The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

This was not the disaster for Labour that many feared

The party has not suffered a 1983-style wipeout.

With 46 seats left to declare, the Conservatives have conceded that there is now no chance of David Cameron emerging with an overall majority from this election. At best, the Tories hope to win roughly 310 seats, leaving them 16 short of a majority.

Labour must now do all it can to win over the Lib Dems, most obviously by offering Nick Clegg's party a referendum on proportional representation. Its attempt to do so has been helped by the fact that its losses have been nowhere near as severe as some feared.

As things stand, Labour has 241 seats. That's more than the party won in 1983 and 1987 and significantly more than the Tories won in 1997, 2001 and 2005. The electoral wipeout that some feared did not come to pass.

Meanwhile, although big names such as Charles Clarke, Jacqui Smith and Tony McNulty have fallen, not a single cabinet minister has lost his or her seat. Neither Alistair Darling nor Ed Balls provided the "Portillo moment" that so many hoped for.

Finally, after weeks of level-pegging with the Lib Dems in the opinion polls, Labour has reaffirmed its position as the dominant centre-left party. Clegg's claim that the election had turned into a "two-horse race" between the Tories and the Lib Dems now looks astonishingly hubristic.

The newly humbled Lib Dems may well be tempted to form a partnership of principle with Labour, rather than an alliance of convenience with the Tories. But Clegg's desire to avoid forming "an alliance of the defeated" is still likely to prove fatal for Brown.

Follow the New Statesman team on Facebook.

4 comments

cameronp's picture

It's all too early to call, the dust has to settle and reality rather than speculation kicks in. What is clear, however, is that the Tories remain predominantly an English party. Any links with other parties in coalition would be extremely difficult to maintain.

Gabriella Coscia's picture

However, I would argue Labour have no moral or political right to maintain a government the South East of England Labour have no representation and the Conservatives have the largest share of the vote and clearly won the largest number of seats, Brown and Labour do not have a mandate to rule and I do not think the second largest area of England in terms of population will sit quietly and allow a delusional power obsessed man to continue in government without their being consequences for the government, and the country in terms of social unrest if you want riots carry on Mr Brown

swatantra's picture

The country doesn't want a Conservative Govt thats why they never gave Cameron a majority. It was always gong to be hung. What the country really wants is a Centre Left coalition with Labour and Lib Dems working together and Brown to remain as PM and sort out the economy. When he's done that in 18 months he can step down with dignity and call a GE called. In exchange we get a fairer electoral system, scrap Trident and pull troops out of conflict areas. Labour can do all that with the help of the Lib Dems. It has to be a coalition with some Lib Dems at the Cabinet Table. So Lance Price is talking complete nonsense. Labour has the right to continue to govern and should not go into opposition.

JohnBaxendale's picture

Problem is, Labour plus Lib Dems have a majority of the votes but not of the seats. Also, Brown would have to go, but be replaced by another 'unelected' PM - yes, I know that's nonsense, but it's how the media will present it. Better to let Cameron take the fall for the cuts, or take credit for restraining them, elect a new leader, and prepare the ground for a proper left of centre alliance, which Brown woefully failed to do (eg. see his disgraceful answer aboout social housing in the Paxman interview). Tories should be worried that Clegg's tentative offer is a trap, but one they can't avoid falling into. Act Two belongs to the Tories (just), but Act Three is when the fat lady sings.

Latest tweets