Rowenna Davis

Because politics happens beyond Westminster

Syndicate contentRSS

What became of Blue Labour?

A year later, there's barely a sight of the buzzword. But its ideas live on, writes Rowenna Davis.

A ferry sails past the Port of Dover
A ferry sails past the Port of Dover, site of some very Blue Labourish goings-on. Photograph: Getty Images

Whatever happened to Blue Labour? Last year I wrote a book about a term that was causing political circles to chatter . Now the name has almost dropped out of existence. Its founder, Lord Maurice Glasman, has effectively been under house arrest in the second chamber after a string of controversial outbursts, the latest on this website. But one year on, Blue Labour is still the rising philosophy of Ed Miliband’s party. The players, the relationships and the policies are having an effect. The name might not be there, but the influence is.

Ed Miliband’s conference speech is set to focus on “predistribution”. Although the term is diabolically policy-wonkish, the concept is spot on. The starting position of Blue Labour is that previous governments were too hands off with the market and too hands on with the state. Predistribution wants us to change that balance. If you force employers to pay the living wage for example, then you don’t have to worry about correcting in work poverty through tax credits. This is central to Blue Labour’s call on the party to value hard work and reduce dependency, and it’s supported by shadow minister Rachel Reeves in a new Fabian pamphlet outlining Miliband’s ideas.

Ed Miliband’s “responsible capitalism” is underpinned by this philosophy. Take the leader’s emphasis on energy companies. If we split up this oligopolistic market and force the companies to compete, we would encourage them to suck out less in profit and dedicate more revenue to improving their offer to customers. Crucially, that means there would be less demand for winter fuel allowance. Similarly, demanding workers’ representation on the boards of companies would give them the chance to challenge fat cat salaries, and call for more profits to be given in wages. Improving vocational education is another way of increasing wages without relying on state redistribution. In economic terms, it’s developing a supply side policy for the left. To your average voter, it’s a way of making a real difference to people’s lives without spending huge amounts of money.

It’s true to say that Glasman is not as close to Ed Miliband as he once was, but he remains tight with people who are. Lord Stewart Wood is a big fan of Germany’s model of worker representation and vocational education, and Marc Stears, one of Ed Miliband’s best friends from university, is working at the heart of the leader’s office. They are both longstanding friends of Glasman.

Meanwhile, Jon Cruddas MP has been chosen to lead Labour’s policy review. Cruddas has been one of the biggest fans of Blue Labour in the parliamentary party (not that this says much) and his close friend Jonathan Rutherford is very close with Glasman. Ed Miliband knew that when he made the appointment. Cruddas is already showing his Blue streak, particularly his call for a referendum on EU membership. We can also expect to see calls for a decentralisation of the state, and a focus on what kind of society we want to build together, rather than an obsession with what processes we want to get there. The conference slogan championed by Cruddas – “Rebuilding Britain” – came from Glasman before anyone else.

The third area where Blue Labour is influencing the party is less well known, but still highly important. A new man has come to work in Ed Milband’s team, focusing on party organisation. Arnie Graf has come from the United States with a long track record of community organising, which Glasman has always admired. Older and wiser than your frantic special adviser stereotype, his gentle but strong manner has won round people from surprising quarters in the party, and last year he was given permission to conduct a root and branch review of its organisation. His report was never published, but he called on the party to open up, raising the possibility of open primaries and less top down control from London. Now he’s taking leave from his work in the US to continue here, and he remains something of a trusted elder to the Labour leader. Few know that it was Glasman who first convinced Graf to come over from the US, and that he was personally responsible for introducing him to the Labour leader.

Whilst all this is happening, Lord Glasman is not sitting still or acting alone. Out of the media spotlight he’s beavering away, building alliances and making new friends. This summer a big conference was held on the “Common Good” – members of the green movement and women’s groups were there alongside MPs and faith groups to discuss how to take the agenda forward. Glasman is also forming links with unions, particularly those representing the private sector, about how they can work together. If that wasn’t enough, he’s also working with the people of Dover to stop the privatisation of their port. A perfect campaign for Blue Labour, it’s about reengaging with the South, supporting private sector workers and mutual ownership. The relationships, the policies, the players – there’s a lot going on. It might not be called Blue Labour, but a rose by another other name…

3 comments

redmary2's picture

Stuff Blue Labour, New Labour, Can we have socialist Labour please,? or is socialist a dirty word in the New/Blue Labour party,? I'm sick of Blue/Yellow/red Tories, Get back to supporting working class people, ( you know the ones that vote you in) stop the attacks on disabled people by ATOS, and give us a Labour party worth voting for,

MarkHoubrook's picture

Blue Labour is a smokescreen for abstract pluralism. The Labour Party is now more plural than the society it wishes to change.

We have New Labour, Old Labour, Purple Labour, Blue Labour,Real Labour and just plain Labour. This simply will not do.

Conflicts and antagonism still appear at the heart of One Nation Labour. The perception is that we are holding it together but the reality is Blairite factions are further fragmenting the party and destroying the good work of the grassroot activist and labour supporters. Ed Miliband needs to replace Cuckoos in his shadow cabinet before they are strong enough to replace him. This is REAL.

It is clear that Jon Cruddas in his intellectual attempt to frame a modern labour thought appears to be creating instability and hostility at the heart of the labour machine. Is Cruddas a social democrat or a democratic socialist? Is the intention to confuse the working class?

Throughout the last 112 years Tory rule has been helped along by the internal disagreements caused by evolutionists, revisionists and revolutionists with the Labour Party. The Fabian movement played its part well in steering Labour away from catastrophe in early part of last century. Then of course we had the Bevanites (democratic socialists) and Gaitskell (social democrats), then Crosland, Bennites, Militant, Blairites and Brownites etc.

The longer labour left wingers are in opposition the more hostile to social democracy they become. Ed Miliband has so far avoided the inevitable.

One Nation is simply Ed Miliband's modern version of "The Future of Socialism"

Forget Progress, Compass and Blue Labour rhetoric the future is in a renewed social democracy where capitalism is controlled , economic growth is championed by liberal economic management.

Somebody once said "With growth there could be fairer distribution and wealth to the less well off through higher wages, social welfare and better education without taking anything from the better off" (middle classes) Is this the One Nation formula to success?

"ENCOURAGE GROWTH AND LEVEL UP"

Funny Anthony Crosland also believed in Comprehensive Education.

Who is advising the Labour Party now?

Davidaslindsay's picture

“David Lindsay has generated a brilliant reconciliation of the conflicting strains of the Labour Tradition and is worthy of the closest attention.” Dr Maurice Glasman, Lord Glasman of Stoke Newington and Stamford Hill; Senior Lecturer in Political Theory and Director of the Faith and Citizenship Programme, London Metropolitan University; founder of Blue Labour.

“This book is well researched, is full of facts and deals with contemporary and historical political and social issues. It comes from the left but it should also appeal to those who are concerned with and interested in the great issues and how they are dealt with by our political and other institutions. It is well worth reading.” David Stoddart, Lord Stoddart of Swindon; Labour MP for Swindon, 1970-1983; Government Whip, 1975-1978.

“Current orthodoxy – both in economic policy and right across the board – has so manifestly failed us that we desperately need some fresh thinking and a different way of looking at our problems. That is precisely what David Lindsay provides in this stimulating book.” Professor Bryan Gould, Labour MP for Southampton Test, 1974-1979; Labour MP for Dagenham, 1983-1994; Shadow Cabinet Member, 1986-1994; Leadership Candidate, 1992.

“Before Red Tory and Blue Labour there was David Lindsay. He was arguably the first to announce a postliberal politics of paradox, and to delve into the deep, unwritten British past in order to craft, theoretically, an alternative British and international future. It is high time that the singular and yet wholly pertinent writings of this County Durham Catholic Labour prophet receive a wider circulation.” Professor John Milbank, Professor in Religion, Politics and Ethics, University of Nottingham.

The book in question is my Confessions of an Old Labour High Tory, which is available from lulu. Ignore any hostile comments on there or on Amazaon; such comments are by a former student of mine who has mental health problems and who is known to the Police for harassment.

Latest tweets