Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Cameron's judgement remains the issue

The PM seems to think loyalty to an ex-colleague is an intrinsic virtue.

One small but revealing moment in David Cameron's press conference earlier today: when he was asked whether he was warned about specific problems in Andy Coulson's past he said he couldn't "recall" being told. A warning light should go on any time a politician uses that formula. It is neither a denial, nor is it an acknowledgement. It is a holding device that says, in essence, "I don't have a line on this yet, my lawyers have told me to say nothing."

The main impression most people will get from that press conference is that Cameron wanted to deflect this whole story away from questions about his judgement. He failed. In the process he left hostages to fortune. All of those references to his personal friendship with Coulson will be problematic if there is a trial and conviction. Cameron seems to think loyalty to an ex-colleague is an intrinsic virtue here. He said you'd have to be a "pretty unpleasant" person to casually drop an old chum.

But brutally cutting off someone who is damaging you is exactly what a politician in Cameron's position should be doing right now. That's the way it works. People won't respect him for staying loyal, they'll see him as part of a clubbish, mutual back-scratching conspiracy.

The attempt to scatter some of the blame around with references to the Blair era, Bernie Ecclestone's money, dodgy dossiers etc, was also pretty off-key, I thought. It sounded desperate, as if he wanted the whole of politics to take some of the heat when clearly the specific question of whether Coulson was an appropriate person to have running the government's communications operation cannot apply to anyone but the man who gave him the job.

What isn't clear is how much of the public anger over hacking will attach itself to the politicians who failed to get to grips with the issue. The principle villains are still the hackers themselves and the media bosses who tried to cover their tracks. Up to a point, all politicians stand accused of complicity. But the danger for Cameron is that, through the Coulson connection, he is associated in the public eye as part of that reviled media-boss class much more than anyone else in Westminster. He risks becoming the emblem of a corrupt power dynamic. With his press conference today he only made that more likely.

Tags: Andy Coulson  David Cameron

13 comments

Mrs.Josephine Hyde-Hartley's picture

"That's the way it works"

It really makes me cringe to hear such an incredibly stupid cliché -given the salutary lesson that surely was/is the global financial crisis.

Be scared, I should say.

People do respect others for staying loyal to a friend - and people in general are much better informed nowadays than we were. I've read somewhere that good names and brands are considered more valuable than commodities, words or even figures can tell these days -I dare say that's in part because of loyalty, obviously.

But loyalty isn't just about money. It seems to me that real virtuous and ethical positions eg being loyal to one's friend without fear or favour - should definitely not to be confused with any clubbish, mutual back-scratching conspiracy, or any other fallacious affectation pretending to be ordinary.

Therefore re; the relationship between a P.M and a friend - there is no issue at all, in my view. Surely it's the same as what goes on between any individuals, with or without an association or contract, elected or appointed.

Fergus Pickering's picture

Didn't Gordon Brown employ a chap called Mac something who is very dodgy? Alistair Campbell never told lies eh? Lord Levy, who he? And, going back a bit, wasn't Harold Wilson very pally with a certain maker of raincoats. Wasn't Tribune sustained by russian money when Michael Foot edited it. How many Kinnocks are on the Euro payroll? Very selective, the memories of you lefties.

tuttifrutti's picture

@ Fergus Pickering
Talking of selective memories, shouldn't that list also include Thatcher?

Freeman2's picture

Coulson at the Sheridan trial:

Tommy Sheridan: “Did the News of the World pay corrupt police officers?”
Andy Coulson: “Not to my knowledge.”

A variation on the 'recall' gambit.

Sodium Haze's picture

Quiet moves behind the scenes to prepare for cameron's departure in the not too distant future. Tories fear worse is yet to come!

Odds tumbling with bookies that he will be the next person to leave the cabinet - lots of blogs think he is finished.

http://www.sodiumhaze.org/?p=645

Anton Jury's picture

David Cameron is incompetent and unfit to Govern this country and should resign.

We have all had Enough of all the Electoral Campaign spin, deceit, lies and protecting those that were known to have been implicated in crime (Phone Hacking).

David Cameron is a disgrace to politic's because he knowingly employed a crook even though he was warned.

Can it get any worse then employing and protecting crooks ?

red mary's picture

Mombassa the Tories are in it up to thier necks not Labour Love it

Stuart Eels's picture

I don't know Anton Jury, lets' just enjoy it while we can. I miss the MPS expenses scandal.

It must be so annoying for Dave boy that his carefully laid plans are falling apart around his ears.

MikeP's picture

Coulson was privey to state secrets. Did Cameron not get a positive vetting report on Coulson? This should have had an MI5 assessment of the potential for blackmail for past misdemeanours. Someone should ask the question.

Mombasa69's picture

Blame the Labour Scum that were in power when all this s**t started, if I had my way the entire Labour Party would all be f**king shot!

SCUM!

martybee's picture

Coulson admitted authorising paymrnts to the police in return for information..in other words condoning bribery of public officials, he stated this at a Commons Select committee and is on the record..I believe this was before Cameron received his assurances from Mr Coulson re Phone hacking...Whether Coulson condoned the the hacking is irrelevant..Cameron hired a known him knowing that he was corrupt.

Anton Jury's picture

Mombasa69

You cannot "bLAME" The Labour Party for this one because it was not the Labour Leader that employed Andy Culson so you had better blame his employer David Cameron. Just in case you have forgotten David Cameron knew that Andy Culson had been implicated in crime (Phone Hacking) In addition to this David Cameron was warned by many people that to bring Andy Culson into Downing Sreet as Head of Communication was very unwise. Remember the News Headlines when Andy Culson first went into Downing Street so David Cameron was fully aware. Any idiot could have told you that to give a person such as Andy Culson an important job in Downing Street was pathetic and irresponsible.

Lets see if David Camerons other close friend (Brooks) finds herself in court.

Its possible that the Conservative Party will wish that David Cameron had been shot a long time ago because he has most certainly put his neck in the noose on this occasion and only himself to blame, not Labour.

Enjoy the news !

Sasha's picture

If Coulson has been dropped in it to save skins at News International, he could start to sing. David Cameron may be staying "loyal" in the hope that all those bodies stay buried. Imagine Coulson's diaries!

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets