Immigrants must learn English, says David Cameron – while cutting funding for lessons
The Prime Minister’s speech indicates that he cares less about integration than about reaching out to his core vote.
By Samira Shackle Published 14 April 2011 10:41
Hot on the heels of his controversial address on multiculturalism in Munich in February, David Cameron is set to deliver another hard-hitting speech, this one specifically on immigration.
He will criticise the "largest influx" ever of immigrants in British history and emphasise the need for immigrants to speak English:
Real integration takes time. That's why, when there have been significant numbers of new people arriving in neighbourhoods perhaps not able to speak the same language as those living there, on occasions not really wanting or even willing to integrate, that has created a kind of discomfort and disjointedness in some neighbourhoods.
There is rather a cruel irony in this, given that the government will be drastically cutting funding for English as a Second Language (Esol) courses from September this year.
Under new rules, free places will be limited to students who are on jobseeker's allowance or employment support allowance – benefits paid to those actively seeking work.
At present, people who receive other benefits, such as housing benefit, income support or tax credits are also eligible for free lessons. From September, this will no longer be the case. State funding for Esol courses within the workplace will also end, leaving employers to pay.
The Institute of Race Relations noted in December:
There is concern that these changes are being introduced with no evidence of prior consultation, and without any assessment of their impact on people from migrant communities.
It is widely acknowledged that English language proficiency is crucial to participation in the labour market, for accessing services, and to functioning independently in everyday life. In consequence, the effects of cutting language provision will be widely felt. Early local impact assessments indicate cuts in core provision of up to 50 per cent.
Newspaper reports of Cameron's speech have focused on a widening gulf in the language used by the two coalition parties on this subject (a senior Lib Dem has described the tone of the speech as "appalling"). However, this basic contradiction indicates that Cameron cares less about encouraging integration than reaching out to the core Conservative vote with hardline rhetoric ahead of the local elections.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















22 comments
Cameron is an odious fart and his dishonesty [even for a politician] is jaw-dropping.
Hideous to look at, but when the voice alone is heard, he sounds like he's from an old pathe news item, you know, where they all sound like the royals.
He's so out of touch and I hate to give them advice, but David Davis would have served them better.
This was an issue in Wales long before it ever became an issue in England. Had politicians been willing to face the problem honestly and take constructive steps instead of brushing the whole issue aside as the concern of a few Welsh "hotheads" then perhaps the whole immigration debacle in England would never have occurred.
Unless there is a sustained willingness to be open and honest about the vital place of language in fostering meaningful communities, and a determination at the top levels to act positively, both the English and Welsh will continue to be threatened with swamping, the English by immigrants from outside the UK and the Welsh by immigrants from England.
The native language of Wales is Welsh (though we're now officially bilingual) and the native language of England is English.
ang. It's the left thats out of touch. So ang. you are very opinionated. You seem to have all the answers. What should Mr Miliband say about the genuine concerns of millions.
"When there have been significant numbers of new people arriving in neighbourhoods perhaps not able to speak the same language as those living there, on occasions not really wanting or even willing to integrate, that has created a kind of discomfort and disjointedness in some neighbourhoods."
That will be Spain then.
"....Cameron cares less about encouraging integration than in reaching out to the core Conservative vote with hardline rhetoric ahead of the local elections."
Spot on, Samira. This is pure cynicism from a wretched and increasingly desperate man.
Why should the taxpayer be responsible for the English lessons of economic migrant dependants?
ang, all politicians have a dark side and David Cameron is no different...
So tell me who do you think is 'in-touch' with the people? across all parties (it seems you are pro-labour so 'try' and be unbaised)
apuleius, try trading the article properly for who is currently entitled and why it makes sense. Then think a bit.
*try reading*
mcquade,
Spot on, I as a tourist am always trying learn more Spanish and yet there are getto's of Brits there that have been there for years and never bothered to learn the language!
Having said that everyone should try.
about immigrants from outside the EU, shouldn't they learn english before they come over here to work?
Having those classes would help but as you know... for example if the company you work at doesn't fund your studies then self study... go out and buy books or the audio tapes to learn? no money??? claim benefits and then that will surely be then end of it as they will learn how easy it is to exploit our benefits system and staying on the dole is better than working... god this country is so messed up... lol
Stuart Eels:
I was thinking just that, the English expats in Spain that I have come across(there are obviously some that do learn the language and intergrate) are terrible at learning the language and becoming a part of the community.
On this basis, I am not sure how we can be so morally indignant to immigrants to the UK.
Ex-pats drawing their pensions out there in Spain, should certainly make the effort to learn the language, eat the food and integrate more.
Here, even Fabio Capello has made a valiant attempt to learn the lingo. Its hard, but he's slowly getting there and not using an interpreter.
Hopefully Englands prospects will improve with better communication.
There would have been none of this if the trade union closed shop had never been abolished. Requiring the production of a union card is no different from requiring the production of a British passport or a work permit. The closed shop was as important for that as it was for giving the Tory forty-five per cent of the industrial working-class a moderating influence in the selection of Labour candidates for the safe Labour seats in which they lived.
New Labour's repudiation of the trade union movement was very much like its repudiation of Clause IV. That Clause did not mention nationalisation, although it certainly allowed for it; it had been framed so that people who already had nationalisation in mind could read that presupposition into it, even though no one could have read that presupposition out of it. But Tony Blair and his fan club thought that it was about nothing else.
So, in repudiating it, they repudiated public ownership in order to repudiate everything that public ownership delivered and safeguarded, notably national sovereignty, the Union, and the economic basis of paternal authority. Likewise, in repudiating trade unionism, they repudiated controlled immigration and the moderating influence of the wider electorate in the affairs of the Labour Party. Mercifully, that last, at least, reasserted itself in the victory of Ed Miliband over the Blairite candidate.
What if they go to live in Wales?
does anyone care about Wales? (bad joke)... Thing is I don't think theres much incentive in Wales for them?
Overall i support the plans on paper anyway and agree immigration is a wider issue tied into other public services... however, it all depends if they are gonna implement it successfully...
It's a long time coming and Labour should have dealt with it...
What an unpleasant little man he is.
Some on the political-left really do need to wake-up and take notice. Multiculturalism has failed, along with Labour's religious fascist appeasement both will no longer be tolerated. Politices has changed and some on the left are playing catch-up.
It must be election time. Thats why Dave has bought out the 'race/immigration' card.
Stands to reason that all immigrants should learn English and go out into the community mix and integrate more, as well as doing a job of work. No one but the most bigoted would argue with that in which case they shouldn't be here, if they don't want to be a part of British Society.
But we also need those ESOL/ESL classes because adults need lessons in the language whereas youg kids will pick it up in 6 months t school in the playground. So why is the funding being cut. Is he expecting the communities themselves to provide classes, voluntarily? as part of their contribution to the BS?
Post new comment