Star Spangled Staggers

US politics from outside the beltway

Syndicate contentRSS

Perry's execution record outstrips Bush's

Rick Perry has overseen more executions than George "the Texecutioner" Bush.

The Republican presidential candidate hopeful, Rick Perry, has outstripped his gubernatorial predecessor, George W. Bush, in the number of executions he has overseen.

George Bush, the so-called "Texecutioner", who has been described as a "modern-day Pontius Pilate", oversaw the execution of 152 convicts over five years.

Perry, the current Governor of Texas, has overseen 234 executions, although he has held the office for 11 years, meaning he is overseeing a lower rate of execution.

If a Governor of Texas is to commute a death sentence, he or she must first be referred the commutation by a Board of Pardons and Paroles, and if the Board denies commutation, the Governor cannot act on this. However, the Governor appoints the Board of Pardons and Paroles him or herself. Perry has only commuted one sentence as Governor.

In 2002, Perry vetoed a bill that would have prevented the death penalty from being handing to mentally retarded inmates.

1,224 inmates have been executed in Texas since 1819 - more than any other state - and it is also the state with the second highest rate of execution, overtaken only by Oklahoma.

In "Fed Up!: Our Fight to Save America from Washington", Perry says "If you don't support the death penalty...don't come to Texas."

He also courted controversy when he refused to prevent the execution of Humberto Leal Garcia, a Mexican national who was not informed that he was entitled to access legal advice from the Mexican consulate, a move that some feared could provoke a diplomatic incident. The White House, and Obama himself, appealed to Perry to reprieve Garcia, noting that failure to do so could "have serious repercussions for United States foreign relations, law-enforcement and other co-operation with Mexico, and the ability of American citizens travelling abroad to have the benefits of consular assistance in the event of detention."

Perry has also been criticised for his decision to ignore forensic evidence relating to the case of Cameron Todd Willingham, a man convicted of killing his children by arson in 1994, and executed ten years later. An investigation into the case was launched in 2009, with one representative of the Texas Forensic Science Commission concluding that "a finding of arson could not be sustained".

The Chicago Tribune concluded that:

Over the past five years, the Willingham case has been reviewed by nine of the nation's top fire scientists - first for the Tribune, then for the Innocence Project, and now for the commission. All concluded that the original investigators relied on outdated theories and folklore to justify the determination of arson. The only other evidence of significance against Willingham was twice-recanted testimony by another inmate who testified that Willingham had confessed to him. Jailhouse snitches are viewed with scepticism in the justice system, so much so that some jurisdictions have restrictions against their use.

Perry dismissed the chair of the Texas Forensic Science Commission, along with two other board members, two days before it was due to review the case. The new chair cancelled the meeting.

Perry's rival Michele Bachmann says she is "100 per cent pro-life" and "believe[s] in the dignity of life from conception until natural death", although she has not made explicit comments on the death penalty.

17 comments

Andyb's picture

Strange comments here. It seems that Americans can't take criticism - even though the criticism here is of Rick Perry (an individual).

As for @A. Cole, China gets lots of stick for its human rights abuses. Where have you been lately?

Ivan Miletitch's picture

Or alternatively send cretins like Flashbuck to live in texas... "if you don't support the death penalty don't come to texas"...absolutely fine, no intention of spending any time with rednecks

Limeys Are Prats's picture

I'm with you Johnny Yank. This Limey belly-aching all the time about America, you would think nothing happens on their wee, muzzie infested, dreary island but we know better. Riots, pedophilia, alcoholism and soccer! Why don't the Limeys in the Pislamic Republic of Englandistan devote some of their time and dole money to stomping out those things rather than OBSESS constantly about America?? How's that multiculturalism thing going in Great Shitain?? LOL

Marcus's picture

@Ivan Miletitch - Funny how anti-Americanism is 'acceptable racism' for many on the left.

Historians will tell you that America is the most powerful, the free-est, the greatest and most successful society in the history of the species.

Perhaps this is why leftie liberals and racists like yourself hate it so.

Andy's picture

Personally I think that people who believe in the death penalty should be taken out and shot.

Andy's picture

@Flashbuck
"The public here in the UK want the death pen. But since we don't have democracy how about sending our murdering scum over to the USA so Perry can fry 'em."

So if the majority want something, it must be right? An ultimate expression of democracy?

By that reckoning, if the majority of the population thought that soiling your underpants at work was a good idea, or travelling everywhere on a pogo-stick dressed as Mother Theresa - would that make these good ideas? No because they are stupid.

When people are given the full facts about how the death penalty works and the implications for everyone involved, including the possibility of miscarriages of justice - people change their mind.

Go and watch 'Let Him Have It' on youtube about poor Derek Bentley.

Andyb's picture

@Johnny Yank and Limeys Are Prats

We're not belly-aching. We are just amazed at how braindead the average republicain is. The fact that ignorant fundamentalist morons like Perry, Bush and Palin routinely become US president is something to laugh at.

And you should do some reading on the Willingham case. If you have the intelligence to understand the details of the case properly, you may well have a doubt about the death penalty and Rick Perry who has played a prominent role in sabotaging the enquiry into this case.

P.S. We are well aware of the problems here in the UK. This is something we do routinely complain about.

Mean Mr Mustard's picture

@Flashbuck

Yep, they'll execute anyone in Texas, adult or child, guilty or not. Off you go then.

@Marcus
Don't be silly. The US has some good points, and some less good. Among the less good are its predilection for fundamentalism, and for frying people.

Johnny Yank's picture

Actually I'm more inclined to visit the "Free Linda Carty" exhibit in London and take a gigantic shit in it, then wipe my ass on some anti-death penalty brochure put out by a Limey prick named Clive.

The English actually think their bleating about U.S. justice makes one iota of difference over here. How amusing. Then they do stuff like parole Baby P's killers after a few years and give them new identities. I think I know which justice system little Peter Connolly would prefer. Whoops, did I break an English law by revealing his name? LOL

Johnny Yank's picture

I can't wait until Perry signs the papers sending "British grandmother" Linda Carty to the gurney. I'm planning a huge Carty Party when he does. Hell, I might even vote for the guy if this animal gets put down before Nov. 2012.

Trajan's picture

God bless Rick Perry. Defender of freedom and Jeebus.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJPcB9JMyu4

P.S. GET BIG GUBURMENT OUT OF MY MEDICAID

Fraziel1's picture

Well said AndyB. It never ceases to amaze me that politicians in the states who would be laughed at and have no chance of election in any sane country due to their crazy fundamentalist rantings, actually get elected.

Reading comments from Johnny yank and A.Cole ( by the way China gets slaughtered for its human rights abuses in many sections of the British press which leads me to think you have no clue as to what you are talking about),really does make me think that Americans have just got smaller brains than the rest of us.

@Limeys are prats, last i looked there have been riots in the US and do you not have any paeodophiles there or alcoholics? You certainly seem to have the monopoly on gun crime,drug addiction though and politicians who in this country would be considered to be actually insane.What a clown.

Ivan Miletitch's picture

"If you don't support death penalty, don't come to Texas" .... SUITS ME FINE ! No intention of wasting any time with rednecks!

Fraziel1's picture

@Johnny yank, its British law not English law. If you are going to make silly comments at least get the basics right.

Ivan Miletitch's picture

@ Marcus >>> Not one bit anti-american! I love going to N.Y / Boston etc...& have wonderful american friends.... BUT, I repeat, I have no time for the 'bible belt rednecks'...ans yes, the USA are on the one hand one of the free-est countries on the planet, but also one where the poor , sick & vulnerable are left with VERY LITTLE assistance from their own country, the richest on the planet!

A. Cole's picture

In China they execute over 1,000 people a year (more than anywhere else in the World).

BUT China is a communist country. So we shouldn't criticise it like we should a successful capitalist democracy like the USA.

Typical lop- sided lefty drivel!

Latest tweets