palestinian child prisoners are perhaps the best example of what the historian Mark Curtis has called "unpeople" - those whose lives are "deemed worthless, expendable in the pursuit of power and commercial gain"; voiceless and delegitimised. They have few advocates or champions in the west.
Hamas must take some responsibility, too. Why didn't the militant group's leadership insist on the release of these children under the prisoner swap? Why lobby for only murderers and bomb-makers? (One source with intimate knowledge of the internal politics of Hamas says the militant group "may have been targeting those with life or long-term sentences who otherwise may not have been let out".)
Most British politicians, in all three main parties, continue to ignore the systematic abuse of Palestinian human rights by Israel, our close "friend" and "ally". Israel's crimes, including the arrest, detention and alleged torture of incarcerated children, are routinely ignored, or even excused. This month, for instance, Foreign Secretary William Hague designated the former Israeli foreign minister Tzipi Livni's visit to the UK as a "special mission", thereby preventing a warrant for her arrest, over accusations of war crimes relating to the 2009 war in Gaza, from being issued.
The double standard is glaring. Gilad Shalit, often described in the Israeli press as "Israel's son" , is finally - and thankfully - free from captivity. Many of Palestine's sons and daughters, however, remain behind bars.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists


43 comments
Israel furthers its ever-deepening global isolation by such behaviour and rightly earns the ire of the world. This situation cannot be morally justified. It deserves to be roundly condemned and far more so than it has been. Even within Israel there is much debate over this practice as the article, to be fair does point out. http://www.grantsforcollege101.com/
Well said. More people need to speak up for the Palestinians and the hell they are in.
People wanting to read more should contact Friends of Al Aqsa at info@aqsa.org.uk. The facts they give will upset any rightminded person.
"Mohammed is God's apostle. Those who follow him are ruthless to the unbelievers but merciful to one another"
Quran 48:29
As adhered to by Medhi Hassan.
Lets not talk about this weeks Islamic terror, we'll bash Israel instead, much easier..
2011.10.21 (Mosul, Iraq) - 'Insurgents' murder a woman inside her home.
2011.10.21 (Bazai, Pakistan) - Muslim extremists throw grenades into a home, killing three family members including a woman.
2011.10.20 (Karachi, Pakistan) - A 22-year-old Shiite is shot to death outside his home by Wahhabis.
2011.10.19 (Maiduguri, Nigeria) - The owner and a patron are shot to death at a barber shop by Islamic terrorists.
2011.10.19 (Ramadi, Iraq) - 'Insurgents' bomb a health office, killing two innocents.
2011.10.19 (Lahj, Yemen) - An al-Qaeda militant throws a grenade into a packed market, killing two civilians.
There is a reason we call it Islamic terrorism, and it isn't because we falsely attribute motives to the terrorists, but because Islam is the stated purpose and aim of the terrorists.
Daniel Greenfield
How old were the kids publicly hung from cranes in islamofascist Iran for the crime of being Gay?
Putting everything else to one side, Hamas could have had every single one of these children released this week. Every single one of them could have been at home tonight with their families. This cruelty could be over, and this would be an article about the past and not the present. Instead they chose to seek the release of murderers and people who assisted suicide bombings in restaurants and buses.
Many (though certainly not all) of the released will return to the armed wing of Hamas and bolster the fighting unit. The children would have been of no use to the fighting unit, so Hamas made the calculated judgment to leave them wallowing in Israeli prisons, instead serving to allow articles like this to be written that, quite rightly, further denigrate Israel.
Israel furthers its ever-deepening global isolation by such behaviour and rightly earns the ire of the world. This situation cannot be morally justified. It deserves to be roundly condemned and far more so than it has been. Even within Israel there is much debate over this practice as the article, to be fair does point out.
However, the fact remains that Hamas could have ended this situation week. They chose not to. They would prefer to leave their own children in prison cells because it serves their own political ends. Whilst some Palestinian families celebrate with their loved ones who are convicted murderers (whose guilt is not in question), others sit waiting for the return of their children whose crimes were miniscule by comparison. This is sick and obscene.
It appauls me that barely 30 words out of an article of more than 900 words has been given over to the behaviour of the Hamas leadership in this instance and it astounds me how little commentary has been made elsewhere. Defending and protecting one's children is the most essential, the most natural rule of all human behaviour and of all human societies. Hamas have defied this by seeking the release of murderous adults over children.
Israel's policies here may well be entirely indefensible, but Hamas's operation defies the most basic laws of human behaviour.
'captured in a cross border raid'
Not 'kidnapped and held hostage'?
Amazing what a little bit of spin can do.
Islam is not a peaceful religion. It is a terrorist organisation. The Koran is not just a book. It is racist, violent poison that should be banned. Possession of them ran should be treated in the same way as possession of heroin.
That elected officials won't even publicly criticise Israel over these abuses shows the extent of lobbying and where true power lies.
It's time for our MP's to do the right thing and speak out against abuse, wherever it takes place!
Post new comment