Rowenna Davis

Because politics happens beyond Westminster

Syndicate contentRSS

Meet the Tories the left should be frightened of

Luckily for Ed Miliband, the Conservative Party is unlikely to listen to the Tories with One Nation vision.

Balloons featuring images of Chancellor of the exchequer George Osborne
Balloons featuring images of Chancellor of the exchequer George Osborne hang near the conference centre. Photograph: Getty Images

I’ve just woken up after a trip to the Conservative Party conference in Birmingham. As a Labour councillor, I was something of an intruder. I went a little red at the hotel reception, mumbling apologetically that I wasn’t “actually a Tory” and feeling shell shocked at the huge numbers of powerful looking men in corporate suits. But as it turned out, one group of Conservatives were far frightening than any other. These are the "nice guys", and they pose a serious electoral threat to Labour.

This group is not a formal alliance, but they are all critical of economic liberalism. They are prepared to challenge the market when it isn’t working for people, and they have a genuine concern for the poor. They are socially conservative, and believe in family, community and tradition. They admit that 1979 brought problems as well as benefits. They are sceptical of big business wielding too much power and stick up for strivers, whether they work in the public or private sector. They believe there is such thing as society. They are, in essence, One Nation Tories.

One man I had barely heard of before the conference actually took my breath away. Guy Opperman, Conservative MP for Hexham, stood up and made a passionate call for apprenticeships, action on low wages, protection for the poor and local banking. He gave up his summer to walk from Sheffield to Scotland, talking to people about why his party was failing in the north, and his speech was clearly rooted in their concerns.  I thought woah, if that’s where the Tories are heading, Ed Miliband is going to be left without any clothes.

Jesse Norman MP, a gentle giant who is respected from all sides of the party, is better known for this position. I listened to him explain that growth – even if it does return – is not enough if it only benefits the top. He might not sign up to a living wage, but he does want to challenge corporate governance structures to make a difference. Shaun Bailey, former candidate for Hammersmith, agreed with him. In separate sessions MPs Gavin Barwell and Kris Hopkins warned about “kicking public sector workers” and expressed serious concerns that their party was not perceived to be on side with fireman and doctors. Outside parliament, ConservativeHome founder Tim Montgomerie and funder Lord Ashcroft are fighting to build a party that speaks to blue collar workers as well as white collar corporates.

The good news for Labour is that this half of the party isn’t likely to get anywhere any time soon. Economic liberals like George Osborne and John Redwood are detatched from the concerns of the country. They are to the right of the Daily Mail because they still favour the rich guy over the small guy. They believe they will be able to win over working class and inner city areas because they are in line with the polls on welfare, crime and immigration. But they need a positive vision for the country as well as a negative one. They need to speak about what they love as well as hate, what they will give as well as take. When they refuse to challenge the market or use the state, that’s very hard to do. The polling from working class, northern and inner city areas shows that they simply aren’t cutting through. 


“Losing the centre ground is our biggest threat,” says one young Conservative sitting with a group of friends in Carluccio's just outside the conference centre. “The right wingers just think we need to carry on the same way, offer a referendum on Europe and add in some stuff on strugglers and strivers and we’ll be fine.”

“People think we didn’t win (a majority) because we weren’t right wing enough,” his friend chips in, “It’s genuine. Honestly. Do they have no brain?”

If the Tories want to win in 2015, they’ll have to listen to these voices. Returning to growth is not enough if the benefits are only felt by a small number at the top. They will need to steal back the One Nation vision, and that means promoting their nicer half. Such a move would unsettle the left. Luckily for Ed Miliband, that's very unlikely. Economic liberalism still rules the Conservative party, Osborne continues unchallenged, and the centre ground is slowly slipping away.

22 comments

newsitewon'tacceptname's picture

They are exactly who Ed needs to be scared of, or join.

Eddy S's picture

the bottom line is that all parties are by and large on the centre and that is where they want to occupy the ground for the 2015 election.

bill23's picture

No matter what they say, their words will only turn into deeds if the Freemasons approve it. The whole of the south coast is run by these people and Osborne is trying to deflect blame when he talkes about scroungers. At least these are honest scroungers, unlike the thousands of non-job civil servants who continue to dream up pointless schemes. In Lyme Regis - and I suspect many towns and villages - they have a 'Trust' which has never done anthing and is duplicated in effect by the Local Plan. The Trust does however employ self-replicating bureaucrats, and has visits, and visits to, other self-replicating parasitic bureaucrats. Now that we have the example of Greece, we should rip up the contracts of these non-job parasites before they do any more damage.

Fluclox's picture

Interesting article. All the more for the little revelation about
rightward drift. That there are Tories who see that such a thing
would be suicide, is interesting.

Martin Yuille's picture

"The good news for Labour is that this (one-nation) half of the party isn’t likely to get anywhere any time soon. "

Wrong, Rowenna. Nothing would be better for Britain. Nothing would be better for Labour than the Tories ditching the neo-liberals from leadership. It would mean politics was on the common ground rather than around it. The fundamentalists of both parties would be pushed onto the rough ground. Labour would be stronger. The Conservatives would either go into their death throes or join the 21st century.

Posh Tosh's picture

It's the new Blue Condom.

Full of puntgent half life gas.

Do not inflate it, it is harmful to life and the only cure is a referendum on Europe before the election coming soon.

LabourMan's picture

I would like to see some of these One Nation Tories join us. Hopefully Phillip Blond will come on board.

LabourMan's picture

I would like to see some of these One Nation Tories join us. Hopefully Phillip Blond will come on board.

NJ's picture

What power does John Redwood have?

Herbert's picture

He has the power to sing. In Welsh. As we all remember. The man is a twerp. In the 1980s women sitting on trains between Richmond and London used to complain to the guard about his staring eyes.

Norman Goldner's picture

the only political party that will win in 2015 is the one that embraces the centre ground, so at the moment it is impossible to call

you cannot win an election from either the far left or the far right

Dark Heart of Toryland's picture

And which party do you imagine is trying to win an elction from the 'far left'? Despite the laughable 'Red Ed' tag, Labour (sorry, should that have been One Nation Labour'?) are hardly hardline radicals. Not even the Greens could be described as 'far left' - unless 'left' is simply a catch-all term for anyone who has intimated the slightest doubt about the neoliberal consensus - a consensus which somehow seems to have managed to survive the catastrophic failure of neoliberalism.

The Corinthian's picture

In the past week Disraeli has been rebranded a dangerous Marxist. Like Keynes. And Eisenhower.

Hugh Jardon's picture

oh and the loony left are a better proposition are they ? These are the ones who sold half our gold on the rock bottom lows (even announcing the sale two months before they sold an ounce in the name of transparency to get an even worse return for the taxpayer) to pay for all their welfare handouts.
No more boom and bust - yes thansk Gordo and Tony B Liar - you couldnt run a bath let alone an economy.

Not saying Tories are the saviour, but out of an awful bunch there is not a hope in hell Id ever want that bunch of idiots running this economy ever again. Last time they left the economy in 1979 it was in a total mess too.

Monkeys could have done a better job - sooner you lot realise the better.

stevem1940's picture

In 1964 and agin in 1974 the Tories bequeathed Labour an economy in ruins. In 1979 the Tories inherited an economythat was recovering from massive inflation caused by the quadrupling of the oil price. and the Barber dash for growth. Unemployment was falling and inflation was down to single figures. We still had a surplus in manufactures.What followed was3 million unemployed, manufacturing was emasculated,child poverty doubled and we saw beggars on the streets. Growth was no better than it had been in the decade before. After 18 years of Tory rule unemployment was still over 2 million. You call that success? The Tories are still the party of unemployment and they refuse to blame their friends in the banks for the disaster we find ourselves in.

Hugh Jardon's picture

I never said the tories were the saviours if you read above - I simply said out of a simply pathetic lot all I know is that Id never ever let the loony left have the keys to the economy again if I had any say in it.

stevem1940's picture

In 1964 and agin in 1974 the Tories bequeathed Labour an economy in ruins. In 1979 the Tories inherited an economythat was recovering from massive inflation caused by the quadrupling of the oil price. and the Barber dash for growth. Unemployment was falling and inflation was down to single figures. We still had a surplus in manufactures.What followed was3 million unemployed, manufacturing was emasculated,child poverty doubled and we saw beggars on the streets. Growth was no better than it had been in the decade before. After 18 years of Tory rule unemployment was still over 2 million. You call that success? The Tories are still the party of unemployment and they refuse to blame their friends in the banks for the disaster we find ourselves in.

The Corinthian's picture

Goldbuggery: the economic equivalent of mental illness.

Dark Heart of Toryland's picture

Well, it certainly looks like the Tories have taken your advice, and put monkeys in charge of the government.

christof_ff's picture

Spot on - there's a generation of uber-Thatcherite bankers and hedge-fund managers within the latest intake of MPs who are so detached from reality that they blame Cameron's 'liberalism' for their lack of an overall majority. The saner side of the party is drowned out by them.

Ultra_Fox's picture

Don't be fooled by these so-called "nice guys". Cameron himself spouted similar rhetoric for years while he was in opposition. Remember the "hug a hoodie" stunt?

The attacks on employment rights, abortion and the poor during recent days show the party is lurching violently to the right. Whether it can carry the country, or even the Lib Dems, with them remains to be seen.

Hugh C Markey's picture

Buffoon Boris is even more right-wing than Cameron and his Mr Hyde - George Osborne. Yet Boris manages to get voters to take the medicine. What a rib-tickler!
If he can duck confrontations with big Media beasts Boris may be the man. If he can't - curtains!
Most of our group worked in the public or quasi-public domain. The majority of our superiors and quite a lot of colleagues were conservative with a hard 'C'. The remainder could have been conservative with a soft 'c' but they kept their opinions to themselves.
This kind of mix also seems to be pretty prevalent in the armaments and aircraft manufacturers industry.
The Tories seem to have a death wish because the private sector does not pay well where it doesn't have to. And pensions and leave are poor.

Hard Task Master/Mistress

Latest tweets