Juliet Jacques

Exploring counter-culture in the arts, politics, sexuality and sport

Syndicate contentRSS

Transsexual people and the public eye

What challenges would be faced by a famous person transitioning in public?

There are few openly transsexual people in British public life -- and virtually none who have come out when already famous. The most notable exception remains acclaimed travel writer Jan Morris, who kept her gender reassignment secret until announcing its conclusion in 1972 and then publishing her autobiography, Conundrum. Since then, nobody approaching Morris's level of celebrity has publicly transitioned, with almost all of Britain's known transsexual people realising their identity before stepping into the spotlight.

By contrast, the hard work of post-war activists and the courage of openly gay, lesbian or bisexual people have created a climate where, slowly, public figures can discuss their sexual preferences without press intrusion -- or pressure to act as advocates -- ruining their lives. Since Thatcher's Conservatives passed the deplorable Section 28 in 1988, banning the "promotion" of homosexuality in schools, progress has been remarkable: having apologised for this legislation, David Cameron's government now retains 13 openly gay Tory MPs, and there is now a diverse range of visible gay, lesbian or bisexual people in the arts, media and, gradually, sport.

The situation for noted people in any field who come out, or are outed as transsexual would almost certainly be less accommodating. (I focus on 'transsexual' rather than 'transgender' people, cross-dressers or transvestites, as the 'Real Life Experience' required to access medical treatment obliges full time living in the chosen gender, making its public expression and resultant attention unavoidable). As there have been so few test cases, I can only speculate on what may unfold, but the experiences of visible transsexual people in the USA offer some clues.

Recently, at least three Americans have publicly transitioned: Cher and Sonny and Cher's son Chaz Bono, actor Alexis Arquette and LA Times sports writer Mike Penner, briefly known as Christine Daniels. Chaz Bono transitioned from female to male, Arquette and Penner from male to female; their contrasting fortunes, including Penner's detransition and suicide, illustrate the challenges that a British counterpart might face.

The fundamental issues would be around privacy. The concerns for anyone whose transition is picked up by the print or broadcast media have been covered here by David Allen Green, but for our transsexual pioneer, these would be magnified by already being in the public eye.

Interest would be most intense at the point of disclosure, which could mean facing virtually every consequent social challenge simultaneously. If preparing to come out, a transsexual person would be best served telling family, friends and colleagues before the press -- if secured, their support would be vital in dealing with inevitable 'curiosity'. If not, that person might think again about going public, although doing so would eventually become essential according to the gender reassignment pathway -- and once made, the announcement may find its way into the public domain anyway, even if retracted.

If outed by someone else, around the start of the process, that person would not have the reassurance that loved ones could be relied upon for backing -- and may have no idea who to ask for help. (Anyone who did come out today might seek out Trans Media Watch as a first point of contact, as they provide support to people whose gender status is widely known.) Either way, the Real Life Experience would have to begin at some point -- and the scrutiny of his or her appearance, if not entire life, would start.

"Before and after pictures have long been a staple in media coverage of transsexual people, alongside undermining of the identity chosen. This is not to mention the possibility of speculation about personal and professional relationships or mental health, or intimate questions about sexuality, genitalia and surgery -- something that activist Christine Burns, for example, had to manage in television appearances -- all when this person would feel most vulnerable, striving on several fronts to assert his or her true self.

For those with little connection to other similar people or any grounding in trans politics or theory, some challenges may come as an unpleasant surprise. Chaz Bono and Alexis Arquette both spent plenty of time within LGBT circles before transition and probably knew what types of attack, and what support, could reasonably be anticipated not just from "straight" conservatives, but from certain lesbian or gay critics, and the 'transgender' community (an increasingly fractious alliance, which, like many groups struggling for social change, has sometimes been susceptible to attacking its own). One of the saddest parts of Penner/Daniels's sad story, chronicled here by Steve Freiss, was the breakdown in relations with trans support networks over how Daniels presented as a woman, and how unprepared she was for this kind of criticism. The crucial problems, however, involved her relationships with her family -- not the media.

Given the continued lack of individuals who are able -- or allowed -- to offer a transsexual perspective to a large audience as a counterpoint to negative coverage, a public figure might feel pressure to 'represent' people, but this role could be declined relatively easily if he or she did not feel comfortable in assuming it. Bono and Arquette both became more famous as a consequence of transition, and have often seemed more comfortable performing an advocacy function, and their patient, articulate explanations of their histories and the support they have received from family, friends and the wider public bodes well for anyone in Britain who takes similar steps. But how much has changed here since Jan Morris's day still remains to be seen.

Juliet Jacques is the author of the Orwell Prize longlisted Guardian blog A Transgender Journey

12 comments

Juliet's picture

@quiet riot girl: that's worthy of further attention, so thanks!

When I began my BA, doing a particularly torturous module on British economic history, I remember the lecturer mentioning "Deirdre McCloskey - history's most famous transsexual" whilst doing a quick capsule review of the writing on whatever subject was boring me stupid that week.

Anyway, I was surprised - and a bit affronted (even then, when I didn't realise that I'd later transition myself) - that he'd chosen to highlight this about McCloskey (surely her work was more important?) but years later I read her autobiography, 'Crossing'.

That's worth a look, mainly as it shows how acceptance or rejection of trans people cuts across ideological barriers (some socialists rejected her, some conservatives accepted her, and vice versa) and how people seemed to think all her opinions, tastes etc would change with her body. It might make an intriguing comparison with Connell's more recent experiences, anyway.

@Christine Burns: good point - and maybe a subject for a follow-up! Although no good examples are rushing to my mind ...

Christine Burns's picture

@Juliet You're right that no examples of the kind I mentioned would rush to mind; however that's the point .. they wouldn't even occur to anyone yet :-)

The reason I mentioned it was because there ARE those people out there, in the media and in high profile jobs, who have a trans history and whom nobody knows about.

I completely understand why they have kept their history quiet. However, maybe one day one of them will decide to surprise the world.

Mizar's picture

EhtchTee - your age is showing. But April Ashley surely was the best known example.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_transgender_people has quite a list.

But it leaves out Adèle Anderson, of Fascinating Aida, pretty well know I would say.

Natacha Kennedy's picture

@Quietriotgirl Raewin Connell's work on Masculinities is considered to be one of the seminal works in the area, and most consider the fact that she now identifies as a woman to have put her in a position whereby she has a particularly good insight into this area. In addition she continues to produce particularly good research in the field of gender, not merely about masculinities.

Many people who write about gender, such as Judith Butler and my colleague Carrie Paechter refer extensively to transgender and transsexual people in their research in order to fully investigate notions of gender. It is actually quite a difficult thing to do to investigate something which is so ubiquitous but which we are al invested in to a large extent.

So it is not surprising that trans researchers and academics have joined in and refer to cisgender as well as trans gender identities in their work. In a sense trans people often bring a new perspective to research on gender, which is to the benefit of everyone.

Natacha Kennedy's picture

Good article Juliet,

BTW you might be interested in this article published on Facebook last night by Autumn Sandeen in the US about Transsexual journalist Janet Mock.

https://www.facebook.com/notes/autumn-sandeen/some-thoughts-and-unsolici...

quiet riot girl's picture

Hi Natacha I wasn't criticising Ms Connell.

I think her work is important in that it has been influential, though I don't go along with much of it anymore!

What I meant was she risked a lot, not just in coming out, but in coming out when she worked in a field that was directly concerned with theorising gender itself.

Christine Burns's picture

If cis-gender people have difficulty imagining the trans experience then I can only speculate how limiting it must be to try and conceptualise gender when you are totally immersed in just one form of it.

If deep sea fish had language then I imagine they would have a similar problem conceptualising "wet" and "dry"

I think of trans people as gender's amphibians, blessed with the insight that's gained from having at different times in life inhabited both environments and crossed the interface between them

Jennie Kermode's picture

The new documentary about Chaz Bono, 'Becoming Chaz', which screened recently at Sheffield Doc/Fest, does an excellent job of exploring these issues. My review here: http://www.eyeforfilm.co.uk/reviews.php?film_id=19578

quiet riot girl's picture

Christine I know what you mean, but I think there are lots of people who do not specifically identify as 'trans' who have done plenty of gender-crossing in their time, and with plenty of trauma and also insight.

I understand and respect and fully support the need to show how trans people suffer some specific discriminations, and also have some specific experiences.

But this cis/trans binary is no more helpful than any other binary in my view.

quiet riot girl's picture

I recently found out that a well-known (to me! Not famous in the general sense) gender academic, RW Connell, quite recently transitioned from M to F.

One reason I thought this was brave (among many) was that she made her career as a man, as an expert in masculinities. So to go to the identity of 'woman' publicly raises some interesting issues about the actual content of her research.

I haven't looked up much information about it as I didn't want to be one of those gossip-hungry voyeurs.

But it is an interesting story I think.

Christine Burns's picture

What you haven't discussed in such depth here is the phenomenon of someone already famous coming out (from so-called 'stealth') to tell people who knew nothing about their transsexual background.

This would be the nearest analogue to the situation gay celebrities experience. I.e. Most gay and lesbian celebs so far seem to have achieved their fame before disclosing their sexual preference.

By contrast (and it is a BIG difference) trans people (as you illustrate) mostly come out either before finding fame or (in these rare cases) they come out to transition.

Duncan Robinson's picture

That is a very interesting case, thanks for pointing it out, @quietriotgirl.

Latest tweets