Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

50 years of PMQs: the best moments

The best videos, including "Stalin to Mr Bean", "we saved the world" and "calm down, dear!"

This week marks 50 years since the first PMQs (Harold Macmillan vs. Hugh Gaitskell, since you ask). So, by way of celebration, here are some of the most memorable moments from the weekly joust.

Blair on Major: "weak, weak, weak"

Here, from his clashes with John Major, are two of Tony Blair's most artful put-downs. In the first clip from 25 May 1995, the young Labour leader taunts Major's inability to control his anti-European backbenchers. "There is one very big difference - I lead my party, he follows his." Major later described it in his memoirs as "the best one-liner he ever used against me".

In the second from 30 January 1997 (again concerning Europe), Blair brands Major "weak, weak, weak" for failing to impose a joint line on the euro.

Cameron to Blair: "you were the future once"

And here's the "heir to Blair" in action at his first PMQs, telling his rival "you were the future once" and reprimanding the Labour chief whip for "shouting like a child".

Cable on Brown: "Stalin to Mr Bean"

It was Andrew Turnball, the former head of the civil service, who declared in March 2007 that Gordon Brown operated with "Stalinist ruthlessness". But eight months later, after a run on Northern Rock, the loss of 25 million child benefit records and another donations scandal, the description no longer seemed so appropriate. Vince Cable, then acting leader of the Lib Dems, caught the mood when he quipped that Brown had gone "from Stalin to Mr Bean" in a matter of weeks.

Brown: "we saved the world"

New York Times columnist Paul Krugman memorably asked: "Has Gordon Brown, the British prime minister, saved the world financial system?" and answered in the affirmative. But Krugman's praise appeared to have gone to Brown's head when he told the Commons: "we saved the world". His humourless response (Blair would have quipped "we'll get round to that later") only made matters worse.

Cameron to Angela Eagle: "calm down, dear!"

Finally, from earlier this year, here's Cameron's ill-advised riposte to Angela Eagle. For an idea of how the remark went down with the Lib Dems, just contrast Nick Clegg's stony face with George Osborne's guffawing.

Tags: PMQs

12 comments

Awake!'s picture

indu
had EXACTLY the same thought, bleating on about investment- did u notice brown nodding his head.. hehe. How the children were betrayed. And i noticed the tories, stuck in their seats, they coudn't say anything, how could they argue- for yearss the taps kept open the money pissed down the drain but it was a vote winner... sick and funny at the same time as u say. Shame for the kids.. Oh no, there grades are the best ever now, officially lol
did enjoy this- Blair is still mesmerising, that guy literally hypnotises

Marcus's picture

The best one was Thatcher lecturing a young Simon Hughes on the dangers of socialism.

Mrs.Josephine Hyde-Hartley's picture

Yes I seem to remember one or two very good sessions at P.M.Q's that might still be very important years later;

One included as I remember the very important question asked of the P.M. concerning who exactly is the head of the public services..he was apparently unable to tell the House - without fear or favour perhaps?

Another time was when Lib Dem opposition leader told the House that the P.M "can't have it both ways.." It struck me as profoundly important because in my view of all the Laws and legislations, policies and guidance provided since I've been able to take notice as an ordinary member of the public - the true and correct leader of any government can of course have anything he or she may require, anyway.

But I may be mistaken about these memories - and I can't be bothered to go and look them up for everyone's perusal, right now.

Rob's picture

So these are the 'great moments' are they?

James Hunter's picture

feeble

swatantra nandanwar's picture

Have to agree, they were all rubbish moments. Surely you could have picked out better.

Alexander Allen's picture

LoL I love these guys. I would say I like Cable on Brown: "Stalin to Mr Bean" the best, absolutely awesome.

Herbert's picture

If these were 'great moments' we might as well pack it in now. Why not - some old scraps w've been able to find of MPWs SINCE IT WAS TELEVISED, not 50 years.

Freeman2's picture

PMQs I mean. Whoops.

Lorna's picture

Ian Lavery asking about David Camerons adviser David Britnall was hilarious...Cameron replied he'd never heard of him, but did some research and it turns out he was an adviser, to the last Government

Indu Pendent's picture

@george
... funny. Laughed and laughed. Then watched the "you were the future once" all the way through blowing a cold chill listening to Blair bleat on about investment investment investment, lying about the defict even back then and criticising the idea of restraint. Guess thats politics - makes you elated and sickened at the same time.

Could we have more please?

Matty1's picture

When I come to power PMQs will be a thing of the past. It will be replaced by flame wars on twitter.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets