The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Continental drift

Cameron plays to the eurosceptic gallery, but where does this leave the coalition?

There's only one story in the Sunday papers this morning: Nick Clegg's"fury" (the Observer) at David Cameron's refusal on Friday to sign up to a revision to the Lisbon treaty. For the first 19 months of its existence, the coalition has managed to choreograph the tensions between its constituent parts reasonably effectively, helped, it has to be said, by the Lib Dem leader's emollience. As Marina Hyde put it in the Guardian yesterday, Clegg's instruction to his party in government appears to have been to "take bucketloads of crap and wield none of the power". But not any more, if newspaper reports are to be believed.

According to the Observer's source: "[Clegg] could not believe that Cameron hadn't tried to play for more time. A menu of choices wasn't deployed as a negotiating tool but instead was presented as a take it or leave it ultimatum. That is not how he would have played Britain's hand." Clegg is said to fear that Cameron's flounce in Brussels on Friday will leave Britain the "lonely man of Europe". This is a view echoed by one of his predecessors as leader of the Lib Dems, Paddy Ashdown. In a piece for the Observer that runs beneath the headline "We have tipped 38 years of foreign policy down the drain", Ashdown argues that Cameron succeeded merely in "isolat[ing] [Britain] from Europe and diminish[ing] ourselves in Washington":

[W]e have used the veto - but stopped nothing. In order to "protect the City" we have made it more vulnerable. At a time of economic crisis, we have made it more attractive for investors to go to northern Europe. We have tipped 38 years of British foreign policy down the drain in one night. We have handed the referendum agenda over to the Eurosceptics. We have strengthened the arguments of those who would break the union.

These latter, Ashdown argues, include not only the 81 eurosceptic Tory MPs who are now effectively "running" the prime minister, but also Alex Salmond, for whom the fiasco on Friday represents an "unconvenanted gift": "If England is to be out of Europe, why should Scotland not be in?"

What of Labour? Shadow foreign secretary Douglas Alexander gave a rather assured performance on the BBC's Andrew Marr Show this morning, arguing that the upshot for Britain of the negotiations in Brussels last week were "economically inadequate and politically disastrous". There was a deal to be made, Alexander insisted, but Cameron never wanted to make it: "This was about the politics of the Conservative Party." That's true, but Labour oughtn't to derive too much comfort from their opponent's misfortune. Andrew Marr asked, reasonably enough, what deal Britain might have made. Here Alexander was evasive, content simply to point out that there are no "legal protections" for the City of London in place today that weren't in place on Thursday.

Much the most interesting part of the interview concerned Alexander's view of the deal that was cooked up by the other European leaders, with Germany and France in the vanguard. As Owen Jones pointed out in a blog here on Friday, "François Hollande - the Socialist candidate for the French presidency - has already spoken out against a treaty cooked up by Europe's overwhelmingly right-of-centre governments," one that effectively outlaws Keynesianism. Hollande has argued that deficit reduction in Europe is a necessary but not sufficient condition of economic recovery: "Without growth, budgetary readjustment on its own will not achieve the desired results." Alexander, for his part, wondered how the "austerity package" agreed on Friday, which will work for Germany, will work for Italy or Greece. It's a good question, and one that Labour, together with its social-democratic partners in Europe, ought to pressing in the coming months.

18 comments

Dominic Lynch Of Construction's picture

I think clegg is worried about his wife's job!

Mike S's picture

When Marr pressed Clegg on whether the coalition was secure given his profound disagreement with Cameron's negotiation, Clegg insisted that there was no question of the coalition breaking up as this would have even more serious consequences for the UK. But if there is nothing that the Tories do that would lead the Lib Dems to walk away from the coalition, how can they claim to be a moderating influence on the Tories. It is ever more clear that the Tories can pretty much do whatever they like - perhaps throwing the odd crumb by way of comfort to the supine Lib Dems.

representingthemambo's picture

Just when you think Clegg couldn't even disgrace himself any more,he pulls this out of the hat.
Why didn't he oppose it at the time? Why wait until it's a done deal to break cover?
We did a brief analysis of this before Clegg started having something to say. It's still valid.

http://representingthemambo.wordpress.com/2011/12/10/the-eu-veto-the-fal...

Tesco Shelf Stacker's picture

Clegg knows which side his bread is buttered. Clever boy! ;-)

Bill's picture

How is it that China and the US can trade with the EU; they are not part of it.
Can anybody explain exactly how businesses will be prevented from trading with each other?

Lox's picture

They won't, Bill. Switzerland and Norway both thrive outside the EU.

matthew fox's picture

Switzerland is a haven for tax dodgers, and Norway had the brains to set up a Oil fund.

Mrs T was bankrolled by North Sea Oil Revenues.

Mike S's picture

"Switzerland is a haven for tax dodgers"

So is the UK - what it is to have aspirations.

Dickie1's picture

People are forgetting that what Nick Clegg says and does has a more complex relationship with reality than sub-atomic particles.

C Baker's picture

The media is hilarious. Everybody knows the lib dems must protest too much to win back the voters. The coalition will continue. Good on Clegg for doing that. He gets knocked far too often, but he is big enough to take the criticisms and keep a stable government.

Clegg and Miliband would have done everything differently. They don't know what, how when, or why, but they would have done something else. What else? well never mind that, but it would have been what ever Cameron didn't do.

Clegg could have been an MEP. He has a lovely Spanish wife. I gather he can speak quite a few languages. Why does he not choose to live in Europe then?

Ah, there lies the problem. For all their love of travelling to europe and being a well paid up member of the club, their heart lies in Britain. That's the answer. So, the coalition remains.

Tomorrow the news is that the euro project fails. America is already turning on Germany. The Swedes are not in it properly. The Polish have to decide on the Zloty or the euro. The Greeks are still broke. Scarily, Le Pen is gaining votes in France and so Sarky - goodbye, not au revoir.

Clegg is glad that Dave can take the heat off him, for promoting the sinking euro zone.

Read all about it in the newspapers of the euro zone countries and you will find, they agree with Cameron mostly. That is the people in those countries- you know the insignificant voters in a democracy. The sort of thing Mugabe hates.

matthew fox's picture

Should have know it's the media's fault, the great almighty media, who can make it snow, gives us extra bank holidays.

Clegg was MEP C Baker, fancy that, just think, instead of ranting, why not do a bit of research.

Fergus Pickering's picture

Rather like the fury of a hamster. He can bite but not a lot.

john henry's picture

As I predicted at the beginning of this ridiculous Coalition between an ideologically driven, backward looking Tory party and the opportunist Lib Dems, blood will eventually flow down Whitehall and it won't be ruthless Tory blood you can bet on that!! The Coalition is finished. They said that they are governing in the National Interest yet Cameron clearly did nothing in National Interest last Thusday evening/Friday morning in Brussels. Dodgy Dave merely acted in his and the Tory Party's interest. Dodger and his mate Boy Georgie are behaving as if they are still at public school or at an Oxford Union debate whereas in fact they are supposed to be running a country. What an utter joke!!They
are way out of their depths. They are deluded fools. Labour should call their bluff and demand a Referendum on the EU. This will finish them off.

Bill's picture

John; you are deluded.In the real world (not snout in the trough MEP Land)everybody wants out. What has the EU ever done for small business; the motor of growth?

Thomas Swedeman's picture

Norway and Switzerland have free trade agreements with the EU and have to follow most EU rules. There is little chance the UK would get such an agreement after Cameron's performance in Brussels.

Anthony's picture

The limp dick Clegg is just protecting his E.U pension and his wife's interests. Well done David and according to the first poll out today, the majority agree with him. Still vote UKIP tho !!!!

Lady J's picture

NO Bill,
everybodY does not want out. Only England does. The Tories will loose a referendum in the UK, because, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland will vote a big fat NO, to us leaving the EU.
Get IT? I guess not, because as we know, Conservatives care little for facts and reality.

Latest tweets