The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Labour challenges Cameron on his Bullingdon past

The party questions Cameron's claim that he never saw a restaurant smashed up.

As I predicted, David Cameron's flawed defence of his Bullingdon Club past has left him politically exposed. Labour has issued a press release challenging Cameron's questionable claim that he never saw a restaurant smashed up, and urging him to "take responsibility" for what he dismisses as youthful indiscretions.

Here's the full statement from Labour MP John Mann:

David Cameron has questions to answer after his claim today that he did not witness people throwing things through windows or smashing up restaurants during his days as a Bullingdon Club member.

This is very different to what other people remember.

He needs to start admitting what he did and start taking responsibility for what he shrugs off as youthful indiscretions.

If we are to get more responsibility throughout our society following the riots then the Prime Minister should set an example.

No doubt some will dismiss this as more "toff-bashing" from Labour. But unlike Cameron's expensive schooling, the party regards this as legitimate political territory. The key point, they say, is that Cameron chose to join the Bullingdon Club. It provides Ed Miliband, who was more likely to be found reading Fabian pamphlets than smashing restaurant windows, with another opportunity to restate his call for responsibility at the top and the bottom of the society.

38 comments

p j wall's picture

The right wingers on here appear to be sensitive little buttercups!!, they`re not pleased their dear leader and idol Flashman, has been caught out again, being a typical Tory hypocrite, and practicing double standards!, The moral of the story is, it`s ok to be a Thug and a Yob if Mater and Pater are rich!, because they`ll pay for any damaged caused!, that`s ok then!!, You only have to look at those infamous Bullingdon club photos, with Gideon and Flashman looking at all of us 'Normal' people with utter contempt, and a look of deluded superiority!!, a trait in which they`ve carried on to this day!, i think we can say they suffer HUBRIS, the reaction by some of Flashmans Sycophantic followers on here is Hysterical!,Ha,Ha, they must have a photo of him along with their other icon, The Goddess Thatcher in some srt of Pathetic shrine!!, Twonks.

Marcus's picture

This has more to do with the (pink) BBC and (red) Channel 4 working with liberal political party's in to set the political agenda for the day.

State funded broadcasters need to be careful.............. They operate under different rules from their comrades at the Guardian and people are now watching.

QT, Newsnight, BBC news editorial policy and most outsourced youth production are all ripe for investigation.

Frederick James's picture

Dear God, you guys are getting desperate!

Al4's picture

@Marcus

Say what?!

ok's picture

@Marcus

Where are you reading this?

Pat's picture

@Marcus

The BBC has always been small-c conservative - look at its attitudes to strikes (see the Glasgow Media reports into its coverage of strike action etc in the 70s) and its fawning spouting of government PR. Just because one of their presenters has the temerity to ask an embarrassing question of the PM, you get into a tizzy fit about bias. Bet you didn't mind when they asked "tough" questions of Labour ministers. Ahh - has it upset you? Grow up, the rest of us did years ago.

Luddite's picture

p j wall:
The right wingers... Sycophantic followers.. are you right in the head son?

lmb's picture

Yes for his crimes Cameron went to Eton and Oxford, is there something wrong with leaders being well educated!
I think the Oxford and Harvard educated
Elite Ed Miliband should stop being such a chameleon he is no champion of the working classes, they are just a necessity.
Also the Left and the BBC to compare the short-term bad behaviour of a few students to justify lawless thugs with their self-pity, violence and hatred is just plain wrong.There are people dying in the middle-east for the freedom we have, there are also countries in the world where people live in extreme poverty, and without Free health care, welfare, education and housing -I think i will save my pity for them although i am sure they would hate pity.

alanm's picture

@Imb
Thanks, you got in and correct @Marcus before me: the BBC at the current time is if anything centre-right: its quite reactionary coverage of the student protests and now the August riots betrays that, as did its pathetically fawning coverage of the royal wedding. Hardly 'pink' I think: more purpley blue these days.

Fergus Pickering's picture

But, p j wall, WE are in power and you are not. Chew on that oh marxist one.

Adam's picture

This kind of behaviour makes the Labour Party look like they're running an Oxbridge student politics campaign. Guess they haven't heard about the stagnant economy?

Hugh Markey's picture

With friends like these ...........! Surprised Rupert Murdoch's name has been left off list of youthful friends of the Labour Party.
What's all this about hardening arteries?
Remember the Mockney Charade? It was quite an issue. Public school chaps and chapesses pretending to come from oh so 'umble circumstances.
Then they showed their school colours when Tory ex- state grammar school gals and lads took hold of the reins.
How frustrating for the present Tory meritocracy now that mummies and daddies' little investments are hogging all the limelight.
Gosh, with all this aspirational guff about you would think there must be a palace revolution.

Ivy Leaguers

swatantra's picture

... yeh, and when the Revolution comes, we'll have servants and butlers and maids, just like them.
I wish people would stop all this class nonsense; it's just trivialising politics.

Mike S's picture

I think they have heard of the stagnant economy, Adam. It's only the boy George who believes stagnation is good.

Arthur Williamson's picture

I do agree subjects such as the middle east and the economy are far more important.

Having said that, if I was one of many shop-owners whose business got smashed-up by the rioters, I would be very interested to find out if Cameron`s strong rhetoric during the week of the riots can be matched with a bit of integrity and humility.

Eddy S's picture

This is a pathetic article.

C Baker's picture

I thought Miliband was doing ok. He was quite mature and non party political about the riots and seemed to be showing some strong leadership. Surely the 'toffs', ,Bullingdon' club issue is a very desperate diversion from his lack of policies. A great diversion too, from the 'Darling Brown, economic story'. Shame. I expected more from Miliband. I thought he was more in touch with the people and issues of the day.

Marcus's picture

@Pat - Have you seen the list of former members of the Labour Party currently employed as presenters and producers at the BBC?

The list is very damaging to the BBC as a 'neutral' broadcaster and to the fabric of our very society.

Dimbleby, Marr, Crick, Wark, Paxton, the list goes on and on............ and yes the guy asking the question was a member of the Labour Party as well.

The only former Tories at the BBC are Neil and Robinson.

What about the little mentioned Channel Four?

Anybody who deems Jon Snow anything other than a member of the Looney-left needs there head examining.

My head? I'm fine. Thanks for asking. I am not either a Tory, or right wing. I can however see the obvious bias within the BBC.

Even the BBC bigwigs note that they are institutionally left wing so silly insinuations that they are small 'c' conservatives is as vapid as it is nieve.

Seems to me that the Labour tribalists commenting are less interested in a free society and more interested in getting their own way.

That is why socialism, which sounds like a good idea to some in principal, fails and fails utterly.

p j wall's picture

Spasiba, tovarish Pickering, your insight is much appreciated!!, Oops, i`ve been rumbled!!!.

Michael Dixon's picture

This must go down as one of the stupidiest acts by the Labour Party. They lay themselves open to any kind of accusation as to their past. Conservative Office will be bevearing away. Labour are in total disarray with this desperate stuff. Who cares and where does it take the debate as to the riots?

p j wall's picture

Luddite.... You`re wrong again, surely you`ve realised, i`m Left in the head son?, Give my best wishes to your fellow inmates at the institute!!!.

REPAY's picture

The only correct response to any Bullingdon club damages is that anyone breaking the law should be dealt with. The PM should have said this...I can't help feeling that youthful indiscretion accounts for some of those in jail for taking a bottle of water in the riots...

swatantra's picture

Surely they've got better things to do.

matthew fox's picture

BBC Bias, that old gag. Nick Robinson has no problem schilling for the Conservative Party.

Graeme's picture

@swatantra - are you a Tory voter, or worse?

Hugh Markey's picture

In the post-war Britain of the Great War it is alleged that a party of four or five threw and a fellow university student into a river in the neighbourhood of their seat of learning. He drowned. And there was suspicious bruising! This student had allegedly espoused leftish views inflaming these British patriots whose elders had just subdued the HUN. One of the group became the ultimate Hollywood villain of the thirties, forties and fifties. Another group member rose to be a high court judge. The remainder appear to have been rugby hearties.
Such youthful indiscretions are naaturally par for the course. We say bring back 'rag' week. That's the way to let off steam.
There should be one cavaet - the perpetrator/s must have been to public school. Not grammar school or a poor-man's model institution funded at taxpayers' expense.

Level Eton Field

Greg's picture

Did someone say flogging a dead horse yet?

Luddite's picture

j wall: Your certainly left-in-the-head!! vacantly left-in-the-head!!
Please.. patients not 'inmates' that so politically incorrect, you should know that being a rabid lefty...

David Lindsay's picture

Consider what would happen if a group of boys on a council estate, the same age as Oxford undergraduates, formed themselves into an organisation - complete with a name, a uniform, officers and a membership list - specifically for the purpose of becoming drunk and disorderly before committing criminal damage and even assault. They would rightly be sent to prison. Whereas the Bullingdon Boys go on to become, simultaneously, an aspirant Prime Minister, an aspirant Chancellor of the Exchequer, and an actual Mayor of London.

Living in rural England, as I have done most of my life and which is a very different matter from merely owning great swathes of it while living in Knightsbridge or Notting Hill, I suspect that the publicans of Oxfordshire are not without connections in the local constabulary and magistracy. One of those publicans should simply tell the Bullingdon Club to stick the money that they offered him at the end of one of their "events", because he would be seeing them in court. How would it look for Cameron and Osborne if the Bully Boys were to be locked up for just long enough to have themselves sent down?

Mizar's picture

Unlike a few trolls here, I actually want to know the truth about Cameron's past. I think this is entirely reasonable. If he engaged in criminal activity, I do say if, then many people would be appalled, and would wonder if he is unfit for his current role.

Dickie1's picture

@Mizar.

I agree.

When he says 'we all do stupid things', does he simply mean joining a club and dressing up a bit like Adam Ant?

Luddite's picture

Labour challenges Cameron on his Bullingdon past. 'Bollocks' who cares about Mr Toffee-nose. Let's talk about Nasally challenged Ed Miliband's Marxist past!!

Acamar's picture

Luddite, how old are you?

Luddite's picture

Old enough to remember previous disastrous Labour governments. How old are you?

Fergus Pickering's picture

You say Cameron was responsible for robbery and criminal damage when he was 18 or so. And you have evidence? What is it? You DON'T have evidence. Shut up then.

Latest tweets