Has David Miliband helped his brother by ensuring Abbott is in the race?
The move has led Ed Miliband to tack left, observer says.
By James Macintyre Published 10 June 2010 14:23As a former special adviser, Tom Clark of the Guardian knows a thing or two about the dynamics of the Labour leadership contest. And he is surely right that the key "headline" from last night's New Statesman debate, my report on which is here, was that Ed Miliband articulated a more leftist approach, thus creating "clear, cold" water between himself and his brother David Miliband.
Another key element of the story of last night was the extraordinary body language between the Milibands themselves, and between Ed Balls and the Milibands. But that is another tale, for another day.
To be fair to Ed Miliband, anyone who has known him for some years knows that his natural instincts are on what is known as the "soft left" and that, unlike some "Brownites" and, to an extent, unlike his brother, his politics are to the left of New Labour.
However, Clark goes on to suggest that last night Ed tacked left as a result of Diane Abbott's entry into the race. That may or may not be true. But if it is, as Clark points out, David Miliband should take some credit for the very grown-up way in which he ensured, through his own nomination and those of supporters, that Abbott got on the ballot paper.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















6 comments
Sue - I don't want to diminish the possbility that this may have been an achievement of the grassroots, putting pressure on the leadership and forcing a concession. I hope that was the case, and I hope the grassroots of the party get stuck in to this debate. The leadership has a lot to learn from them.
What's just as likely is that David Miliband helped Abbott over the line in the hope that it would split the left vote and thus hobble his brother and Balls. Clark's analysis, which I agree with, shows that this may have been a serious miscalculation, with a different dynamic emerging from the one Miliband the elder envisaged.
You love lavishing praise on David Miliband.
Yeti - I agree and its so sickening!
David Wearing... I agree with your suggestion about the splitting of the left vote... but there was also the considerable pressure of an enormous flood of e-mails to MPs demanding an opening up of the nominations. Ironically, most were sent with a view to getting John McDonnell on the ballot... I don't think that David Milliband would have risked putting Abbott on the ballot lightly.... and last night's hustings must have confirmed some of his fears.
Post new comment