Reviewing politics
and culture since 1913

The Staggers

The latest comment and analysis from our writers

8 April 2025

Can the White House stomach this trade war?

Trump allies Elon Musk and Bill Ackman have turned on the president's tariffs.

By Freddie Hayward

The question every finance minister, factory owner, stockbroker and person who uses money to buy stuff is trying to answer is whether Donald Trump’s tariffs are permanent. Will he back down on his huge wave of tariffs once other countries drop their own tariffs on American products? Or is protectionism the point? Team Trump itself does not seem to know. Each day more loyalists start to sound as if they hope the president is lying but fear he is being honest. Advisers look scattered during interviews trying to explain the strategy behind these tariffs. As markets crash, the treasury secretary Scott Bessent has spent a week evading questions with the nonchalance of someone who has not been the treasury secretary during ...

4 April 2025

What Donald Trump gets right about the Canadian border

It is an arbitrary line. He’s wrong to think that’s unusual.

By Jonn Elledge

A few weeks ago, a reporter asked President Donald Trump whether he was still going to impose tariffs on Canada. A simple “yes” would have sufficed, and been terrifying enough; but Trump being Trump, that question was enough to inspire a long and rambling answer which strongly implied that Canada was not actually a real country at all. His response brought to mind Vladimir Putin’s ominous 2021 essay, “On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukraine”. The bit that jumped out at me, though, was this: “If you look at a map, they drew an artificial line right through it, between Canada and the US, just a straight artificial line. Somebody did it a long time ago, many, many decades ago.” In ...

4 April 2025

The Scottish Greens are lost in the new world

Patrick Harvie’s resignation as co-leader marks the fall of Scotland’s king of woke.

By Chris Deerin

It’s a long time since the Scottish left found its home amid the clangs, sparks and shouts of the nation’s ship and steelyards. In today’s economy of professions and services, of university graduates and the technological juggernaut, leftism has become a middle-class pursuit. It is, largely, a hobby of the urban sophisticate, more likely to inhabit a spacious Glasgow tenement than a modest council house, whose hands remain wholly uncalloused. Eye strain is the greatest risk posed by their day job. But the high-water mark of this modern caste has also passed. It encapsulated a decade that took in the independence referendum, with its exultant gatherings and angry slogans; the Jeremy Corbyn years where, for the briefest of periods, it seemed ...

3 April 2025

The UK isn’t a winner from Trump’s tariffs

“America First” will always mean Britain second – at very best.

By George Eaton

It was both predictable and predicted. Donald Trump, a politician often defined by his unpredictability, is on some questions almost maddeningly consistent. Trade policy is one of them.  “Liberation Day” wasn’t months or years in the making but decades. It was in 1987, as Trump first pondered a bid for the presidency, that he published an open letter in the New York Times, the Washington Post and the Boston Globe. “To The American People,” it opened portentously. “For decades, Japan and other nations have been taking advantage of the United States.”  Trump proceeded to argue that tariffs would allow his country to “end our huge deficits, reduce our taxes, and let America’s economy grow unencumbered by the cost of defending those who ...

1 April 2025

Don’t blame the OBR for Britain’s economic woes

We can’t spend more without taxing more and we can’t tax less without spending less.

By David Gauke

It is all the Office for Budget Responsibility’s fault. This, plus Rachel Reeves’ rigid fiscal rules, has become the fashionable explanation for our economic travails. Were it not for these, it is argued, the government would not be announcing painful welfare cuts and could be investing in the future. For the most part, it is an argument advanced by the political left, but by no means exclusively. There are those on the right who are sceptical of a George Osborne-era institution and who bemoan the self-imposed constraints on government policy. Not least among those critics is Liz Truss, which should give others pause for thought. The cause of the recent criticism of the OBR is that its judgements on economic growth, and ...

31 March 2025

The Lib Dems should terrify the Tories

Ed Davey’s bid to take political ownership of Middle England represents an existential threat.

By George Eaton

A decade ago, the Liberal Democrats fell victim to the “black widow strategy”. Having mated with Nick Clegg’s party for the purposes of coalition, the Conservatives then devoured them. Twenty-seven Lib Dem seats – West Country fortresses thought impregnable – were won by a majority-bound David Cameron. This electoral shock cast doubt on the party’s very existence. In 2010, Clegg had aspired to break the Tory-Labour duopoly and become prime minister. By 2015, he had too few MPs to fill a committee room (eight). But the Lib Dems are now enjoying glorious revenge. At the last election they won 60 seats from the Conservatives – not only reclaiming their West Country heartlands but advancing through the Tories’ own. South-east voters repelled by ...

28 March 2025

Scotland must sell itself to the world

Holyrood should learn from Ireland’s example and do more to project the nation’s soft power.

By Chris Deerin

Should Donald Trump’s Turnberry golf course host the Open in the next few years? The US President is golf-daft, and yet the top-level Scottish course hasn’t been home to a major since he bought it in 2014. The politics of such a decision manage to be both simple and complex. First Minister John Swinney has, sensibly, said he wants to work with the Trump administration to enhance Scotland’s interests. He recently met Eric Trump, the President’s son, at Bute House, where the pair discussed the family’s business interests in Scotland. As world leaders have learned, Trump senior appreciates nothing more than flattery and obeisance. If you want something from him, you have to give him something in return – the art of ...

27 March 2025

Down with the “positive male role model”

The landscape of contemporary masculinity – sex-obsessed and porn-addled – is not one Gareth Southgate can speak to.

By George Monaghan

An out-of-work football manager has dropped a fresh batch of stone tablets and the House of Commons has found a workaround for Netflix’s password-sharing restrictions, so, under the twin waves of Adolescence and Sir Gareth Southgate, we have enthusiastically recommenced our national hunt for that promising superman: “the positive male role model”. How long have we been chasing that hopeful silhouette now? Long enough by now to realise, I think, that he’s not just elusive – he’s a chimera. He is also, really, a squeamish innuendo. Southgate has no balm for the boiling shame of your porn consumption. When a large man forcing you off the pavement leaves you livid with impotent rage for hours, visualising that you were actually Marcus ...