The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Phil Woolas's day in court

Labour MP faces expulsion from Parliament over election campaign smears.

It's going to be an uncomfortable day for former Labour minister Phil Woolas, who's in court fighting an attempt to have his election victory overturned on the grounds of "corrupt practices".

Woolas's Lib Dem opponent, Elwyn Watkins, who lost by just 103 votes at the election, took legal action after a demagogic leaflet by the MP (see below) suggested that the Lib Dems were courting support from Islamic extremists. On another occasion, Woolas and his campaign team doctored a police photo (see below) to make it appear as if Watkins had been arrested.

Leaflet

A campaign leaflet claimed that Islamic extremists "want you to vote Lib Dem to punish Phil".

Police

A doctored photo made it appear as if Lib Dem candidate Elwyn Watkins had been arrested.

The Lib Dems' central contention is that such "misleading" material swung a tightly-fought election in Labour's favour. Legal documents submitted to the High Court appear to confirm that there was a calculated attempt by the Woolas campaign to whip up racial tensions in the area in a bid to get the "white vote" behind him.

An email by Woolas's election agent, Joseph Fitzpatrick, to the candidate declared: "we need ... to explain to the white community how the Asians will take him out ... If we don't get the white vote angry he's gone." Another from Fitzpatrick to Steve Green, the MP's campaign adviser, said: "we need to go strong on the militant Moslem angle" and proposed the headline "Militant Moslems target Woolas."

A defeat for Woolas (who remains a frontbench spokesman) would see him expelled from Parliament and a by-election held in the extremely marginal seat of Oldham East and Saddleworth. He has pledged to "robustly defend" himself. But whether he loses or not, let's hope that Woolas finally apologises for one of the most disgraceful election campaigns in recent history.

37 comments

swatantra's picture

Wonder if Joanna Lumley will come to his assistance; he was under a lot of pressure at the time?
But there are no excuses for this alledged behaviour if itis is found libellous.
In these circumstances, as a general point, if any MP is expelled, then instead of a bye election, the seat should be given to the runner up.
That may be a deterrent in future for MPs erring. The same should be the case if any MP loses the Whip and tries to cross the floor. We have too many instances of MPs feeling they can do whatever they like.

Helen's picture

I'm not sure I agree about that swatantra nandanwar.

Although in this case I think the sitting MP should be slung out on his ear, it still goes against the general principle that courts should stay out of elections.

The court will decide whether Woolas committed a corrupt practice. If he hasn't, he'll stay. If he has, he'll be barred from public office. As a result of that he will no longer be an MP. Hence there being a byelection.

There's a world of difference between that and a judge or pair (couple? brace?) of judges getting rid of one fellow and appointing another. MPs are elected, not appointed.

David Paul Sheard's picture

If you think this is one of the most disgraceful campaigns in recent History. You are demonstrating either your bias or ignorence

Attrition47's picture

Let's hope that the former Minister for Racism gets his just deserts.

Well said Dave Wearing.

Tom's picture

It would be marvelous is Woolas lost his seat over this disgraceful conduct. Given the garbage put in election leaflets by all parties it can only be good if finally someone is brought to book.

jie4v7i14's picture

Phil Woolas has dug a bit of a hole for himself here, and has a few uncomfortable months ahead of him. It sounds as if he has been a bit of an arse in the last few years, as subtle as a breeze block in his re-election tactics.

What's the latest on Goldsmith and his jackets? Or has it been drowned in expensive litigation and being suffocated for media reporting?

Sam's picture

It's strange how the party most disillusioned Labour supporters are likely to switch to is the BNP, isn't it?

thinkov's picture

Coiurt appearance is happening a few doors from me

will be a 5 day hearing they reckon

off on thursday may get a look in

If he loses I thought it'd be a re run ?

Don't care who wins or loses here

they're both appalling . I would have thought the lib dems would lose by more votes on a re run

seeing as how the worse lie was their no cuts bull

Helen's picture

It's not a re-run as Woolas would be barred from public office if he loses. Hell, he'd be barred from voting. But there's some way to go yet.

I presume that you got the Labour literature during the election then? what did you make of it?

Marcus's picture

This type of electioneering is sickening. Well done NS for mentioning the case.

Left Is Forward's picture

Actually I appreciate Woolas' stand against political Islam. We need more MPs capable of fighting against religion in the political sphere - more opposition to political Christianity is sorely needed. Political Islam currently poses a more radical threat but we must remember political Christianity is more widespread and just as insidious (even in bizarre forms such as "Christian Socialism" - have these people not read Marx?).

Woolas seems to have crossed the line into anti-Asian rather than anti-Islamic hectoring. That was a mistake that he deserves to pay for. Racial discrimination has no place in progressive politics.

Helen's picture

There is a political argument, and there is photoshopping some London-based criminals to make it look as though they're somehow linked to your Oldham-based opponent.
The racial aspects of Woolas' campaign were exceedingly distasteful. I'm not sure that's the illegal bit though.

I'm not sure there are many politicians who wouldn't take legal action if they were accused of taking brown envelopes from murky foreign businessmen, smuggling it into the country and illegally funding his campaign with it.

Helen's picture

I'm not sure whether this site allows links, but the opening comments from Team Woolas are available on the Manchester Evening News site.

Helen's picture

Sorry, it's Watkins' side's opening, not Woolas'.

"Mr Woolas made these false statements as part of a series of reckless and irresponsible steps in this campaign - using doctored photographs, misrepresenting facts, stooping even to fomenting racial divisions and tensions."

Dave C's picture

You can see the badly doctored photo in its context at: http://www.electionleaflets.org/full.php?q=6100#l14875

I can't see any justification for it, much as I like Phil Woolas.

jie4v7i14's picture

Coming on the outside, Kashif Ali could very well be a winner in a re-run. Tory vote up almost 4,000 on 2005.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oldham_East_and_Saddleworth_(UK_Parliament_constituency)

Wonder if he was an air-drop candidate by Dave? Oh dear, looks like it, quote,
"When Mr Ali was selected as the Conservative candidate last year, the party’s local constituency chair Barbara Jackson stood down, complaining Mr Ali had been forced on them by the central party. However, Mr Ali said today that “just two people” left the association during the row, and he insisted the “vast majority” of Conservatives in the area are behind him."
link, http://www.saddleworthnews.com/?p=1358

David Wearing1's picture

New Labour: it starts with Blair attacking the Tories from the right, and it ends in the grotesque chaos of Phil Woolas whipping up race hatred to save his worthless career.

Disgusting.

swatantra's picture

@Sam. The Party has always contained a small element of supporters that would have more affinity with the the BNP and UKIP than Labour, but they've been either too lazy or too tribal to their working class roots to actually vote other than Labour. I'm pretty sure you've come across the type. But now that they the Party has been cleansed of that very small element, it would be better if they didn't return. The Party is a lot better off without them.

jie4v7i14's picture

Enoch Powell anyone?

Harry's picture

Ditto, Attrition and Dave Wearing. Let's hope it's the end for another Nu£abour spiv.

jie4v7i14's picture

PHIL WOOLAS IS BEING HIGH COURT JUDGE TORY SUPPORTER VICTIMISED _ CAN YOU NOT SEE IT.

jie4v7i14's picture

Well I can see it - it is an SE England NE England stistch up.

Plain as day with that cheat Zac about.

jie4v7i14's picture

NW England stitch up, even.

SE England tory cun-I-help you,
song, for NW England, not those SE cups,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KcoGU5i9E9s

jie4v7i14's picture

Thatcher stole millions from Northern England in her time, millions, yes fecking millions.

jie4v7i14's picture

And I mean pounds, let alone people.

jie4v7i14's picture

And where was the detail on the sale of the Stretford/St.Pancreas - Channel Tunnel details in the press, Dave? Behind Times paywall, with your mates?

jie4v7i14's picture

What Phil Woollas has done is very small potatoes compared to that cont our Prime Minister has got in his den, fecking Andy Coulson.

You Judge Shits.

jie4v7i14's picture

Funny you get let of for things in London that woyld put you away for five years in Northern England.

People need to be told about these carry ons by you judges.

thinkov's picture

@Helen

it was so far fetched it de sensitized me

...like all of it really

I was more shocked at watkins taking such umbrage....which looks bad on me really as it was stupidly far fetched rubbish

jeremiah's picture

Ha Ha! The Lib Dems complaining about "dirty" tactics!

NS should run a story about all the s*it they have pulled over the years, particularly in by-election campaigns.

Clem the Gem's picture

It is immaterial whether or not the LibDems and Tories run nasty racist/homophobic campaigns - as we know they have.
Woolas and his agent should be expelled for bringing the party into disrepute - along with Mandy.

chris's picture

@jeremiah

Exactly what I was thinking!!! Their own election handbook tells them to lie and cheat!

If Woolas is on trial over this then so should Nick Clegg for his 35 metre squared VAT bombshell billboard!!!

jie4v7i14's picture

Ol' Nicky Clegg and the rest of the LibDem gobshites do not have a leg to stand on after their fawning to Tory tossrs since May.

So pathetic as recent history, you could not have written it as fiction in April last.

Helen's picture

Goodness. I think this is why the Labour Party is often accused of being tribalist. As Woolas said of Mandy after the Little&Sadd byelection "He might be a bstard, but he's our bstard".

Is it not possible, regardless of what you think the opposition has done in the past, of saying "No, actually, he's stepped over a line here. He can't stay in our party?"

Andrea Gill's picture

I by NO means want to defend Woolas, but from the emails etc which will be shown in court, it sounds like it should be Mr Woolas' agent on trial alongside him

Helen's picture

Do we have to wait for an official verdict before the Labour Party will do anything? Is the racism not enough to see him expelled? I thought that the left were meant to be hot on equality rights? Is that just another myth that's been shattered before my very eyes?

After all, equating all muslims with "mad moslem" terrorists isn't exactly going to help race relations in a town known for race riots. But still, gotta "get those white folk angry"...

Helen's picture

Andrea: Woolas' agent IS on trial beside him. "Washed up ex-councillor on trial" just isn't as good a headline.

Latest tweets