Archbishop of Canterbury appointment revives Cameron's class problem
After being accused of running an "old Etonian" elite, the appointment of an Eton-educated Archbishop is awkward for Cameron.
By George Eaton Published 08 November 2012 10:19
In the week that David Cameron was accused by former Home Office mandarin Helen Ghosh of surrounding himself with an "old Etonian clique", the media has been quick to note that Justin Welby, who was revealed today as the new Archbishop of Canterbury, was educated at the school. Significantly, the Telegraph reports that there were "questions over whether an Eton-educated Archbishop would be well received in some quarters" and that these "played a part in delaying the final decision".
It appears likely, then, that Welby's education was, if anything, a hindrance, but his appointment, which will be officially announced by Downing Street (although Welby was selected by the 16-member Crown Nominations Commission), will inevitably be cited by some as evidence of favouritism. It will also prompt further discussion about the state of social mobility in Britain. It's notable that the Prime Minister, the Mayor of London and, now, the head of the Church are all Eton alumni. When was the establishment last so dominated by public school boys?
Welby's predecessor Rowan Williams is, of course, a former NS guest-editor (you can read his famous editorial attacking the government for pursuing "radical, long-term policies for which no one voted" here). Asked yesterday in Auckland, in what was his final press conference, what advice he would give to his successor he declared that the new Archbishop should preach "with a Bible in one hand and a newspaper in the other".
"You have to be cross-referencing all the time and saying, 'How does the vision of humanity and community in the Bible map onto these issues of poverty, privation, violence and conflict?'
"And you have to use what you read in the newspaper to prompt and direct the questions that you put to the Bible: 'Where is this going to help me?'
"So I think somebody who likes reading the Bible and likes reading newspapers would be a good start."
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















16 comments
It matters not which school the AoC attended— the CoE is not the CoE unless it represents that ultimate absurdity and contradiction in terms, the state church. The secular decline in attendance at Anglican temples has been partly due to recognition of this anomaly. However, that Welby is an OE— by design or necessity— does make the embarrassment more acute.
Acute awareness of this problem is now displayed by Welby's grammar-schooled predecessor, who tells him to carry a newspaper as well as a Bible; undoubtedly to give Anglicanism the appearance of representing left wing values, rather than those likely of an education that costs about the same per annum as the income of the average British household. Williams did make rather amateur essays at economics after the Coalition arrived, which might have persuaded some to stay with the CoE. Cameron politely kept him at arm's length; as well he might, of course. It may be that he will attempt to 'rescue' the CoE by taking more notice of Welby, to contrive public empathy for the CoE that it cannot get without artificial means. Watch out for stage management.
But Ed Miliband would be very well advised to stay a good distance from any Cameroon trickery, and from Welby, as he may be less aware of the long, historic association of Toryism and Anglicanism than some. He is of course aware that the Labour Party has little if anything to do with Marxism, but he may have forgotten, as many seem to have forgotten, that its roots lie much more in Methodist inspiration than Anglican. (Of course, as modern Methodism seems to have abandoned its roots, this amnesia is not so surprising.)
Though if Welby, who has already started to moralise, actually understands economics (and a business career is no guarantee of that, at all), he will tread very carefully indeed, where angels fear to tread. Not that he would discard the newspaper and open the Bible instead. That is not the Anglican way, especially today. There does not seem to be any direction in which the CoE can now go. Even with precious help from Ladbrokes.
Well actually any leader worth his salt should lead forward - not react as if to perceived problems concerning schooling. The idea that the state Church is acutely embarrassed about anything " designed" or " necessary" concerning the decisions it has made is a fallacious affectation, probably.
Obviously the advice to lead with the Bible in one hand and a newspaper in the other is an oblique reference to the theory / practice thing. - God's Law as in the Bible on the one hand and common knowledge as reported in newspapers and the like, on the other, as it happens.
I can do a long and windind post , but hey it amounts to the same, its just simply jobs for the boys, if you know the handshake, your in.
Blinkin' 'eck Wainright I thought they were the Blackbirds repopulating our rural area's and our towns.
When did you last see a bird near your home, or anywhere for that matter?
Are all birds dead through genetic engineering gone wrong?
Another Old Etonian. Oh dear.
I do wish people would find out a bit more about him before jumping to conclusions about his values. He clearly didnt put money first when he left a well paid job in the oil industy to train as a priest, and he's no defender of wealthy tory bankers either.
Presumably, Mr Welby would be described by Mr Cameron as a safe pair of hands?
I am sure there will be no need for some spittle lipped, foaming Tory to call for and end to this 'troublesome priest'.
I suspect Mr Welby will be leading whole camel trains through the eyes of needles, preparing the way for the City rich kids to follw.
It's Dr. Welby.
Dr of medicine or something trivial?
It only bothers people like yourself.
The vast majority could'nt care less where a child went to school.
Atlee, Gaitskell, Blair, all Labour public schoolboys. And many more besides
Give it a rest. At least another of those who plays the class card is stuck in the jungle.
It means they are wealthy, privileged, have never worried about having enough to eat or feed their kids, or face eviction. So ... it does matter.
you've clearly not been to public school, or bothered to learn about what it's like for those who have been sent there by their parents.
physical assault, intimidation, rape, no family save for holiday times, no 1st names just your surname, everything controlled by a Totalitarian regime of Prefects and Masters. you just have no idea Ken, and you appear to have no empathy.
But they are wealthy. After your statement, perhaps those schools should be closed down. Many would agree with that.
ah, so money is everything?
i talk about emotional welfare and family life, and you return to the single topic of "wealth".
how's that for irony...?
Can we have similar posts when the heads of other religions are nominated to represent their faith at the House of Lord's?
Over promoted.