Liam Fox: Afghanistan is a “broken, 13th-century country”
Defence Secretary causes controversy in Afghanistan with “colonialist, orientalist” remarks.
By Samira Shackle Published 24 May 2010 12:26
The new Defence Secretary, Liam Fox, has got off to a flying start in Afghanistan. In an interview with the Times on Saturday, he said:
We are not in Afghanistan for the sake of the education policy in a broken, 13th-century country. We are there so the people of Britain and our global interests are not threatened.
Understandably, this hasn't gone down too well in Afghanistan. The Times today quotes a senior Afghan government official:
His view appears to be that Afghanistan has not changed since the 13th century and it implies that Afghanistan is a tribal and medieval society.
The source adds:
We see Britain as still a colonial, orientalist and racist country that they should have this view.
Fox's response has been somewhat inadequate. He clarified that his point was that national security was more important than nation-building, but on the insulting tone of his comments, his office said only:
Hamid Karzai has used similar words himself, describing what the Taliban left behind as 13th- or 14th-century.
There are several problems here. First of all, his comment overlooks the fact that a stable Afghan state is central to the interests of our national security.
As my colleague Mehdi Hasan has pointed out, it is estimated that there are fewer than 100 al-Qaeda operatives in Afghanistan. We are no longer fighting terrorists in the country. Therefore, the only way to "serve the British interest" is by ensuring that a government is in place that is strong enough to fend off the Taliban, who, if back in government, could allow Afghanistan to become a safe haven for terrorists once more. It's tenuous at best.
The second point, which Fox has declined to address, is the patronising, colonial overtones of his comments. Perpetuating an existing perception of a conquering western power that views Afghanistan as primitive and inferior is hugely damaging. Fox can think whatever he likes in private, but he cannot afford to alienate the Afghan people any longer.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















8 comments
magician3all
arabonly
anime3as
animok3a
delegnt3a
mexaty3a
animeta7a
mexaty3a
animes3t
mexa2at
3arb-anime
anim5k
albrqn3t
mexat3an
top3film
z7may
z7mhat
ta7ata
animeyate
mnhosat
mokmsyat
animeca3fe
mazaryte
animeyzo
animesnipat
anime-bnatc
banatm5dern
star5at
monaystat
mal7zat
zol7at
kol7at
animoyat
foxyat
maz7kat
3solaty
kool7at
ta7oy
mal7oy
zalyta
ma7aryat
sokolat
barn7ty
tey5at
d5olat
caloyat
anim3snipe
sadt3ars
animeonlye
nsf7
3solat
mnoms
magicians4all
animexyt
mexyt
delegnet
What's the big problem? It's not really that insulting, because Afghanistan is really only a 14th century country - by the Islamic calendar, that is.
Fox is about as intellectually impressive as his televisual namesake.
Liam Fox: Afghanistan is a "broken 13th-century country"
Of course its insulting, Afgahnstan is a modern sophisticated society, up there with Japan, Germany and Switzerland, yeah.
At least they got rid of their Monarch years ago...
Fox probably summed it up. You have only to look at the puzzlement and bewilderment on the craggy wind beaten faces of the local peasants in the villages, the men women and children, as they try to work out what the hell these Western soldiers are doing, with all their sophisticated equipment and helicopters and weaponry, in the desolate dusty barren plains of Afghanistan.
As Fox said: Just to keep the village shop open?
Afghans did not sent an invitation card for the west to come to Afghanistan.
Fox's coment is damaging, it not the way forward.
Far be it from me to agree with Liam Fox, but he is right.
Afghanistan is broken down hellhole of a place. They have had a war for nearly 40 years.
Why don't we fire a few Tridents and ICBM's at the place and start over?
It would be quicker and probably cheaper in the long term!