Tories abandon plans to abolish 50p tax rate -- for now
The top rate of tax will stay in place until 2015, according to the latest reports.
By Samira Shackle Published 09 January 2012 10:49
The 50p tax rate has been a persistent political headache for the Tories -- and now it looks as if it is not going anywhere until 2015.
David Cameron and George Osborne have always maintained that the top rate of tax, introduced by Gordon Brown in 2010, was a temporary measure. It was suggested in August that it could be cut to 45p as soon as this year or next.
However, the Telegraph today reports that the Prime Minister and Chancellor have concluded that cutting the tax rate is politically impossible in the near future, as they wish to avoid looking like they are pandering to the rich.
Asked about the 50p tax rate on the Andrew Marr Show yesterday, Cameron said:
When you're taking the country through difficult times and difficult decisions, you've got to take the country with you. That means permanently trying to make the argument that what you're doing is fair and seen to be fair.
Given that the public sector pay freeze has effectively been extended until 2015, it would be bad politics to remove the 50p rate. Osborne actually said in his 2009 Conservative conference speech that it would be "grossly unfair" to scrap the top rate of tax while public sector pay remained frozen. Polls have shown that the public broadly support the 50p rate.
On top of the issue of presentation is, simply, the economics. HMRC is currently preparing a report on the top tax rate. While earlier reports suggested that it would find only modest economic returns, it is now expected to show a "surge" in revenues totalling hundreds of millions of pounds in the first year alone. This is despite Osborne's declaration in the last Budget that high rates of personal tax "crush enterprise, undermine aspiration and often undermine tax revenues as people avoid them".
The 50p rate has been a sore point in the coalition, with Liberal Democrats arguing that it must not be removed unless it is replaced by another tax on wealth. Danny Alexander memorably declared that anyone who wanted to scrap the tax was in "cloud cuckoo land", although he was soon contradicted. After Nick Clegg's concession last week that the mansion tax is unlikely to happen, my colleague George Eaton noted:
The corollary of this is that the 50p tax rate is likely to remain for the duration of the parliament. The Lib Dems will not accept the abolition of the top rate unless it is replaced with some kind of wealth tax.
Yet backbench Tories remain opposed to the tax. In the Budget in March, Osborne is expected to indicate that the decision to retain the 50p rate until 2015 is still under review.
Change may be off the table for the moment, but the pressure from backbenchers on Conservative top command will remain.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















12 comments
Shinsei67 - and I'm sure HMRC staff would like it if governments (Labour and Tory) stopped cutting their numbers so there were enough people to do the job properly.
@Freeman
Weren't the staff numbers cut following the merger of Inland Revenue and Customs and Excise and the resultant cost savings, efficiencies that this was supposed to create ? Plus a new expensive IT system to modernise the system.
It all probably made sense at the time.
"The surge in revenues does rather nail the common prejudice held by many of the left that rich bankers avoid paying tax."
I assure you that common prejudice will persist.
"rich people are a problem, and this must be addressed."
Loonie left unite!
the coalition has missed a trick with tax simplification, there is no party which is willing to do this properly vested interests excemptions and tax simplification. we need to get rid of national insurance and add to income tax, remove road tax and add to fuel tax (more greener policy and less admin costs), remove thousands of exemptions like for films etc, bring the main taxes around the same rate (e.g. capital gains, income, vat) - this reduces incentives for avoidance.
I support the concept of a vastly simplified tax regime-maybe not a flat tax but something much nearer to it. Transparent rules,even if not 100% fair, would reestablish public confidence in the system-and perhaps even create even more economies at HMRC.....
A couple of observations:
1) I don't think anyone would be surprised that revenues surged in first year of its introduction. Bankers on £5m with a large house, family in schools etc aren't going to be able to decamp to Singapore or Dubai that quickly even if they wanted to. Longer term is the issue as internationally mobile people choose whether to come to London or work elsewhere.
2) The surge in revenues does rather nail the common prejudice held by many of the left that rich bankers avoid paying tax.
HMRC would do a better a job if they actually cracked down on tax loopholes and tax avoidence and simplified the tax codes. I think that would bring in more money. The process might be long but we're going nowhere fast.
I agree with @Inequality. Rich people are a problem, and this must be addressed. But of course the Tory scum hate the poor, and want to drive them further into poverty. Time for a revolution.
"HMRC would do a better a job if they actually cracked down on tax loopholes and tax avoidence and simplified the tax codes."
Government legislation is responsible for the complexity of the tax system not HMRC.
Brown famously doubled the size of Tolley's Tax Guide.
I'm sure HMRC staff would like a much simpler system to manage.