Listen to the heroes of Israel

The moral courage of Israeli dissidents.

I phoned Rami Elhanan the other day. We had not spoken for six years and much has happened in Israel and Palestine. Rami is an Israeli graphic designer who lives with his family in Jerusalem. His father survived Auschwitz. His grandparents and six aunts and uncles perished in the Holocaust. Whenever I am asked about heroes, I say Rami and his wife, Nurit, without hesitation.

Soon after we met, Rami gave me a home videotape that was difficult to watch. It shows his daughter Smadar, aged 14, throwing her head back, laughing and playing the piano. "She loved to dance," he said. On the afternoon of 4 September 1997, Smadar and her best friend, Sivane, had auditions for admission to a dance school. She had argued that morning with her mother, who was anxious about her going to the centre of Jerusalem. "I didn't want to row," said Nurit, "so I let her go."

Rami was in his car when he turned on the radio to catch the three o'clock news. There had been a suicide bombing in Ben Yehuda shopping precinct. More than 200 people were injured and several were dead. Within minutes, his mobile phone rang. It was Nurit, crying. They searched the hospitals in vain, then the morgue; and so began, as Rami describes it, their "descent into darkness".

Rami and Nurit are two of the founders of the Parents Circle, or Bereaved Families Forum, which brings together Israelis and Palestinians who have lost loved ones. "It's painful to acknowledge," he said, "but there is no basic moral difference between the [Israeli] soldier at the checkpoint who prevents a woman who is having a baby from going through, causing her to lose the baby, and the man who killed my daughter. And just as my daughter was a victim [of the occupation], so was he." Rami describes the Israeli occupation and the dispossession of Palestinians as a "cancer in our heart". Nothing changes, he says, until the occupation ends.

Open your eyes

Every "Jerusalem Day" - the day Israel celebrates its military conquest of the city - Rami has stood in the street with a photograph of Smadar and crossed Israeli and Palestinian flags, and people have spat at him and told him it is a pity he was not blown up, too. And yet he and Nurit and their comrades have made ­extraordinary gains. Rami goes to Israeli schools with a Palestinian member of the group, and they show maps of what ought to be Palestine, and they hug each other. "This is like an earthquake to children who have been socialised and manipulated into hating," he said. "They say to us, 'You have opened my eyes.'"

In October, Rami and Nurit sat in the Israeli high court as the state counsel, "stammering, unprepared and unkempt", wrote Nurit, "stood like a platoon commander in charge of new recruits and refuted . . . allegations". Salwa and Bassam Aramin, Palestinian parents, were there, too. Tears streaked Salwa's face. Their ten-year-old daughter, Abir Aramin, was killed by an Israeli soldier firing a rubber bullet point-blank at her small head as she stood beside a kiosk buying sweets with her sister. The judges seemed bored and one of them remarked that Israeli soldiers were rarely indicted, so it would be best to forget it. The state counsel laughed. This was normal.

“Our children," said Nurit, at a rally last December to mark the first anniversary of the Israeli assault on Gaza, "have learned this year that all the disgusting qualities which anti-Semites attribute to Jews are actually manifested among our leaders: deceit, greed and the murder of children . . . What values of beauty and goodness can we squeeze into such a sophisticated apparatus of brainwashing and reality distortion?"

Rami now tells me the high court has decided to investigate the case of Abir Aramin after all. This is not normal: it is a victory. “Where are the other victories?" I asked him.

“In America last year, a Palestinian and I spoke five times a day in front of thousands. There is a big shift in American public opinion, and that's where the hope lies. It's only pressure from outside Israel - from Jews especially - that will end this nightmare. People in the west must know that while there is a silence, this looking away, this profane abuse of Israel's critics as anti-Jew, they are no different from those who stood aside during the days of the Holocaust."

Guilty silence

Since Israel's onslaught on Lebanon in 2006, its devastation of Gaza in 2008-2009, and Mossad's recent political murder in Dubai, the criminality of the Israeli state has been impossible to disguise. On 11 February, the influential Reut Institute in Tel Aviv reported to the Israeli cabinet, which it advises, that violence had failed to achieve Israel's ends and had produced worldwide revulsion instead.

“In last year's Gaza operation," the report said, "our superior military power was offset by an offensive on Israel's legitimacy that led to a significant setback in our international standing and will constrain future Israeli military planning and operations." In other words, proof of the murderous, racist toll of Zionism has been an epiphany for many people; justice for the Palestinians, wrote the expatriate Israeli musician Gilad Atzmon, is now "at the heart of the battle for a better world".

However, his fellow Jews in western countries, such as Britain and Australia, whose influence is critical, are still mostly silent, still looking away, still accepting, as Nurit said, the "brainwashing and reality distortion".

And yet the responsibility to speak out could not be clearer, and the lessons of history - family history for many - ensure that it renders them culpable should their silence persist. For inspiration, I recommend the moral courage of Rami and Nurit.

17 comments

BarnabasGaston's picture

Israel has become worse than Nazi Germany, and Heil Hitler to you, apparently you would not hesitate to kill your fellow Jewish compatriots, just because they have the decency and self respect which you and your sort who voted for far right in Israel cannot understand; therefore I do not care about what happens to you. http://www.womenrainboots.net/

MikeS1's picture

Pilger quotes approvingly "the expatriate Israeli musician Gilad Etzmon". The naive, Pilger's target audience, might assume that he was a crtic of Israeli policy as he might legitimately be. But Pilger know perfectly well that this is not so. Atzmon describes himself as a former Jew who thinks that The Protocols of the Elders of Zion are an accurate blueprint for a Jewish plot to take over the world.He is also a Holocaust denier. Presumably Pilger is happy to be associated with someone like this?

fiona's picture

Pilger again tells it just like it is, and with a moving narrative. I salute you, John... You are one of the few honest and brilliant journalist/writers left in the world.

By the way, to Ellen: Your comments are disgusting! Nobody buys Israeli "self defense" bulls...t any longer, and we are sick of your exploitation of every decent human being's compassion for Holocaust victims.
Israel has become worse than Nazi Germany, and Heil Hitler to you, apparently you would not hesitate to kill your fellow Jewish compatriots, just because they have the decency and self respect which you and your sort who voted for far right in Israel cannot understand; therefore I do not care about what happens to you, you do not deserve my compassion, hence shut the f... up keep your sick thoughts to your kind!

RFM's picture

Adam, we don't need John Pilger to remind us of the rocket attacks, the Palestinian reluctance to deal with the Israeli leadership, or the Hizbollah attacks from Lebanon, we have the BBC for that, and failing the BBC, there is always the never failing New York Times. But if John Pilger is not going to tell us about Rami and Nurit Elhanan, do you think the BBC or the New York Times will do so in his place? If they won't, why won't they?

By the way, out of interest, I have just searched the BBC for Rami, there are four results. Entering Palestinian rocket attacks into the BBC site yielded 133 results. Perhaps there is more going on here than your analysis suggests.

Searching for Rami Elhanan on the NY Times site yielded no results, not even going back to 1851. However, Palestinian rocket attacks yielded 5710 results.

Will you also be complaining to the BBC and the NY Times that they are teaching us about oh, innocent Israel and so villainous Palestinians? Be honest ... if you dare.

Joshua Blakeney's picture

Speaking of "Moral Courage," next week in Calgary, AB, Canada there is a trial taking place for the man who attempted a citizens' arrest on George W. Bush. Cynthia McKinney and Ramsay Clark will be attending. Why is the New Statesman not reporting this upcoming trial? I am unaware of any person in the world, other than Splitting the Sky, who has risked his/her life to break police lines and arrest Bush. Here are some links: http://www.splittingthesky.net/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=62a53enMtA0

http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=17350

Ari Rusila's picture

I have met people working in “Parents Circle” and I admire their courage and commitment to work for peace with non-violent way. I also have been informed about other inter-cultural groups as e.g. those working in Arawa with environmental studies. These examples show that peaceful cooperation between Israelis and Palestinians is possible on the ground.

Saying that I however have almost opposite conclusions as Mr. Pilger. Why so? Israel-Palestine inter-cultural groups represent only tiny fraction of population. The main part of political leadership and population both in Israel and Palestine area has other priority. In Israel big part of population thinks that Israel as strong Jewish state can best defence their interests and hard line government to implement their wish. Palestinian leadership is defending rights of local Muslim population, refugees and vision of Palestine state. Hard line Palestine groups – with remarkable popular support – is implementing their vision with terrorist acts. In outside power centres especially in Anglo-Saxon world Israeli and Palestinian interest groups are putting their pressure to western capitals. Many outsiders admit that both sides have good base for their claims.

So far resolving the Palestinian-Israeli conflict has had two options on the top of agenda. The first is aim of two states for two peoples and the second is a bi-national Palestinian-Israeli state in which Palestinians and Israelis would have equal rights or a Palestinian-Israeli confederation, in which two states share joint political institutions – a one-sate option. Sadly – I do not believe any of these alternatives and from my viewpoint instead of dead road maps more pragmatic approach should be applied. In my recent post “Will (East) Jerusalem be the End of Two-State Illusion?” - http://arirusila.wordpress.com/2010/03/29/will-east-jerusalem-be-the-end...
I try to find elements for this approach.

nicholasblack's picture

If you read one comment to this rubbish article, read this:
http://blog.z-word.com/2010/02/john-pilger-and-the-
enabling-of-antisemitism/#comment-10076

AdamSGNJ's picture

RFM, you make it sound as if the BBC and the New York Times only report the Israeli point of view. I don't agree. I think they try to provide balanced coverage, including human interest-type articles on individuals like the Elhanans. You and I may disagree on their success, or if they draw the line of balance in the right place. But on any given day, you may find articles on all belligerents in the horrible Arab-Israeli conflict, and (indeed) articles that portray Palestinians, Israelis or both in a less-than-flattering light.
I'd argue that John Pilger makes no pretense of objectivity and produces article after article reinforcing his own presupposition: i.e., that Israel is essentially bad, the Palestinians are all blameless victims, and the world is moving in an inexorable, somewhat Marxian-utopian fashion, toward realising this moral truth. If you show me evidence to the contrary, I'll gladly offer you my apologies. Otherwise, I stand by my original point.

Daniele1's picture

Another excellent and moving article by John Pilger.
I only wish there were more Jews who would find the truth and the courage in their heart to do what this couple does. In particular in the West where the Jewish silence on the atrocities committed by Israel, is deafening.
I also wish people of all origins, would be more prepared to ignore the abuse thrown at them and the cries of anti-semitism when they denounce the murderous state of Israel.
This accusation of anti-semitism which raises its ugly head every time Israel is criticised must be consistently challenged and debunked and no one must feel intimidated by this dishonest and pathetic defence device.

Ellen's picture

Why don't you, and your "Palestinian" friends go to schools in Gaza and other Muslim schools and share your love? What do they teach in the Palestinian schools? That everyone should live side by side? I am quite frankly sick of the Jews who are eating the Muslim propaganda. Heil Hitler to ya'all

Latest tweets