Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

The Lib Dem fees split widens

Lib Dem MPs threaten to resign from the government over the tuition fees rise.

Update: It now appears that Mike Crockart is not resigning after all. The word from the Lib Dems is that the mistake occurred because the wrong phone number is beside his name in a media directory. A spokesman for Crockart said: "The quotes were from a random man, not Mike. They had somebody else's number against his name. Mike is still waiting to see what the final offer will be before he votes and that has always been our line."

The fake Mike Crockart also appeared on the World At One and was quickly cut off after the show realised their mistake. All of which begs the question: is he the only Lib Dem imposter? It would explain an awful lot ...

Update: Lib Dem MP Mike Crockart has said that he will resign from his post (PPS to Michael Moore) in order to vote against tuition fees. He told the Evening Standard: "I will be voting against 100 per cent. I'm not going to be pushed out. Resigning probably will be the only option." Norman Baker and at least one other Lib Dem MP are also thought to be on the verge of resigning.

The dizzying attempt to chart the Lib Dem split on tuition fees continues. It's some measure of Nick Clegg's lack of authority that party unity has decreased, not increased, in the past 24 hours.

What looked like a three-way split has become a four-way split. After failing to reach agreement on a mass abstention, senior Lib Dem ministers including Clegg and Vince Cable will vote in favour of their own policy. They will be joined by pro-fees MPs such as David Laws and John Hemming.

A second group of ministers and backbenchers will abstain from the vote (as is their right under the coalition agreement). A third group of left-leaning MPs including the party president, Tim Farron, and the former leaders Charles Kennedy and Ming Campbell ("my credibility would be shot") will stick to their election pledge to vote against any increase in fees. A final group of backbenchers is pushing a fourth option of calling off the vote in order to allow a full public consultation to take place.

One of them, Greg Mullholland, told the Guardian: "Sometimes the most courageous thing to do is to admit you need a rethink. The best thing for higher education is not to force this vote through on Thursday." All of which looks like a feeble attempt to postpone the inevitable. There is no prospect of a substantially different package being put forward by the coalition.

Meanwhile, it's worth keeping an eye on the three Tory MPs who also signed the NUS pledge to vote against any increase in fees. After all, as recently as Michael Howard's leadership, the Conservative Party itself was opposed to the principle of tuition fees.

The Fees Three are: Ben Wallace (Wyre and Preston North), Lee Scott (Ilford North), Bob Blackman (Harrow East). Wallace has since claimed that the NUS "misinformed" people of his intentions but Scott (who is Philip Hammond's PPS) is still on record as opposing any rise in fees.

Here's a list of those Lib Dem MPs likely or certain to vote against the bill on Thursday:

1. Charles Kennedy ("I shall be voting against the coalition's proposals on university tuition fees.")

2. Ming Campbell ("My credibility would be shot to pieces if I did anything other than to stick to the promise I made.")

3. Mike Hancock ('It's a big step in the right direction but the government hasn't done enough to make me vote for it and I won't.")

4. Julian Huppert ("I made a promise to the students that I would never support a rise in tuition fees and I have reaffirmed that promise today.")

5. John Leech ("I again publicly state that I will vote against an increase in tuition fees.")

6. Ian Swales ("I can't support raising the fee cap up to £9,000 per year.")

7. John Pugh ("I will vote against any rise in tuition fees, unless a rabbit is pulled out of the hat – and there is no sign of that.")

8. Tim Farron

9. Bob Russell

10. Mark Williams

11. Simon Wright

12. Roger Williams

13. Martin Horwood

14. Greg Mullholland

Tags: tuition fees  Liberal Democrats  Nick Clegg

39 comments

CrISpY DuCk's picture

I think the Lib Dems and their Tory partners in crime will in future stick to attacking with impunity the poorly educated,the weak and the needy who are far less equipped to stand up for themselves.This along with the child benefit cuts are attacks too high up in the food chain to succeed.Significant too is that these attacks hit the journo in the pocket too ensuring longer more sustained campaign against.

zhidian2011ppp's picture

YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!

-------------- http://www.ftoto.com/ -----------

a leading worldwide wholesale company (or ucan say organization). We supply more than 100 thousand high-quality merchandise and famous brand name products all at wholesale prices.

-------------- http://www.ftoto.com/ -----------
Send Christmas Gifts. Buy more to send.

swatantra nandanwar's picture

The interesting ones to watch are Bob Russell and Sarah Tether see which way they fall. If they vote for then the Lib Dems are finished for good. Someone should open a book on it and give the proceeds to the NUS.

Lou's picture

Sarah Teather will surely vote with the Govt being a Minister of State for Education? One only has to look at her sat on the front bench, yah boo-ing at Labour with her Churchill nodding dog impression at everything Dave, George & Nick (Zippy, Bungle and George)say to see how much in awe she is of where she is and with whom. She's like a kid let rip in the Christmas department. I had a decent opinion of her before but my opinion has done an about turn almost as quickly as the volte face she did.

Bob Russell has said in October and November that he will fight against tuition fees.

ang's picture

Very well put Nick.
I just wonder, if this were the Labour party, fighting among themselves, the Tory press would be hammering them by now. Truth is, if the Lib dems pull out, it damages the Tories and this 'would be terrible for the country'. I don't think so, it's this dangerous coalition that is ruining our country. We need a general election now!

ang's picture

It will be political suicide for the Lib dems, if they do anything other than oppose the rise in tuition fees.
Don't they see that this is an appalling assault on the future generations of our country, our economy benefits greatly from having an educated workforce.
I find it so patronising when I hear Willets saying that the people need to look at the proposal again because we don't seem to have explained it properly. Well we have looked at the proposal and we don't think it's fair, along with the 80% cut to university funding, scrapping of EMA, the rise in travel expenses, VAT rise,etc.
The young people of England know that they don't deserve to be blamed, for a global economic recession, by a bunch of Tory chancers, whose dream is to destroy the state.
It's not just the students who are angry about this, it's also the schoolkids and their parents and grandparents and that will be a large chunk of the population, who will not vote for the Lib dems come 2015.
Think again!

ang's picture

Sarah Teather is a Tory through and through. It is so obvious that she hates Labour and was seen to mouth the word 'Bollocks' to the opposition, a couple of weeks ago in the commons, it was a real 'spitting venom' moment.
I really don't know how the likes of her, can call herself a Lib dem.

ang's picture

It seems they have all been threatened with the sack if they don't vote for the rise.
Danny Alexander said that he is looking forward to voting tomorrow. God someone should punch him in his arrogant little face!

Lou's picture

The four way split, the latest sweetener regarding the poorest students fees being waived if they qualify for free school meals shows the ill thought out, shambolic even, policy.

I know people who don't get free school meals because they are one pound above the cut off point for eligibility - can it be fair that someone only a pound better off but still amongst the poorest will not get their fees waived?

Anonymous's picture

Every LibDem who votes in favour of a rise in fees should be tried for treason.

They have betrayed the people they are supposed to represent. They should be held accountable for their actions.

yuccuplant's picture

Have to agree with Lou its beginning to look like policy on the fly,made up on the back of fag packets in the commons bar.

What a shambles.

KS's picture

Martin Horwood (MP for Cheltenham) should be on that list as well.

yuccuplant's picture

Oh and on my last say on this matter the list of libdem mps who will vote against will get ever shorter as vote draws near,by the end it'll be down to 2 or 3 at most.

Cosmic  Elms's picture

Yay!! Liberals to IMPLODE!!
CONSERVATIVES NEXT ON WISHLIST!!
BRING ON THE 9TH DEC

YAAAAAY!!!

swatantra nandanwar's picture

Sarah Tether is the spitting image of Queen Victoria and should have a comfortable job as her lookalike when she leaves the Commons at the next GE. 2 minor Lib Dem aides to MPs have discovered a conscience and said they will vote against.

Amanda's picture

I wonder how my local mp Jenny Wilcott will vote, she has a lot of students who voted for her

Jamie1's picture

We could save this whole tuition fees malarky by cutting funding to stupid degrees, making it harder to get into universities in this first place! Once we've got rid of the 'BBC' candidates with their Social Policy and Media Studies degrees out of the system, we could probably afford to increase funding and have no tuition fees at all!

Union Steve's picture

Mr Pledge's judgment and years of experience at ministerial level are paying dividends again.
Mr Posh looks to be having a touch of the John Major's. Well you can't keep the bastards down!

maxinemf's picture

Paddy Ashdown's statement that students are not listening, misses the point. Students understand and lsiten to every word that Nick Clegg says; they just do not happen to agree with him. How the coalition government can think that tokenistic gestures on a scholarship fund will assuage student concerns, shows that the coalition do not understand what students want. The government too is just not listening to the general public or to Liberal Democrat MP's.

The Manchester Student Occupation's picture

We've heard that Jenny Willott will also be voting against the proposals, which would require her to resign her position as well.

Although we're also hearing on Twitter that Mike Crockart's declaration here was a hoax by an impersonator... any more news on that?

We're very pleased to see some of the statements on this article in support of the students and this occupation sends love, rage and solidarity out to everyone involved.

A Brown's picture

Pleased Mike Crockart is voting against it, he was the one I was most concerned about living in Edinburgh

Hopefully the West Lothian Question will now be reopened as Danny Alexander is clearly damned whatever he does.

Union Steve's picture

David Miliband lost. The rank and file of the party have accepted this.
New Labour days are history. Gordon Brown has gone. These are facts why don't peple just get it and get over it. The king is dead long live the king!!!

Lou's picture

The Manchester Student Occupation,

With you in spirit. Keep up the fantastic work, keep raging against the machine that is this Government.

Joanne Tisdall's picture

I lived in Sarah Teathers constituency for ten years, moving just after the election. Then it felt like the dimunitive one was round every day, knocking up her vote. Her silence is now deafening. It would be great if people could join me in keep writing to her about her position on tuition fees, opposition to which was the subject of her maiden speech. How as Childrens Minister she can watch 13 and 14 year olds from her own consituency demonstrating on the streets I don't know. But happily they will be able old enough to vote her out next time.

kenny jenkins's picture

In fact, all LibDem MPs have said, in writing, as part of their election campaigns, that they will vote against any attempt to raise fees in this parliament. They were elected on that basis. If they vote in favour of raising fees they are no longer legitimately Members of parliament.

ang's picture

Maybe they should all vote against, then resign, then there will be a general election, which everyone wants anyhow!

Amanda's picture

Lib Dems owe it to their core vote- hundreds of students to vote against the rise in tution fees. They cannot justify anything else and will surely be absolutely mashed at the next election. If it takes Ministers to resign so be it, they would be and look stronger and couragious that way. I can vote next year but with the Lib Dems current performance, I'm unsure if Ill be voting for them come 2015. As for EMA cuts without EMA I would not be able to go and study the Alevels of my choice at the college of my choice. I don't wish this to be taken away from anyone. The coalitons policies on education are flawed. Higher education benefits the whole economy and should be provided free. Labour can critise the government but which fuckers introduced tution fees! Labour have created the stepping stones for the Tories to walk over. I'm fast losing faith in our political system.

Sir Bufton Tufton's picture

Don't worry Lib Dems, Paddy Ashdown says we will "hold together"( by voting in 4 different ways).

Hugh Markey's picture

Hair shirts - fergit it! All that sub-text on T-shirts promoting the Secretary of State for Culture & Ragbags. Back burner.
Latest LibDem scam. A little masochistic, maybe. Apology T-Shirts. Yes, shirts!! It was a little like women fighting over remnants at a sale.
Nick grabbed the top with the text 'I'm Sorry!' - 'I'm Sorry!' - 'I'm Sorry!' on the torso.
Vince was stuck with the T-shirt advertising it's wearer's excuse - "It's All My Fault!"
Timmy Farron's T-Shirt proclaimed 'You're Right, I'm Wrong as Usual!'
On the back of Nick's T-Shirt the instruction: ' Dave, please kick me!'
Vince's begged: "Please Dave, Kick me hard!
Timmy's implored: ' Please, please Dave, Kick me harder still.'
These public school hijinks! Daft! And dangerous! Could upset the old grey matter.
By the way, has Danny Alexander been toning down the Titian locks by any chance. Danny ran a 'fun fair' you know. He has the experience.
What Larks

jeremiah's picture

I support students paying a part of their university education.

However for the Lib Dems to sign a pledge with massive publicity opposing tuition fees and then support a large rise in them is a disgrace.

The Lib Dems who maintain the pledge should of course be highlighted but those MPs who break it should be shamed and called out for their betrayal.

matthew fox's picture

I think that disaffected Lib Dems, who will not join Labour, should consider joining the Liberal Party.

Nick's picture

Whatever happened to politicians with a mind of their own? they should vote for or against; according to their beliefs. I'm sick and tired of hearing Liberals saying it's different because they are in a coalition. A coalition is built upon a compromise of the individual party values; values which reflect those spouted prior to the election. Any party which changes its beliefs just to suit its bigger counterpart is betraying its principles and demolishing democracy by virtue of people no longer standing up for what they believe in. The reason we have so many MP's is because they are there to represent those that voted for them in their constituencies, something all politicians seem to have forgotten.

This coalition is an absolute sham and has become dangerous rather than stable.

yuccuplant's picture

They wont do it,power is nice and i know its near Christmas time but i don't see to many turkeys in asda that would have voted to be there same goes for the libdems.

Nick9's picture

Ang: Hate to say it but much as I'm a staunch Labour supporter, we really need to up the anti if we are to get this lot out before 2015. People are definitely falling out of love with the coalition at a rapid rate of knots but they are not seeing an alternative in Labour.

I can see some logic in Ed M 'thinking things through' but people want alternatives now, Labour should be much more on the attack, they've got loads of ammunition but no canons to fire at the moment. Labour can work on longer term policy review as well as go on the attack. People are getting angry that there is no opposition. I loathe the idea of this lot going until 2015 and I want to hear far more from Labour now, not in 2015 when frankly it will be too late. I was all for giving Ed M a chance but I'm not impressed at all. I can't help but feel David M would have got the upper hand by now. Come on Ed, pull your finger out!

Abbas's picture

I''m a student at the University of Westminster and am studying for a BA in Arabic and English Language. I chose to study these languages for personal fulfilment and job security. I have four years experience of teaching English as a foreign language. Consequently, I have a genuine interest in my degree and the various modules that I study. My concern is therefore not just passing the next exam but also to better understand the languages that I am studying. Unfortunately, many students seemed to be studying for a degree merely for the sake of having a degree which would perhaps be fine except for the fact that they seem to have no or little interest in the subjects they have selected. Furthermore, I've heard students say 'the degree is heavily subsidised so what the hell, right? Only my travel expenses to take care of". Anyway, I am all for the raising tuition fees. Doesn't affect me so that is probably why!

Abbas's picture

Sorry that should read '...little or no interest...'

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets