The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Climate loans threaten rerun of Copenhagen

UK loans to low income countries will make the poor pay twice for climate change

On Thursday, International Development Secretary Andrew Mitchell promised to stump up funds to ensure developing countries are better heard in climate negotiations. But it is difficult to see how those countries could be any clearer than they were last year at the disastrous Copenhagen climate summit - the problem is that the British government isn't listening.

At the end of next week, delegates from across the world will start arriving in Cancun for the follow-up to Copenhagen. They do so in the shadow of the World Bank's announcement of $270 million for three countries - Bangladesh, Niger and Tajikistan - to help them cope with the effects of climate change, for instance by protecting coastlines and planting crops more resilient to flooding.

These funds will be enhanced by others and ultimately the money comes from developed country governments like that of the UK. The problem is that much of the money will come not in the form of grants but low-interest loans. The total package given to Bangladesh, for instance, is $624 million, of which 92% comes in the form of loans. $60 million of these loans have come from the UK Government.

Why is this a problem? Because it contradicts the main principle which developing countries are fighting for in climate negotiations - that rich countries must not only reduce their emissions substantially but they must pay for poorer countries to clean up the devastation caused by climate change, not to mention helping those countries to develop in a more sustainable manner now they are denied the 'cheap development' which has fuelled wealth in the West.

Instead, offering loans attempts to make developing countries pay twice - first because they are suffering the worst consequences of climate change, but second because they now have to pick up the tab for that chaos when they repay their loans. That's why developing countries and campaign groups are united that these loans are completely unacceptable.

The developing countries involved in this first tranche of funding cannot be regarded as anything other than very poor. All are defined as low income. Bangladesh already has a high debt - $23.6 billion and rising, despite the country paying over $1billion a year servicing that debt.

Niger owes much less - but only because it received over $1 billion of debt relief in 2004 after struggling with unjust debts for over a decade. Meanwhile Tajikistan is already at high risk of a debt crisis according to the International Monetary Fund.

Forcing these countries to pay for their own clean-up is rather like breaking into your neighbour's house, causing devastation, and lending them money to get the cleaners in.

UK funds are all channelled through the World Bank, rather than a special United Nations fund which has been created through international agreement. This too is contentious. The UN Fund has a unique bottom-up approach to finance - any country can apply to it, and that country retains a good deal of control over how the project is implemented.

The World Bank, on the other hand, is top-down - selecting which countries should receive climate financing - and hypocritically remains one of the world's largest supporters of fossil fuel projects. In fact the UK has made the World Bank's funding even worse than it otherwise would have been; the Bank says that the only reason it is giving loans is because the UK has provided its money as capital rather than a grant.

None of this sits well with the pre-election commitments of the governing parties. Liberal Democrat party policy is to "support the UN Adaptation Fund" and to provide "grants for communities vulnerable to the impact of climate change without increasing the burden on indebted countries". Conservative party policy is to "continue, as far as possible, to give aid as grants not loans" and to "encourage other donors" to do the same.

Perhaps it's little wonder that expectations are being vigorously managed ahead of Cancun. But let's not pretend it's because developing countries can't be heard. Any progress towards a just climate solution depends on rich countries starting to listen pretty quickly.

Nick Dearden is the director of Jubilee Debt Campaign

21 comments

David Vinter's picture

These climate change conferences are nonsense, until the world not only limits its population voluntarily and slowly, then disaster is on the cards! Curently the rate of growth of population exceeds the rate of growth of world food output. Nothing brings a country to its senses faster than srarvation.

zzllaq's picture

welcome come to our ( http://madejerseys.org/ )
website:
everybody!sorry bother your time a min,we are serious and professional
jersey supplier,we can offer NFL,NHL,MLB,NBA jerser,the NFL jersey 18usd each,
the NHL jersey 38USD each.MLB jersey 18usd each,
NAB jersey 18usd each.we have many jerseys of other players,
so please contact us for more information if you are interested in .
1) More pictures available on our website (http://madejerseys.org/ )
2) Many colors available .
3) Perfect quality, small order accepted .
4) 100% safe door to door delivery, within 5 - 7 days air express for small orders .
5) We have lots of jerseys in stock
6) Letters and number are sewn on b2cshop body, 100% embroidery
7) Size: .48, 50, 52, 54, 56, 60
8) Delivery by UPS, DHL, EMS door to door
9) Delivery in 5 - 7 days NFL,NBA,MLB all are 18usd!!!! The jerseys in stock may be updated everyday !
come on,join us! ( http://madejerseys.org/ )

Fruitbat's picture

NS - can't you stop all these f*ing spammers in the comments section? Other political commentary sites don't seem to have this problem.

zzllaq's picture

http://fashionboots.hk/
http://fashionboots.hk/
http://fashionboots.hk/
U-gg Boots
U-GG Nightfall Boots
U-GG Coquette Slipper
U-GG Sundance Limited Edition
U-GG Classic Argyle Knit
U-GG Bailey Button Boots
U-GG Classic Cardy Boots
U-GG Classic Tall Boots
U-GG Classic Short Boots
U-GG Ultra Tall Boots
U-GG Classic Tall Metallic
U-GG Sundance II Boots
U-GG Ultra Short Boots
U-GG Classic Mini Boots
http://fashionboots.hk/
http://fashionboots.hk/
http://fashionboots.hk/
╭⌒╮⌒╮.’,”’,,’,.”,,’,”,.
╱◥██◣”o’,”’,,’,.”.”,,’,.
|田|田田│ ”,,’,.’,”’,,’,.”
╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬╬e:

shoestrade52's picture

========= http://www.1shopping.us/ =========

Best regards for you all,

Looking forward to your visiting.

========= http://www.1shopping.us/ =========

========= http://www.1shopping.us/ =========

Best regards for you all,

Looking forward to your visiting.

========= http://www.1shopping.us/ =========

bbei18's picture

welcome to :
===== http://doiop.com/afl412 ======
U-GG Nightfall Boots
U-GG Coquette Slipper
U-GG Sundance Limited Edition
U-GG Classic Argyle Knit
U-GG Bailey Button Boots
U-GG Classic Cardy Boots
U-GG Classic Tall Boots
U-GG Classic Short Boots
U-GG Ultra Tall Boots
U-GG Classic Tall Metallic
U-GG Sundance II Boots
U-GG Ultra Short Boots
U-GG Classic Mini Boots
===== http://doiop.com/afl412 =====
+++ http://doiop.com/afl412 +++

llog622's picture

========= http://clothesmall.org =========

Best regards for you all,

Looking forward to your visiting.

========= http://clothesmall.org =========

meimeihg's picture

====== http://www.clshoe.us/ ==========

====== http://www.clshoe.us/ ==========

====== http://www.clshoe.us/ ==========

Wonderful
Share a website with you ,
input url in google sirch
(http://www.clshoe.us)
Believe you will love it

Missy Elliot's picture

@swatantra nandanwar
23 November 2010 at 14:55
The west is responsible in the sense that our medical advances made it possible for these people to breed beyond the limits of their own Malthusian sustainability.
You believe your own crap, do you ? Even our gap year students seeing the situation in India and elsewhere for themselves, do not believe this.

shoestrade6779's picture

Best regards for you all,

Looking forward to your visiting.

http://www.1shopping.us/

Best regards for you all,

Looking forward to your visiting.

http://www.1shopping.us/

Best regards for you all,

Looking forward to your visiting.

http://www.1shopping.us/

Missy Elliot's picture

@Fruitbat
These spammers are at least trying to make a dishonest crust in a socialist give away society!

Luddite's picture

Man-made climate change is a proven lie!! The real problem for the worlds ecosystems is overpopulation.
And quite frankly the rest is bull-shit.

jie4v7i14's picture

Climate, shlimate, who is caring anyway these days?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4AdtfCm9gE0

historybuff's picture

The Tajikistan problem has nothing to do with either capitaliusm or climate change; its problems with it's lakes are caused by the continuing effects of Soviet era water diversion policies. And yet they're apparently getting a third of this $270m fund to offset climate change on it's 'coastline'!

swatantra's picture

An excellent article drawin atention to the duplicity of the West who are responsible for the state of climate change. And instead of cutting down on emissions by the most direct methods, do so by trading C credits.
In the meantime the West attempt to keep the LDC in continuous bondage by 'loans' and add to their ever increasing debt. Basically the West are living beyond their means and ned to reduce their consumption of energy and provide reparation for the damage they've caused to the livlihood of those on a subsistance level. But we'll never get an admission of guilt or repentance from them.

jie4v7i14's picture

Well put, swantantra, and a video it has become a habit of mine to post on NS - Brooks, Wilde, Marcheaux, Alice in Wonderland, New Yawk, and other thoughts....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9iHXo13tJEE

dgbhfgjfkgfh's picture

Click on our website (= = = = = http:/nta.us// = = = = = ) Will bring you different surprise ===== http:/nta.us// ...

schotte300's picture

Wonderful.

Share a website with you ,

input url in google sirch

=== http://bit.ly/bbenTr ====

Believe you will love it

Latest tweets