The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Byelection likely after Labour suspends MacShane over false invoices

Labour acts after Commons standards and privileges committee calls for MacShane to be suspended from Commons for 12 months.

Denis MacShane, pictured whilst Europe minister. Photograph: Getty Images.
Denis MacShane, pictured whilst Europe minister in 2005. Photograph: Getty Images.

It didn't take Labour long to act after the Commons standards and privileges committee recommended that Denis MacShane be suspended as an MP for 12 months for submitting 19 false expenses invoices totalling £12,900. The party has immediately suspended the former Europe minister and has signalled that his "career as a Labour MP" is over. A party spokesman said:

These are very serious findings concerning Denis MacShane and we accept his statement this morning that his career as a Labour MP is effectively over. In the light of the report’s recommendations to the House, the Labour party has suspended Denis MacShane with immediate effect, pending a full NEC enquiry. We will be talking to Denis MacShane about his future and the best course of action for him and for his constituency.

MacShane previously had the Labour whip withdrawn after a police investigation into his claims was launched, but had it reinstated when Scotland Yard announced in July that it would be taking no further action.

The MP has so far refused to say whether he will step down, stating that he is "consulting family and friends" as he reflects on his future. Here's the statement published on his website:

I am shocked and saddened that the BNP has won its 3 year campaign to destroy my political career as a Labour MP despite a full police investigation which decided not to proceed after investigations and interviews. I am glad the Committee notes that there is no question of personal gain.

Clearly I deeply regret that the way I chose to be reimbursed for costs related to my work in Europe and in combating anti-semitism, including being the Prime Minister’s personal envoy, has been judged so harshly.

I remain committed to work for progressive values, for Britain playing a full part in Europe, and for combating anti-semitism even though I can no longer undertake this work as a Labour MP. I am consulting family and friends as I consider my position and study the full implications of the report. I am obviously desperately sorry for any embarrassment I have caused my beloved Labour Party and its leader Ed Miliband whom I greatly admire.

MacShane will surely conclude that he has to resign, rather than leave Rotherham without representation in parliament for a year. Equally, the verdict of the committee, which said this was "the gravest case which has come to us for adjudication, rather than being dealt with under the criminal law", is so damning that he can no longer reasonably remain an MP. It said:

We accept that Mr MacShane is widely acknowledged for his interest in European affairs, and the funds he claimed could be said to have been used in supporting that interest. Those activities may have contributed to his Parliamentary work, albeit indirectly. He has expressed his regret, and repaid the money wrongly claimed. But this does not excuse his behaviour in knowingly submitting nineteen false invoices over a period of four financial years which were plainly intended to deceive the Parliamentary expenses authorities. This is so far from what would be acceptable in any walk of life that we recommend that Mr MacShane be suspended from the service of the House for twelve months. This would mean he lost his salary and pension contributions for this period.

MacShane would be wise to announce his resignation today, rather than cling onto an office he can no longer credibly hold.

UPDATE 2/11/2012 16.35

MacShane has announced that he will be resigning as an MP. The BBC's James Vincent reports on Twitter that MacShane made the following statement:

"I hope by resigning I can serve by showing that MPs must take responsibility for their mistakes"

31 comments

Will Podmore's picture

MacShane was of course a total EU-enthusiast. Well, the EU was good for him, until - unlike the EU - he was rumbled.
He has cheated the taxpayer out of £12,900 of expenses. He fiddled the money through regular false claims for European travel, (so handy, this euro-enthusiasm), using fake signatures. The House of Commons Committee on Standards and Privileges found that his claims were ‘plainly intended to deceive’.
Bit like the EU's claims too!

Hugh C Markey's picture

Ray Gunther a leading light in the TSSA rail clerks union who became Minister of Labour in the Wilson government describes his time at the ministry as 'a bed of nails' experience.
Some of our lot, although somewhat younger, recall Ray losing the 1951 election and being posted by a spiteful BR management to the Continental Booking Office.
Issuing first class rail tickets to Tory MPs and Grandees soon gave him a firm grasp of his place in post-War British society and when he was re-elected to Parliament Ray moved ever more steadily and determinedly to the right of the Labour Party.
This is one of the reasons for creative accounting on the part of MPS. Many Conservative MPS and some Labour and LibDems have other sources of income and are in reality part-timers.
Pay MPs a decent salary and keep tabs on expenses and ban MPs from having other employment. 'Oh, that's the Division Bell! Sorry, Old Chap! Duty calls!'
Do you really believe there are Chinese walls operating between dedicated MPs' employment and outside jobs?
McShane seems to have devoted a lot of his time to UK and EU politics but not having
another income seems to have been a problem. The solution is pretty obvious. Halt the taxpayers' subsidization of private business.
Otherwise not only will the cabinet will be crammed with multi-millionaires but the Parliamentary back benches will be overflowing with wealthy MPs or business nominees.

Blind Trust

Dr David Hill - World Innovation Foundation's picture

“The MacShame Affair” and where democracy is under further threat through the constant erosion of the public’s trust in politicians per se

Political democracy and the trust of the people in our political classes are constantly taking a battering. Indeed the people are losing complete confidence in our politicians as they constantly take illegally from the public purse. Years ago when I was young we used to think that things like this could only happen in a banana republic, for we were told that by our politicians, but now the people are seeing that it happens unabated in their own back yard. The Dennis MacShane fraudulent exposé is another fine example here and where he was seen before this unlawful event as whiter than white within the public eye. Therefore if the perceived public opinion is shattered in a man whom they thought could be trusted, their trust again in our political classes is undermined further. For as it seems that that politicians of all political colours can act in deceptive ways if they want too and that they have learnt nothing from the expenses scandal, it is time that a ‘totally’ independent body and I mean a totally independent body outside the ‘Establishment’, was set up to stop all this happening. And in this respect again, parliamentary rules have to be altered so that in clear cases of crime they too should be dragged through the courts like we mere mortals that vote them into power. For the present rules to protect the perpetrators through parliamentary privilege are not protecting the people against crimes committed against them, and where if the same crime was committed by the people they would most probably receive a custodial sentence. It appears to me that there are two systems in force presently and one of them is basically illegal when we do not use common sense. Time for great political change I feel or voters will simply just not turn out to vote and where unless we wish to see the possibility of a return of what happened elsewhere in the 1930s, things have to change for that reason also. Democracy is therefore bit-by-bit under threat and everyone should see that clearly for their own long-term good.

Dr David Hill
Chief Executive
World Innovation Foundation
Huddersfield, United Kingdom – Bern, Switzerland – Arlington, United States of America

Davidaslindsay's picture

Denis MacShane did valuable work against prostitution and against indecency in the media.

And he had, at least, the virtue of being honestly in favour of all of the assaults on British sovereignty, inseparable as they are among themselves: the EU, American hegemony, Israeli interference (time to revisit those Israeli Embassy press releases which he used to pretend were parliamentary reports), and so on. Including their imposition on the world by force of arms.

His fake think tank is the neocon norm. Liam Fox had his Atlantic Bridge. Policy Exchange, long ago exposed as a forgers' den, is really just a trading name of Michael Gove's office. And apart from pay its staff, what, exactly, does the Henry Jackson Society, a registered charity, do?

Now, both to continue MacShane's good work and to counteract his bad, which Blue Labour figure is going to be the candidate at the Rotherham by-election?

Posh Tosh's picture

A lot of body-dealers bringing in prostitutes came from Europe when he and Kinnock were in not any control.

JonP's picture

You'd have to have a heart of stone not to laugh and cheer at this news. A ridiculous, pompous neo-con - Labour's answer to Gove. He did nothing for the people of Rotherham. When the crisis broke in 2008 instead of trying to do anything for Rotherham - a part of the country that hadn't benefited much from the boom - all MacShane was interested in was wittering on about events in Georgia (as if Britain could influence that). Good bye and good riddance.

Herbert's picture

And let's hope this means we won't have to see any more of MacShame's trupe in the New Statesman.

scampy's picture

Another extremely slimy labour stooge gets caught stealing money from the public purse and even if convicted by a court of law he will be given a soft sentence and released after a few months?
Let us adopt the Chinese way of dealing with these vermin by giving them long jail terms?

Posh Tosh's picture

I would like to se both McBlair and McKinnock taken to the cleaners for their expenses.

I wonder which group of Labour activists in Warpedminster wants his seat?

Barrie J's picture

Or charging his family for the bullet?

Quattro Man's picture

Good old Labour, snouts in the trough yet again.
True colours shown once again, no policies, no strategy, no morales.
When the money runs out....they just steal it!

matthew fox's picture

Welcome back Suziquatroman, as usual, we can depend on you.

Easby's picture

Living in Rotherham I have had the great privilege of hearing Mr MacShane speak on a number of occasions and afterwards sometimes having a follow up conversation with him on the topic of his speech.

Mr Macshane in his speech and subsequent conversations clarified something that had puzzled me for may years concerning what type of person was described by a seemingly well used vernacular word.

That word was "Dick head".

M .Wenzl's picture

I have to admit that, one time after (unknowingly) sitting next to Denis Macshane in debate, I came to the same conclusion as you.

Eddy S's picture

where is the transparency we were promised by this government. we were promised that we would be able to see everything costing more than £500 from any government department or public body. if anyone knows where this website exists, please post it.

M .Wenzl's picture

If you look back at the Tory manifesto, some of their promises are pretty laughable. A big part of their campaign was this notion of 'interactive' government, a feature of which was sacking your MP if he was unpopular/corrupt. What a strange, distant dream.

VoxAngliae's picture

So thedirty dog has resigned?-O Frabjous day,calloo callay I chortle in my joy!
Now it's up to Plod to nail him properly.....

Anthony (Little Englander and Proud)'s picture

How you like them apples? this has made my day, the odious Macshane busted , Tony Blairs little E.U qusling no doubt picked as Europe minister because he had all the lefty socilist traitor skills and fruadster abilitys needed for the job and a regular for the New Statesman.

Check this man out on Wiki - Intresting character to say the least!

Mrs.Josephine Hyde-Hartley 's picture

Well i think it's positively wrong to cause the expense of another election - without the Law having been broken. In fact I think it may be positively wrong to set any working context up a way that is so easily corruptible.

If it's true the man spent £20, ooo per year on an office attached to his house without breaking the Law- one wonders how, where and why such a cost was cranked up - given the dearth of common knowledge or information publicly available concerning what M.P's do and what they are supposed to do..and why can't the people of Rotherham benefit instead from a dedicated emergency application of appropriate systems technology, one that can serve as an emergency Parliamentary representative. I suppose any surgeries could be attended perhaps by some other M,P.. or even some suitable person acting as a virtual M.P. for the purposes of accountability whilst the man is in his period of suspension, or whatever it is.

I don't see why the Labour party should be talking to the man about the future of his constituency when we have an electoral commission. What about the Parliamentary standards people? Isn't the future of a local constituency a job more generally applicable to more independent concerns?

Michael Dixon's picture

It is ironic that the last main act of this pro-European Labour politician was to agree to join forces with the likes Bill Cash and Bernard Jenkins just so his "beloved" Party could score a political point or two, without any regard to principle.

Now he is unpersoned by them

What a way to go.

guevarache's picture

Shoddy money grubbers... self aggrandizement tossers fiddling dodging
in the pocket of this that and the other corrupt corporation
a honest days work for a days pay you got to be joking
the whole system is based on fiddling and outright corruption
in a word EXPLOITATION

Indu Pendent's picture

"I am glad the Committee notes that there is no question of personal gain"

This is totally wrong. He should repay his MP's salary from the point the first breach which led to his suspension.

Are Labour going to press for that? Didnt think so.

matthew fox's picture

McShane did the right thing by resigning, aware he was in the wrong. On the other hand, Andrew Mitchell, swore at a policewoman, refused to be candid with the public, and dragged out the whole issue for a month.

Remind me of you point Inastew?

Stuart Eels's picture

Well yes he should have gone because he's a Toryboy liar who offends my sense of smell but he didn't fiddle,as far as we know at this time, the thousands that sunny boy Dennis did.

matthew fox's picture

Super sorry, it should be read " Remind me of your point Inastew?"

Indu Pendent's picture

Fox

My point of view is that you have a chip on your shoulder with women getting ahead, But that aside McShane is potentially a criminal fraud whilst Mitchell is a arrogant prick with a big mouth.

Neither of them are worth voting for. And one that point we disagree,

matthew fox's picture

So your a woman, really, Inastew, are you super sure?

It's just your biography seems to be evolving, you know like your cheques to the HMRC, the businesses you run, your children, you helping your husband with CV's, etc, etc, etc.

The last installment about attending a state school, put your kids through private schools, it all seems disconnected.

Barrie J's picture

This pompous, self-serving parasite is just the tip of an iceberg.
Every institution of our state has been shown to be totally corrupt from the top to the very bottom.
Before the government targets so called 'benefit scroungers', they need to look to themselves, the City, the judiciary, the police, the media etc., etc.

How can we possibly repair such a broken society?

Indu Pendent's picture

Agree with a lot of this

Orson's picture

I would dip my fist in molten iron and them make a mould of the fist and it would be gleaming and be voted for!

St Bededict's picture

Can i get some of what you inhale?

Latest tweets