Being untouchable no longer
Increasingly powerful voices in India are calling for a true end to discrimination based on caste.
By David Griffiths Published 28 October 2010 13:36
When President Obama visits India next month, it is quite certain that he will pay tribute to Mahatma Gandhi, perceived around the world as one of history's most celebrated symbols of liberation, and a source of inspiration for the US president himself.
But there are calls within India for Obama to look further than Gandhi in paying homage to Indian heroes. For India's community of 167 million Dalits, once known as "untouchables", the true icon is Dr B R Ambedkar. Himself an untouchable, Dr Ambedkar gained doctorates from Columbia University, where President Obama, too, was educated, and at the London School of Economics, before becoming the architect of independent India's new constitution.
Relatively little-known internationally, Ambedkar has accrued almost divine status as a focal point for Dalit aspirations. Within India, Ambedkar appears everywhere. His statues easily outnumber those of Gandhi. Deep in communities of Dalits, you will hear the greeting, "Jai Bhim", meaning "hail Bhimrao [Ambedkar]". You will see his portrait in any self-assertive Dalit's home, and his name is spoken with pride. When, in 2006, the nation marked the 50th anniversary of his death, over 800,000 Dalits crowded to pay him their respects in Mumbai.
Dalits stress that, unlike the Mahatma, Ambedkar challenged the very existence of the caste system as the basis for discrimination against Dalits. It is because of Ambedkar, they say, that Dalits play any role in India's political and administrative structures – albeit a limited part. That is why anti-caste activists are urging Obama to pay homage to Ambedkar as a true giant of the cause of liberation from oppression.
These calls are just one sign of the increasingly powerful vocalisation of Dalit aspirations for recognition of their cause, and for social, economic and cultural equality. Dalit hopes for liberation from caste oppression – and it is important to add that Dalits suffer discrimination in every religious community – are resonating increasingly loudly around the world. The issue has gained profile at the United Nations, the UN Committee for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination having charged the Indian government to bring about clear improvements in a number of areas. NGOs continue to press companies investing in India to tailor their corporate social responsibility policies to address the specific challenges of caste discrimination.
Two campaigners against caste discrimination, S Anand and Meena Kandasamy, visited London last week to highlight the cause by speaking at events around a photography exhibition, "Being Untouchable".
The exhibition, by Marcus Perkins for CSW, offered a sympathetic series of portraits of the many different faces of untouchability in modern India, in a powerful reminder of the plight of the tens of millions of victims among the Dalits: the woman who cleans excrement from a dry latrine because it is her caste job; the young girl pushed into burning ashes because she walked on a path reserved for "high" castes who may never get justice; the destitute who may always be excluded from education and opportunities. Theirs are the stories that truly need to be heard amid the cacophony of coverage of India's economic boom.
Reading from her deeply moving 2006 poetry collection at the launch last week, Meena Kandasamy offered a poignant reminder of the depth of Dalit aspirations for drastic change:
We will rebuild worlds from shattered glass and
remnants of holocausts.
[. . .] It will begin the way thunder rises in our throats and we
will brandish our slogans with a stormy stress and
succeed to chronicle to convey the last stories
of our lost and scattered lives.
David Griffiths is south Asia team leader at Christian Solidarity Worldwide.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists



















8 comments
The caste system is just apartheid by another name. It's appalling and unacceptable that people can be classed as "untouchable". India thinks of itself as a modern democracy, so how can it allow this to continue?
@Left is Forward: You make some good points, but the Dalits themselves seem to want this practice to end, so perhaps they would welcome any outside help, no matter where it came from?
Yes David lets look at what Ambedkar said shall we? In his 1916 book "Castes in India" he wrote:
"The Brahmins may have been guilty of many things, and I dare say they were, but the imposing of the caste system on the non-Brahmin population was beyond their mettle. They may have helped the process by their glib philosophy, but they certainly could not have pushed their scheme beyond their own confines. ... I have urged so much on the adverse side of this attitude, not because the religious sanctity is grounded on scientific basis, nor to help those reformers who are preaching against it. Preaching did not make the caste system; neither will it unmake it."
http://www.columbia.edu/itc/mealac/pritchett/00ambedkar/txt_ambedkar_cas...
While this is a very beautiful story, the fact that David Griffiths is a leader of "Christian Solidarity Worldwide" indicates that a note of caution should be held.
Christian organisations have long used the caste system in India to their advantage, targetting the lowest castes for conversion to their barbaric, outdated and irrational set of prejudices (i.e. "religion") and then boasting about how this pre-medievalisation of India is actually "improving" it by reducing caste divisions. In fact it is creating an even more dangerous set of socio-cultural divisions - religious dividing lines, where their alien faith is set up to clash with native ones. (It can't help intercommunity relations that Christians are so set on prosletysing, increasing their numbers at the expense of Hindus, Buddhists and Muslims, and also believe that the unconverted, "unsaved" natives are going to go to Hell. Puts quite a smacker on achieving friendly neighbourly relations, that.)
So we have the ultimate irony of an alien superstition invading India, using the caste divisions as the basis for the spread of its mind-virus, then claiming international legimitacy (including here) on the basis of reducing the very caste divisions it needs to survive, all the time creating a deeper and more dangerous set of social faultlines.
I think it's woeful that the NS would allow such a biased missionary group to comment here, without at least a right of reply to native Indian groups appalled at the human rights abuse constituted by the destruction of their native culture at the hands of an invading faith organisation.
The caste system is institutionalized racism. The fact that it has a firm hold in the 21 st century speaks for itself. Hindus everywhere have it. Even if you leave it, it won't leave you. Tragic and shameful.
Ranbir Singh
30 October 2010 at 22:32
OK. mate lets blame the caste system on the tooth fairies then . You had no part in Sikh terror I know. You probably do think donating a few quid has no effect. When one of you prats stands up and takes responsibility for your own shit there will be a mass outbreak of non racism.
Reply to Dear Nelson, If caste is regilion then better you keep it yourself and do what job/work is now done by Dalit.i.e removing human remains, removing skin of animal...etc.
Caste is not regilion, it is symbol of exploitation by one man by another.It will be better to finish or remove words "Hindu" from world map, otherwise India will lost once again its freedom.
caste is religion. you cannot separate caste from religion.It is not just a social division. it has been a strategy of the lazy to exploit other people who are considered to be lower, weak and impure.
Left Is Forward, another reason why a Christians POV might not be completely neutral on this issue, is that Christian Dalits have been displaced by the tens of thousands in pogroms recently. 50,000 were dishomed in Orissa in 2008. Nobody knows the death toll yet.
http://www.christianpost.com/article/20100129/india-finally-allows-eu-to...
Attacks continue too. Some of the more recent pogroms were ostensibly in retaliation against "attacks" on Indian students in Australia.
http://www.zenit.org/article-28177?l=english
I guess any victim will do.