Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Do we want the BNP in our schools?

Arguments over whether or not Adam Walker’s comments were “racist” obscure the real issue.

A BNP activist and former teacher has been cleared of racism by the General Teaching Council. Adam Walker, 41, used a school laptop to post comments online describing immigrants as "savage animals" while working at Houghton Kepier Sports College, in Houghton-le-Spring, County Durham. He also claimed Britain was a "dumping ground for the filth of the third world".

Despite declaring itself "troubled" by Walker's views, the GTC decided that while Walker's postings demonstrated an attitude that might be considered racist, the specific references to immigrants were not necessarily "suggestive of any particular views on race".

The ruling has been criticised by teaching unions, including the NUT, whose leader, Christine Blower, described the decision as "perverse".

The decision in March by the then schools secretary, Ed Balls, not to ban teachers from joining the BNP outright means that the debate has now descended into an argument over semantics. (The GTC, in effect, is saying it's not racist to describe immigrants in general as "filth", because immigrants are an ethnically diverse group -- a line of argument not unlike that of a comedian who makes jokes about black people saying "I'm not racist, I hate everyone . . .") But this threatens to obscure a more fundamental question: should BNP members have any involvement in our schools at all?

The education system plays a crucial role in the far-right party's quest for respectabililty. It has made a determined effort to get its members elected to school governing bodies. (This has been made easier in recent years by a shortage of ordinary people willing to take up governors' posts.)

In Stoke-on-Trent last year, for example, three BNP councillors attempted to join the board of governors of Edensor Technology College, a school where 80 per cent of the pupils are Asian.

Speaking outside the GTC hearing in Birmingham, Walker and his party chairman, Nick Griffin, presented the case as a free speech issue. But there is a clear difference between expressing privately held views and being a member of a political organisation that is committed to dividing British society along ethnic lines -- the party's 2009 county council manifesto, for example, declared that mixing white and non-white children was "destroying perfectly good local secondary schools".

Furthermore, Walker plays an active role in the BNP. He stood as a parliamentary candidate in May and, as the NS revealed in April, during the BNP's election campaign he was frequently pictured by Nick Griffin's side, wearing army fatigues. Here is how we reported it at the time:

On Saturday [Walker] was parading in front of news cameras gathered in Barking to cover the BNP's campaign launch. Asked if he was a real soldier, he admitted he wasn't. "I'm wearing this uniform in solidarity with our boys in Afghanistan," Walker said.

David Cameron has already said that he sees membership of the BNP as "incompatible" with the role of a teacher. It remains to be seen whether his government will take a fresh look at the matter.

Tags: BNP

21 comments

Al4's picture

Oh, the BNP - whatever happened to them?

ROBERT TAGGART's picture

No. But. Neither do we want Liebour, LibDem, Tory, Greens...
So ? So if it be legal for all the others to be in our schools it should be legal for the BNP.
No fears, no favours.

Shaun's picture

As long as people keep politics out of the class room then I see no problem. Look how many socialists and Marxists we have in the classrooms along with the Communist supporters, a regime that is responsible for nearly 100million deaths worldwide.

Simon Davies's picture

Surely it is "incompatible" with a free society to ban someone from becoming a teacher or a school governor because of the political party they support?

I don't want my nephews and nieces taught by someone who propagates lies and ignorance, but the BNP are, rightly or wrongly, a legal political party. As long as this remains the case, I don't really see what anyone can do about it without opening up a can of worms.

With regards to school governors, perhaps efforts would be best spent encouraging more "ordinary" people to take up those positions. Where I grew up, governor positions were dominated by upper-middle class types who championed all sorts of motions that would benefit their children at the expense of poorer pupils. Obviously, we can't ban Tories from our schools. Labour should be making a determined effort to get their members elected to governing bodies.

Getting back to the Adam Walker, another overlooked fact is that this idiot is mindlessly regurgitating talking points picked up from the press. How can we reasonably suggest banning BNP supporters from anywhere while newspapers are untouchable in their promulgation of misleading hate stories?

If David Cameron does pursue this, it'll further expose his (and his coalition partners') approach to civil liberties. If the left pursue this, it'll again position them as the anti-freedom, thought-police, "ignoring public concerns" brigade.

Of course, we all know that is not a fair representation at all. But, as the right-wing press has shown us time and time again, you don't need to be clever or correct to shape people's opinions.

Sam's picture

Dave, there may be similarities between now and 80 years ago, but there are also key differences, an important one being that in 2010 we are in a position to prove we have learned from the mistakes of the 1930s. Mistakes that the British voter is not going to want to repeat, lest we forget.

And that 90% stat is way off.

dorothy brooke's picture

YES we certainly do want BNP TEACHERS in our schools.Education is very important especially HISTORY LESSONS. Our culture is also important and should not be forgotten.THE BNP is a legal party SO leave them alone and let them do there job. STOP these exaggerated hate stories every one has a choice and an opinion of there own democracy

Lee John Barnes's picture

Adam Walker is an ex-soldier who served in the first Gulf War in a tank, who has put his life on the line for this country.

He of all British citizens is entitled to freedom of speech in his own country, precisely because he has fought for freedom and free speech and put his life on the line defending liberty.

Whilst the pathetic Marxist journalists and other media pseudo-moralists peddle their faux outrage over Adam Walkers 'Thought Crime', all they have done is continuously surrender our right to free speech - to the Islamists, to political correctness and the race relations industry.

Adam Walker has the right to think what he wants in our society.

He has fought for liberty, whereas his critics seek merely to moralise their betrayals of liberty.

He said nothing to any his pupils at any time in the classroom, he merely expressed his opinion on the internet in a private news media chat room.

Thats it.

The fact that our liberty has degenerated to the point where ex-servicemen and all Britons can be penalised for writing their opinions on the internet, shows us that the war on terror we must fight in order for our nation to survive involves a war more than one front.

No nation collapses without being first betrayed from within.

Those who assist in treason, should be expected to be dealt with as traitors.

Mike's picture

Sam, you honesly believe that
the majority of British people are going to sit by whilst our government give the vast majority of jobs to foreigners whilst we are going through a huge recession,
At the same time chopping away at our free speech, 500,000 new immigrants given British passports each and every year, not to mention the growing problems we are facing with islamism?
Something as got to give and believe me when I say, just as the PVV (Geert Wilders freedom party) gained a huge stride towards winning the role of government in the netherlands, the same is going to happen here in the UK very soon, with the BNP, people are waking up and seeing what's going on.
Yes you are right I remember, the 90% stats is well off aia believe it was something like 97% reported and cited by several sources.

Graecus's picture

BNP, or Communist, SWP, Marxist Labour - who are worse, whose ideologies have more blood on their hands? The latter, before you answer. Leftist teachers are a cancer, excise them!

beppe74's picture

You miss the point.
Anyone who works in education knows that it's hard to attract and retain qualified teachers and usually the only one who apply are the graduates who are poorly qualified.
When there is a shortage of teachers you cannot ban people because they are BNP members.
Beggars cannot be chooser

margaretwilson's picture

If you actually read Mr Walker's comments in the context in which they were written, you would probably agree with what he said. After all he was talking about immigrants who "have committed heinous crimes" and are then allowed to stay in the country, which is evidenced by the huge number of foreign lowlife in our prisons and the fact that people we have granted asylum have gone on to bomb, murder and rape British citizens. Perhaps its time liberals adopted a more tolerant position towards people who believe in the rights of the victim as opposed to the criminal. This is an important ruling as the liberals and Marxists in the establishment have attempted to restrict free speech and at least on this occasion have failed. The BNP appear to be the only group in Britain which is still championing the concept of free speech. Well done to Mr Walker for not bowing down to these attacks on his right to a career and free thought.

Sam's picture

No, I think you'll find that's the number of *new* jobs, a subtle difference there - in reality the number of jobs that are being done by a foreigner is not going to be anything like that high, there simply aren't enough of them here for that.

Addressing all your other points, your first question implies that the only options available to the British public are to (a) be completely apathetic or (b) vote for a narrow-minded bigot. In reality the majority of Brits are somewhere in between, and most realise they're not going to have to resort to supporting a sick organisation. I share your concerns on freedom of expression, and think the BNP-ophiles are the biggest threat to that and similar freedoms in this country: in power they would restrict many forms of religious expression, the burka, and the building of mosques. I think the problems with Islamism are for Islam to sort out for itself. I don't really mind who gets a British passport as long as they qualify for citizenship, why would you?

Geert Wilders has got a lot of popularity but it's stretching logic too far to assume what happens in the Netherlands is going to be reflected in the UK. There are big differences, the equivalent party over here is generally seen as an outcasts party, and always has been, so you can't compare the two. This "waking up" you refer to seems to be all in your head and not borne out by facts: in reality their popularity peaked at 944,000 votes in the 2009 euros just as the expenses scandal was turning people away from mainstream politics, and has recently fallen to just over half a million in this year's GE. In fact I'd hypothesise the exact opposite, that the BNP-ophiles of 2009 have indeed had an awakening and realised quite how odious their policies are whereas previously they'd naively assumed they were simply voting for a tighten-up-immigration-laws party.

marcy's picture

Looks like all the BNP rent-a-mob wingnuts are out in force.

You simply can't have someone who hates people with brown skin teaching kids from all kinds of racial backgrounds, when by their own admission they DESPISE them. Education is supposed to be equal for all. This is such a bleeding obvious point that it beggars belief people don't get it. However I prefer to assume that all the people supporting this hateful man are racist themselves. That certainly makes more sense to me than seemingly intelligent people backing dangerous people looking after our kids. What are you going to do for an encore, invite a paedophile to be headmaster?

Stan Mason's picture

I don't know if Adam Walker is racist - you can't equate opposition to high levels of immigration to racism. And anyway racism doesn't seem so bad when you compare it to the mass murder of over half a million people generated by the Labour Party which lying to drag the UK into two illegal wars. Now if my kids were being taught by a Labour Party supporter - that would be a real cause for concern.

Bill Gibbons's picture

Marcy,

You wrote,

"However I prefer to assume that all the people supporting this hateful man are racist themselves."

A blanket judgement if ever there was one. So you do not believe that freedom of expression should be the right of every law abiding citizen? If the General Teaching Council had established beyond reasonable doubt that Walker was jeopardizing the well-being and psychological health of the children he was teaching, he would have been sacked and most likely charged under Section 5. if you don't know what that is, then read on. As it happens, while they disagreed with his views, he did not express them inside the classroom to the children he teaches daily.

However, should we shut him up just because some people, particularly those on the left, regard his views as "hateful?" It would appear that almost any opinion publicly expressed, whether verbally or on a blog that is not politically correct is deemed as "hateful."

But it's not just teachers than can get into hot water. Take the case of 14 year-old Codie Stott. During a classroom project. young Miss Sott asked her teacher at Harrop Fold High School if she could sit with another group to do her science project as the other five girls in her present group all spoke Urdu and she didn’t understand what they were saying. The teacher called the police, who took her to the station, photographed her, fingerprinted her, took DNA samples, removed her jewellery and shoelaces, put her in a cell for 3½ hours, and questioned her on suspicion of committing a Section Five “racial public order offence.”

“An allegation of a serious nature was made concerning a racially motivated remark,” declared the headmaster Antony Edkins. The school would “not stand for racism in any form.” In a statement, Greater Manchester Police said they took “hate crime” very seriously, and their treatment of Miss Stott was in line with “normal procedure.”

This oneone reason why I quit Britain for a vast, beautiful, clean and gentile land called Canada, where political correctness still exists, but doesn't run amock by turning a 14 year old girl into race criminal because she can't understand foreign speaking students who sit in the same classroom.

But then again, you would have her doing hard labour in Siberia somewhere wouldn't you, Marcy?

Pat Harrington's picture

I was very pleased to represent Adam Walker for three years at the GTC and to ensure that he got a fair hearing. In the end the case was decided on the evidence. That evidence showed that Adam was a good teacher, who improved grades, treated people from all backgrounds with respect and was a positive, life-changing force in the lives of pupils. Many were so moved that they sent testimonials to the hearing or wrote to local newspapers.

Yes, he did criticise some immigrants but not all. He criticised people he saw as taking part in violent crime while enjoying the protection and hospitality of our country. Was he wrong to call rapists and murderers "savages" and "filth". He is a man of strong passions and speaks from his heart. Yet he expressed his views under a pseudonym on a local debate forum and never sought to embarass his School.

Shoud members of the BNP be allowed to teach? I say "yes". We live in a democracy and people have the right to freedom of belief, association and expression. These are fundamental Human Rights. Yes, they are qualified in certain circumstances. Society has to have a pressing social need to qualify these rights. I do not see that there is one. Those who want to ban BNP members from teaching and negate their Human Rights have made a poor case so far.

http://www.solidaritytradeunion.net

Dave Wood's picture

I do agree with Pat when he says that “we live in a democracy and people have the right to freedom of belief, association and expression”. However, when these beliefs compromise the ability of a person in a position of authority over another to execute their role with impartiality and without prejudice, then the suitability of that person to carry out that role should indeed be called into question.

That is not an attack on the freedom of belief; you are free to believe what you want. But you must be prepared to accept that those beliefs may make it difficult to function in the fair and impartial manner that professions such as teaching and policing require.

Patrick Harrington's picture

Dave Wood makes an interesting point. Surely you would need evidence showing that beliefs compromised your professional behaviour though? Otherwise you would just be making assumptions. In the case of Adam Walker the evidence was that he was a good teacher who treated his pupils fairly and with respect.

I did not find it hard to provide testimonials on behalf of Adam Walker. One pupil was so moved that she wrote to a local newspaper. Here is what she said:-

"I am a 14-year old student at Teesdale School and I am writing to you about a story that you have recently published on supply teacher Mr Walker.

Although I am Eurasian and Mr Walker is being accused of 'racism', I have not once been treated unfairly or even differently by him. It was really quite the opposite: Mr Walker and I got on tremendously. I would also like to point out that his wife is in fact Japanese, and he spent many years living in Japan.

When I came to the North East, my headmaster at my previous school in Yorkshire warned me that there may be racism here. He was right. Children at school regularly call me P*** and N*****.

But yet, Mr Walker, who has treated me with respect, is the one who being accused of racism, and even worse: being put in the public eye for it.

So what would happen if all the children and their parents who have called me racist names in the past were to be put in the newspaper?

Should not the kids be threatened with expulsion from the school, and their parents be threatened with being fired from their jobs, as Mr Walker is being threatened with being fired from his job? Their actions have proven them to be racist, whilst his actions have proved the opposite.

I know nothing of Mr Walker's politics – and nor do I care, as long as he is a good teacher and treats the class accordingly, with respect. He is a good teacher, there is no doubt about that, and my class-mates and I feel that he is being unfairly victimised.

I hope that he will be allowed to continue teaching, and if so, I hope he comes back to my school".

Dave's picture

Support for the BNP is going to rise over the next few years and people will vot BNP in large numbers at the 2015 GE.Why? Well, we are in a similar position to the 1930's and there isn't going to be another World War to provide full employment and take people's minds off domestic issues. Don't you just hate this current system where millions are paid to not work and 90% of jobs went to foreigners in the last 10 years?

No2PC's picture

I went to a school where left wing teachers regularly forced their views on the pupils. This included telling sixth formers to vote Labour, attacking our armed forces despite the fact that some pupils parents were serving, pro republican comments during the troubles, trying to make pupils ashamed of British culture by lying about historical facts and deliberatly ignoring racist and anti semetic comments made by some Muslim pupils. I therefore find it incredible that the left wing teachers unions and the NS talk about BNP discrimination in schools.

What they are actually saying is that left wing teachers are fine but right wing teachers must be sacked. True totalitarianism wrapped up in anti racist clothing.

freedom is slavery, ignorance is strength, War is Peace.
George Orwells dicription of Labours Britain.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets