Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Hamas’s crackdown on Gaza’s youth

Closure of the Sharek Youth Forum reflects the growing influence of fundamentalists.

A student demonstration in support of the Sharek Youth Forum in Gaza City was brutally broken up by Hamas police yesterday, following the forced closure of the group's offices last Tuesday. Demonstration organisers claim a girl of 18 was beaten and 20 others were arrested on charges of protesting without a permit. At least three are still being held.

Sufian Mshasha, co-founder of Sharek, told us he was "happy that people in Gaza were still willing to stand up for causes they believe in", but expressed fears that the forum's supporters could face further intimidation.

Sharek's liberal agenda had resulted in frequent clashes with the Hamas government prior to its closure, which has announced that the forum is now under criminal investigation on unspecified charges. Sharek staff protest the closure is illegal and unjust.

In the past seven months, the group's offices have been repeatedly raided and members of staff have been subjected to physical intimidation, harassment and threats. During this time, the xecutive manager, Muheib Shaath, has been summoned to 15 separate interrogations from internal security. A summer camp run by Sharek in partnership with the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) was destroyed in May.

Mshasha told us the harassment and ultimate closure were "prompted by our agenda of democracy, social development, and our insistence on holding activities for both genders". He claimed that "80-90 per cent" of questioning of Sharek staff focused on their practice of encouraging both sexes to take part in their programmes.

Mshasha believes the closure is in violation of the 2000 charitable societies and NGOs law, which states: "The closure of any society or organisation should be according to a decision issued by a court of law." Despite verbal threats and an order from the attorney general, Mohammed Abed, no legal process took place to justify the police's actions.

Sharek, which also has offices in Ramallah, has a broad mandate to promote youth empowerment in the Palestinian territories. It serves 65,000 children in Gaza, through capacity-building, education workshops and social activities. Some of these have been perceived to violate sharia law, including concerts and a mixed-gender trip to the beach.

The forum has also come under fire for its links to UNRWA, from which it receives funding, and other international organisations.

Shasha claims the group is sensitive to Gaza's conservative environment. "Our director is an observant Muslim, our IT technician wears a burqa. Almost all the women wear traditional Islamic dress and all our volunteers are from Gaza." He also denies Sharek is opposed to Hamas: "We hold all political groups accountable [for failing to promote youth empowerment], but Hamas take our actions as accusations."

Sharek has enjoyed a good relationship with high-ranking members of the Hamas administration. Prime Minister Ismael Haniyeh is said to have supported its cause, but to have been unable to protect it from more conservative elements of his government.

The Gaza journalist Mohammed Mohanna believes this exemplifies a worrying lack of central control. "There are three parts of Hamas: military, government and the mosque groups [dowas]. The mosque leaders are very powerful. They influence the government by saying, 'Look what these associations do, they are all bitches and motherfuckers, they are against Islam.'

"It creates a lot of pressure. They have been campaigning against shisha pipes in coffee shops and women without hijabs."

He believes Hamas officials infiltrate associations like Sharek in order to control them. "They change the faces, run it differently and do what they want."

The increased pressure on development groups such as Sharek was demonstrated by the recent closure of two associated organisations, although these were run by the municipality itself. "It's crazy, but sometimes the decisions are just stupid, they don't have a plan," Shasha says.

Since the closure is technically temporary rather than permanent, Sharek is unable to bring a legal case against it. The group hopes to win enough popular support, which Shasha claims has been coming in waves in Gaza, to force the government to reverse the action. Sharek is petitioning prominent politicians in the West Bank and Gaza to come to its aid.

Shasha believes the principle is too important to let go. "The fundamentalist elements measure adherence to Islam by how boys and girls dress," he says. "This latest move is a very dangerous indication of their influence."

When Hamas was elected in 2006, it was with a commitment not to impose sharia law and a pledge to accept pluralism in society. "This is why they won the election," Shasha says. "All our efforts now are to make them respect the promise."

Kieron Monks is a freelance reporter and editor of the Palestine Monitor news website, based in Ramallah.

17 comments

DouglassBishop's picture

We can't see the ISLAM in such behavior of violence,closure, threats,,, etc. Hey guys!!! the Islam is the religion in which respecting the individual's freedom is highly prioritized. WE ARE ALL SHAREK. We are all PALESTINIAN. how can we seek the solidarity for our issue, while our internal body is fighting in that way. Please remember that, for free Palestine we have to support each other. http://www.medicaldebtsconsolidation.com/

Luddite's picture

Left Is Forward
06 December 2010 at 23:20
This is the reason we should bar believing Christians from government positions in the UK. The Labour party was founded on Christian principles. Jesus Christ was probably the first revolutionary lefty. The Labour party is a broad church NOT a Marxist political-sect.

Sharek's picture

I work with Sharek in the West Bank. This cannot be left to go un-noticed and I urge readers to take action to help Sharek reverse the decision. If it is not reversed, Sharek will not be the last organisation to be closed.

http://www.sharek.ps/gaza-take-action
http://www.sharek.ps/gaza-youth-work-forbidden

Sharek's picture

UN Statement: Top UN humanitarian official in Gaza concerned over closure of youth NGO (Sharek)

http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=36979&Cr=Gaza&Cr1=

Reuven's picture

It is ludicrous to think that Israel has anything to do with Hamas elections in Gaza. There wont be elections in Gaza because Hamas knows they could not win another election with their record of provoking war with missile attacks against Israel and suppression of freedoms in Gaza.

Palestinian's picture

I'm one from many who were working with SHAREK. For one year I lived in that family, worked in enthusiastic and different way. And now, If I'm in a position of choice I will choose SHAREK again and again to work with. Simply SHAREK supports the youth regardless of their political view. Their agenda is one of the most important agendas toward rebuilding the thought of the Palestinian youth on objective liberal way, and support them to be able to take a decision for their future, since they are the "future leaders". We can't see the ISLAM in such behavior of violence,closure, threats,,, etc. Hey guys!!! the Islam is the religion in which respecting the individual's freedom is highly prioritized. WE ARE ALL SHAREK. We are all PALESTINIAN. how can we seek the solidarity for our issue, while our internal body is fighting in that way. Please remember that, for free Palestine we have to support each other.

W. A.

Marc's picture

Thanks to the New Statesman for this thourough analysis. Thanks as well @Sharek for his links. Hamas just shows her totalitarian attitude. Just recently she declared the Holocaust as an "zionist invention". Hamas decries Israel as a militaristic state but she herself cracks down on liberal youth organisations. This is just a mismatch.
http://www.transatlantikblog.de/2010/12/19/hamas-wissen-uber-holocaust-u...

swatantra nandanwar's picture

Looks like its not just the Coalition which is have a few difficulties with its revolting students. Its a disgrace that Hamas are not sticking to their election promises of no to Sharia and yes to a pluralist society. When is the next election? Hope they listen to their students who are the voice of the future. If they don't change their ways Hamas don't deserve to be re-elected. Wonder if Hamas will do away with elections altogether like many other Arab Govts.

Homo Sapiens's picture

swatantra, I don't expect Israel to permit free elections again in the forseeable future - once bitten, twice shy. The presidential election is already a year late. Isreal has also destroyed the parliametary building and imprisoned a large proportion of MPs.

MatthewBlott's picture

Why does Mehdi Hasan never write articles like this?

Des Demona's picture

'Why does Mehdi Hassan never write articles like this?'

because his self-invented Qataraphobia is obviously on the rise and has to be stamped out!!! lol

Hans Castorp's picture

@Matthew, Des: Indeed!

Thank goodness the NS still occassionally posts reports from people actually in Palestine, instead of dessicated grandees like Chomsky.

In that way we are reminded of what Hamas really means for Gazans.

swatantra nandanwar's picture

Is it that bad that Gaza has to get permission off the Israelis as to holding elections? My answer to that is for Hamas to stick 2 fingersr up to Israelis, and Fatah, and go ahead and hold those elections starting off with the Presidential one followed by the Parliamentary ones. That Hamas manadate must be renewed otherwise Hamas can't claim they are the voice of Gaza.

MatthewBlott's picture

@ Des Demona, Hans Castorp

I'm starting to think Melanie Phillips has a point. Don't get me wrong, I'm not blind to Israel's crimes but the fact its Arab citizens enjoy far greater human rights and freedoms than they would under a Hamas government is an irony that's lost on Mehdi Hassan and others.

Left Is Forward's picture

This is the reason we should bar believing Christians from government positions in the UK.

Tal's picture

I'm surprised that people are shocked at this. Hamas has always, and always will be a totalitarian militaristic organization seeking to impose Sharia law. No surprise there. It does NOT base its values in democracy, humanitarianism or liberal rights, whatever it promises in order to win elections.

Empower liberal youth, encourage cross-border economies, and you'll see the Israelis soften up and be more receptive to mutually beneficial deals. As long as Hamas are in power they will repress local groups and keep antagonising Israel, ruining their chance of establishing a viable independent Palestinian state.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets