Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

Will the police ever be held to account?

Verdict due tomorrow on Ian Tomlinson’s death.

On 1 April 2009, during the G20 riots, a 47-year-old newspaper vendor was walking home from work. He was then struck by a member of the Metropolitan Police's Territorial Support Group (TSG). He later died.

Over a year later, the Crown Prosecution Service will tomorrow deliver its verdict on the Ian Tomlinson incident. As the Guardian reports, "The possible charges include manslaughter, assault and misconduct in public office. Or, the CPS may decide not to bring any charges."

I am very far from hopeful that justice will prevail. As I wrote last year, the police are the most unaccountable public body in Britain. If you don't believe me, ask the family of Jean Charles de Menezes, shot repeatedly at point-blank range at Stockwell Tube station, in south London, on 22 July 2005 after being mistaken for -- and reported as -- a "suicide bomber".

As I wrote last year, the two deaths have something in common: a police cover-up. Here is brief reminder from the piece of what happened, lest we forget, over Tomlinson:

[On] the day that Tomlinson died of a heart attack the Met issued a wholly misleading statement. A member of the public, it said, told police that "there was a man who had collapsed round the corner". Officers, it was claimed, had tried to help medics save his life as "missiles, believed to be bottles", were hurled at them.

The reality, again revealed in video, shows Tomlinson walking with his hands in his pockets, offering neither resistance nor threat to the police line behind him. Next, he is struck around the legs by a baton-wielding TSG officer who then shoves Tomlinson to the ground. After "bouncing" -- a witness's word -- on the ground, a terrified Tomlinson can be seen looking up in disbelief at the officers, who stand back, leaving the public to tend to him.

In the case of de Menezes, not a single police figure has been held to account. I would be pleased, but very surprised, if the Tomlinson case does not result in the same injustice.

Tags: G20 2009

6 comments

Boldero's picture

Unbelievable, the officer concerned, who has been on paid leave for almost a year will not be facing any charges because of inconclusive post mortem results....

Irrelevant! what matters is a man died from the actions, (unintentional or not) of a police officer, surely thats what the charge of 'manslaughter' covers.

Seems that the only way you can get any kind of justice in this country is to be in the police force.

A sad day for british justice :*(

Boldero's picture

As someone who has had close contact with members of the police force over the years, I can assure that that there is a prevailing attitude of 'you cover my back, I will cover yours'

The police themselves are indoctrinated from day one with the intrenched attitude that they are only accountable to themselves and their superiors, and hold anyone outside of the 'club' with disdain and contempt.

They ceased to be a 'police force for the public good' many years ago, they are now a paramilitary organisation with their own political agenda, and woe betide anyone who stands against them, or becomes a victim of them.

Gone are the days when people joined the force to make a difference, they are no longer part of the solution, they are now a big part of the problem.

jeremiah's picture

The Police in this country are largely a law unto themselves.

Stanley, De Menezes and Peach are just a few names of people who have been killed (unlawfully in my opinion) by the Police. Yet who was prosecuted or even lost their jobs?

Sure some Policeman do a good job in difficult circumstances. However as Boldero correctly points out the Police are just a well funded gang who happen to be employed by the state.

I my working life I have come into contact with many Police officers. The overwhelming experience I have is one of arrogance and contempt for anyone who is not part of their world.

Police "service" my foot.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets