Christianity and homosexuality

In the third of our series on faith and homosexuality, we take a look at how Christians continue to

It is never a simple thing to write about faith and homosexuality from a Christian perspective because there is no one Christian perspective. The acceptance or otherwise of homosexuality as a valid expression of human sexuality differs according to the view of the different denominations and even within those denominations, groups and individuals may hold opposing beliefs. Even when people share a belief on homosexuality, how individuals should be treated and what the response of the Church should be to those claiming a homosexual orientation may not be shared.

Many denominations now accept that homosexuality is not simply a lifestyle choice and therefore advocate acceptance and pastoral care towards gay men and lesbians. However, this is usually only as long as they don’t ‘practice’ their homosexuality. In other words, it’s okay to be a homosexual but not to express your love physically or sexually with the person you love. This is quite ironic when most Christian denominations believe that celibacy is a higher state that not many are called to and yet they expect all gay men and lesbians to live their lives in this way.

At the Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement we believe that all sexuality is a gift from God and therefore the expression of our sexuality in loving, mutual same gender relationships is just as honourable and blessed by God as are loving, mutual heterosexual relationships.

The Biblical debate rests on 6 verses, 3 in the Old Testament and 3 in the New Testament, but many scholars have shown clearly that these texts are not referring to the type of relationship we label as homosexual today. In fact, some of the verses aren’t even referring to sexual relationships at all but concern the Jewish laws of hospitality.

The fact is that the debate on homosexuality will never be resolved by reference to Scripture alone as both sides of the argument can use Scripture to support their particular viewpoint in the same way as it can and has been done on many other issues over the years, such as, the treatment and acceptance of women, children, and ethnic minorities.

We are told that to be a Christian all we need to do is accept Jesus as God’s son and proclaim him with our lips. Naturally, when a person does this then they try to follow Christ’s teachings. As Christ never said anything about homosexuality we have to look at how he treated people and how he expected us to treat each other. Christ welcomed people from the margins, people who had been excluded and rejected by mainstream society. However, when he called these people he didn’t then say they had to start behaving like the Pharisees and Sadducees. All he asked for was that we treat each other with love as he loved us. Confirmation of his acceptance of loving relationships regardless of the gender of those involved is the story of the healing of the Centurions servant. Christ had no hesitation in healing the male servant even though the Centurion referred to him as his beloved. The servant certainly must have been greatly loved for a Roman soldier to beg a Jewish teacher for help, especially as servants were generally valued no more than any other possession.

I have had a personal relationship with Christ ever since I can remember. When I realised my sexual orientation, the love I felt both for and from God didn’t change. God is concerned about the quality of my relationships, not the gender of who they’re with. Unfortunately, a lot of lesbians and gay men encounter so much homophobia and discrimination within their Church that they start believing that God can’t love them as they are.

It’s no good telling someone that you ‘hate the sin but love the sinner’ when the sin you’re referring to is integral to who they are. It’s like telling someone that you understand that they can’t help being born with blue eyes so it’s okay as long they don’t look out of them!

What is even more distressing is that the religious view on homosexuality often informs the implementation of laws. Consequently there are still far too many countries where homosexuality is not just considered a sin but is also illegal and punishable with life imprisonment and even the death penalty. This treatment is often justified by religious beliefs. The Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement continues to campaign against such laws and against any form of homophobia within faith.

Rev Sharon Ferguson is the Chief Executive of the Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement that will be holding their second conference on Faith, Homophobia, Transphobia, and Human Rights on Saturday 16th May, to raise awareness around these issues. For more information and booking form go to Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement

5 comments

zinoviev's picture

The two posts, above, chime very clearly with me. I too
think the bible is a work of fiction, written, I would add,
to keep the masses in their place. Likewise, I cannot
understand why people, gay or straight, identify as
Christians or republicans (in the U.S. political sense).
But the fact of the matter is that people, gay and
straight, do take the bible and their religious faith
seriously and people do identify as Christians and
republicans. It seems to me therefore that Christians
and republicans are more likely to be persuaded that
gay people are little different to straight people if the
message comes from a Christian or a republican.

So, Sharon Ferguson, I find it hard to comprehend
how you have come to hold your religious beliefs but I
wish you well with your "campaign against such laws
and against any form of homophobia within faith" and
with your conference on 16 May. The message about
being born with blue eyes is a powerful one.

lostforyou's picture

When you say that society should "get over" the bible,
you are, rather strikingly, asking millions of Christians
and Jews—and to a certain extent, some Muslims—to
forsake a sacred text that has been at the heart of their
heritage for thousands of years. Even apart from the
debate on homosexuality and religion, that is an
absurd suggestion. And frankly, it is going to happen.
Christianity and Judaism will always go back to their
sacred texts to engage serious issues such as this
and others.

Regarding the bible, you are seriously misleading,
especially your remark about the "Modern Scientific
Theory of Evolution" disproving the bible as a work of
fiction. I assume you are referring to Genesis 1–2
here, two chapters of thousands in the bible. Whilst
some interpreters take these chapters as a literal
description of the creation of the cosmos, the reality is
that they are, and always were, works of creative
prose. So yes, they are "fiction" in a sense. So if
modern scientific theories prove that, well good
(though I'm not sure how it really disproves anything
since scientific analysis can only disprove scientific
hypotheses). In my opinion, nothing in the Genesis
text, properly understood, excludes the possibility of
evolution.

Shanfox's picture

Because somefoolish people believe the harsh judgement of Gays and Lesbians is authentic Christianity is no reason for the victims of this false doctrine to condemn us all. The central core of Chrisy's message (much distorted) is love of all: poor, rich, men women fortunate and unfortunate, gay or straight - all humans are welcome into the fold. The doctrinaire American evengelists are false Chritians: they introduce hatred and that is unChristian. Pray and be welcome to the joy of faith.

tomsj's picture

A gay christian, it strikes me, is as improbable as a gay republican. Both republicans and christians hate us as passionately as George Wallace and Jim Crow hated Martin Luther King. This "love the sinner hate the sin" credo is so patently absurd as to be laughable. And articles such as this, that purport to weigh the issues carefully and soberly, lead me to peals of laughter. Jesus hates me, this I know, 'cause my pastor told me so.

Euphobia1's picture

Oh dear! To have to publish this article in this day and age!

The bible is a work of fiction! I know this may annoy some of your readers but it is!

My advise to any homosexual or lesbian is to forget about religion and enjoy yourself free from any guilt.

The Modern Scientific Theory of Evolution proves the bible is a work of fiction so why worry about a bad tempered god who doesn't exist!

Society has got to get over the bible. Thanks to Darwin we should all be able to enjoy life free from religious persecution, prejudice, and hate and enjoy our own personal sexual orientation without fear of censure.

Latest tweets