The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

A successful jasmine revolution, but what next for Tunisia?

The toppling of Ben Ali will inspire oppressed people everywhere – but takes Tunisia into new territ

On Friday, the western media finally woke up to the "Jasmine Revolution" unfolding in Tunisia. After weeks of light coverage of events there, I was surprised to hear an in-depth report on Tunisia on BBC Radio 4 early on Friday morning. The New York Times despatched a reporter to the capital on Thursday, and the Guardian has been carrying stories on its home page daily. By the end of the week, people in the UK and US understood the gravity of events in Tunisia that Middle East watchers had been following for the past three weeks.

Despite President Ben Ali's best efforts to dissipate the energy in the protest movement, which began with the suicide of a young man frustrated at the Tunisian state for having confiscated the vegetable stall where he earned his livelihood, Tunisians gradually became more agitated, and the protest moved from distant towns and cities to the capital itself at the start of the week. Promises of huge investments in job-creation programmes and urgent democratic reforms were rejected by the nationwide movement, which brought together young and old, people in urban centres, small towns, working people and the middle classes. Despite the threat of lethal force, thousands of Tunisians took to the streets as the movement's potential became clear.

The focus of the uprising moved swiftly beyond jobs and the price of food to the corrupt and repressive regime that has been running the country since 1987. The Ben Ali dictatorship is seen as one of the most repressive anywhere in the world, having ruthlessly silenced opposition politics and the press since the early days of his presidency. Internet access has been widely available for years, but many foreign websites – for example, YouTube – are banned, permanently. The trade-off for Tunisians was the promise of a job and a good education, but widespread corruption, emanating from Ben Ali's own family, had reached so far and wide that ordinary people could feel its effects and the economic trade-off started to slip.

It became clear when the protest reached Tunis that the ultimate aim of the movement was a revolution, not just economic reform. Tunisians chanted anti-Ben Ali slogans and made their aims clear on the streets of the capital. I've watched Tunisia for years and I was astounded and impressed at the audacity of this uprising, considering the strength of the formal (police, secret service) and informal (neighbours, taxi drivers, etc) networks that worked to repress alternative political views and ensure the continuity of the regime. Tunisia, and particularly Tunis, can be intimidating at times, if you know how to spot the secret police agents posted on every corner of the capital, and it must have taken real courage for Tunisians to show their discontent in this way.

The regime was startled by the speed and voracity of events, and scrambled to hold on to power. Ben Ali announced on Thursday night that he would not run for election again in 2014, and after a general strike on Friday morning reduced his plea to just six more months as leader, promising a summer election for his replacement. It was clear, however, that after the 23-year period of his rule, mixing fear with shrewd economic management, impressive progress on women's rights and a moderate brand of Islam, the president would barely survive the weekend, let alone six months. The question became not if Ben Ali would fall, but what would happen after he fell: would there be a leadership vacuum and what would fill it?

Some western observers feared an extreme Islamist element would take advantage of any vacuum, but a close look at Tunisian society should calm such fears – Tunisia is no Algeria. Ben Ali's actions over decades to squash all opposition and free media comment resulted in the near-disappearance of a political class outside the regime itself, so there are no obvious national politicians ready to take over. The Tunisian constitution states that, in the event of a president losing power unexpectedly, the leader of parliament takes over, for a 45-day period, leading to new elections. The current leader of the Tunisian parliament is too old and frail to run the country; instead Prime Minister Ghannouchi, a senior member of the regime, led a palace coup and is now de facto president, his views on the next steps unclear. Ben Ali has sought refuge in Saudi Arabia, apparently having been refused entry to France.

Tunisia is reliant on tourism and foreign investment for prosperity. French, German, British and Russian tourists are being evacuated this weekend by the thousand, and western companies with a significant presence in the Maghreb economic powerhouse will be watching events carefully. If chaos ensues, the economic and social progress will rapidly become undone; Tunisia will lose its prized position as a beacon of economic success in Africa and the Arab world. It is vital that a period of calm now comes about – though early signs point to sporadic looting and violence. The interim government today announced elections in 60 days – Ghannouchi must make his intentions clear to give Tunisians confidence that they haven't swapped one dictator for another.

This scenario might be the best possible outcome of last week's successful uprising. Things might not turn out so benign. The final act of the dictator Ben Ali had its seeds sown many years ago when all opposition and alternative political leadership was squashed, and it's an act that could have long-term, damaging ramifications. The Jasmine Revolution is an inspiration for oppressed people everywhere, but it is taking Tunisia into unknown territory.

Luke Bozier writes on the Middle East and has run projects for the British Council in Tunisia.

49 comments

DouglassBishop's picture

The youths of Tunisia will bring this country together and make it stronger than before and I for one support them all the way. I congratulate them all and to the many that have lost their lives in this Revolution standing up for what they believe in they have died National Heroes and will never be forgotten. I salute you Tunisia. http://www.medicaldebtsconsolidation.com/

triedeinsursE's picture

andyg.

Please don't encourage him.

swatantra's picture

What happened to the Lavender Revolution, and what became of the Rose Revolution? Probably ran out of steam, as this one will, surely?

andyg's picture

@swatantra.
Although I agree with your first sentance I'm afraid that the Tunisian people could do very little when living in fear. If a vegetable seller has his stall confiscated one must ask to what extent this corrupt government would go to bully its people. The same relative situations are beginning to be uncovered in many governments of late and the same key fits all doors. The key of Greed, affluence, status, prestige, and power.

Ahmed R's picture

Baltazar, do you think Ban Ali or his wife can live in a Muslim country with a clear conscience all their life? No. At some point they will probably want to go and live in their many palaces in Europe or Canada. He must have looked a right idiot flying around for hours over Europe with his gold begging for refuge in until Saudi Arabia saved his arse.

ali's picture

why is it called jasmine revoution

andyg's picture

@freeman. Sorry mate but revolutions occur when thing's just can't get any worse. All those Tunisian people saw part of themselves in that vegetable seller. It is for him which became the piece of straw that broke the Camels back.
@Ehtch tee. Your a f******g disgrace.

jie4v7i14's picture

Cheers, andyg, tell me something I don't know, tosser.

Got at you did I, diddums, maybe.

Grow a set, like I have got hanging down to my knees between my legs.

Jo's picture

My husband is tunisian and is still in tunisia at the moment whilst I unfortunately am not. I fully support what the people of Tunisia stand up for, they work so hard and deserve a better life. The youths of Tunisia will bring this country together and make it stronger than before and I for one support them all the way. I congratulate them all and to the many that have lost their lives in this Revolution standing up for what they believe in they have died National Heroes and will never be forgotten. I salute you Tunisia.

andyg's picture

@Ehtch Tee.
You confuse audacity with wit my friend. I meant to write that your a f*****g disgrace to your fellow man. It is you that has reacted because you inform your audiance of where you keep your brain.
Toodle pip raisin.

jie4v7i14's picture

and fuck off you stalker/MI5 too.

A King Canute.

A disgrace... I am not a disgrace, surely...

fuck'im, song,

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qSPc5pcrqj0

jie4v7i14's picture

...and by the way, get your stones/lips off on this, works for me,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HIofSxwkkQE

Naughty? That's life.

jie4v7i14's picture

...but apologies to my islam friends above, this is how we do business in our country here, via sex slagging between each other, even if it does actually show female sex. But like Harems you could say, when everyone is away down your way, but maybe not...

I've said enough I think.

andyg's picture

oh dear,diddums.
The drugs don't work, that was the song son.

jie4v7i14's picture

andyg, I bet you loved it, you spermed/wet your pants, didn't you?

Come on, hide your British Empire reserve for once and say you fell about laughing like a simple man, ey?

jie4v7i14's picture

Seems you did. Hello efflng oh.

christ, more english to cope with.

How about tis english MI5, a good song in my reckon, in judgement for a lobng time with my people. Said song,

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Aj_cEP-PdA

jie4v7i14's picture

This is MI5 fecking positive policy to use fucking welsh, fucking useless - never saw one in coats, or it might be me there - hey, that is paranoia inland is, as in Tunisia.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x_2iDg2focw

andyg's picture

@tich Tee.
Why does everything have a sexual connection with you? Are you lonely, paranoid or just a simple being who is unable to debate an article.
By the way in Norway Canute is spelt, Knut.
Toodles K nutty.

jie4v7i14's picture

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyfXWSVaqUE

vision.

jie4v7i14's picture

jeexus, andyg, still on my case?

Sex, as the psycho-bablers say makes the world turn over, as you no doubt know it, as in this song, which yowill no doubt watch, closely, and etc..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GxSeMBWcoFs

andyg's picture

@Tich Tee square.
Is that it, have you given up at long last or are you still been entertained on your tube?
Toodle pip. (Big brothers watching you)

Des Demona's picture

Internet law number 32. A thread disintegrates in direct proportion to the number of youtube postings.

jie4v7i14's picture

andyg, as since 1966 watching Camberwick Green in Priory Street Primary School in Carmarthen, I have sinced worked out the nuts and bolts of our country, so don't ask me to suck plums, english-like, will you.

Song,http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KcoGU5i9E9s

andyg's picture

Your still not debating anything tich. Come on cock get the ball rolling. Your audiance is becoming tired of all this nonsense.
Now where was we, erm, yes, you been a little mean to your fellow man, without care or feeling for the suffering of others.

Careful what you say, we're onto you.
Toodle pip.

jie4v7i14's picture

YAWN! You have fallen into the typical english/MI5 trap, that you are getting to an average working man miner welshman.

Didn't you know the average old british celt was more intelligent than your rhine saxon, didn't you?

We sing better, for a start. And play the piano better. Even I can play the piano, and that is saying something.

andyg's picture

I wasn't aware that there was either a priory street primary school, or a Carmarthen in Tunisia.
We're all here laughing because we know you suck plums, but your still not debating anything.
TP

jie4v7i14's picture

Might as well post a link of Camberwick Green, it seems,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KAD-DgL2bdk

jie4v7i14's picture

Debate anything?

I thought I made my point elsewhere, our problem is the diversion of world power after WW2, unhealthly. I will go into it further, if you ask, nicely.

Olijaan's picture

‎Let it be an inspiration. 1901: Ahmed Abdul Aziz in Cairo, Egypt, tells the BBC World Service's World Have Your Say: "I'd like to congratulate the Tunisian people on the success of their peaceful revolution. They are opening the door for us; all Arab people live under the same circumstances, under the same oppressive regimes, the same dictators. What the Tunisian people did we will do in Egypt, in Syria and all over the Arabic world."

jie4v7i14's picture

Sut mar's hwul, badd am bwyty kinken bach, ie? At S4C teledu. Ie?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aCNT_oMtFUY

Welsh farmers moved to Canada, by the way, during Thatcher....

jie4v7i14's picture

Sut mae's hwyl, bedd am bwyty linken bach, ie? Ar S4C teledu. Ie?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aCNT_oMtFUY

Welsh farmers moved to Canada, by the way, during Thatcher....
Post your comment

This better show MI5,

jie4v7i14's picture

Can ayone answer me this simple answer now -what is the status que we should be following now?

No-one seems it seems.

Have they gone underground, planet of the apes like?

David Vinter's picture

Let's just hope the people manage to establish a stable, fair, democratic, government giving the general folk, a country with a great future!

Des Demona's picture

@ David Vinter
Seconded.
A lot of self interested people and organisations will be looking to slip into the power vacuum. I hope the brave people of aren't let down again.

kenneth warhurst's picture

I have visited Tunisia many times over the last 8 years.I have just returned from a week in Mahdia.Tunisia is not the same and is not a nice place to be.The people particularly the shopkeepers are more aggresive.The place is like one huge rubbish tip.I will not go again.

Ahmed R's picture

Marie Antoinette and Bernie Madoff cannot possibly hold a candle to Mrs Ben Aziz for greed and sheer audacity. How is it possible in the 21st century, can a leader's wife cart 1.5 tonnes of gold on to an Airbus and take off Scot free?? This has to be The heist for the record books. Any Western country that gives refuge to these petty criminals and their gold will be guilty of the same crimes as their colonial forefathers.

jie4v7i14's picture

Dates will be in short supply next xmas.

Raisins are so fiddly, aren't they?

Jim's picture

Ben Ali
The faith of Sadam, and the Shah of Iran awaiting you, You poor homeless cruppted little man.Run,but do not hide. Tell other Arab Kings they are the next one in line.

jie4v7i14's picture

well alright then send in the tanks as us pathetic infatile tend to do in times like this.

La Infintile, nous soms nutters,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkJ7pAnjTc8

Suppose what I said will make no difference if I will get a pack of dates from my rels next xmas?

Freeman2's picture

I enjoyed the way Channel 4 News showed us a shot of a plain clothes cop in the crowd beating someone up until the uniformed thugs arrived to give him a proper kicking. Were they trying to tell us something?

Freeman2's picture

'The jasmine revolution is an inspiration for oppressed people everywhere, but it is taking Tunisia into unknown territory.'

That's the nature of revolutions. If it was going into 'known territory' we'd know the CIA were organising it. And surely they're not. You know, to pre-empt an Islamist rising?

Jess's picture

Your tweets make you sound like a child.

triedeinsursE's picture

Tehran take note.

Mr Somalia's picture

The West created these hungry hyenas and when their regimes come to an end like all things; the West wants to alley itself with the people and pretend to be innocent.

Things will change and those oppressed people will be on the other end of the spectrum soon or later.

Ben Ali and his corrupted family can go to hell. The next dictators need to fall are Egypt, Algeria, Saudi Arabia and Jordan.

The Arabs will not be liberal but powerful nations.

Baltazar's picture

But Ben Ali and family was accepted by
an Arab country for asylum not a western country.

swatantra's picture

The gold should be returned and Mrs charged with theft. Its not their money; it belongs to the people. The Swiss Banks are a disgrace.It took less than a week for the Govt of Unity to collapse. Which means that the People are going to have to wait a little longer for change, and the domino theory on N African dictatorships is put on hold, indefinitely. The People have only themselves to blame for letting the situation continue.

Latest tweets