The "meaning" of James Purnell's resignation
"Politician in honest move" shock.
By James Macintyre Published 19 February 2010 13:12
Like almost everyone in Westminster, I certainly cannot claim to have predicted that James Purnell would announce that he's to stand down as an MP at the next election, as he has done today. But I can claim to be unsurprised, having rejected the cynical view that everything Purnell does -- including his call this week for ideological clarity in Labour -- should be seen through the prism of the party's leadership.
In an article for the Guardian on Tuesday, I wrote:
Purnell probably knows that in the eyes of Westminster cynics he can make no intervention that isn't interpreted as some sort of act of hostility towards Gordon Brown, if not a pitch for the leadership when and if it becomes vacant after the general election. But Purnell should be taken at his word when he expresses a desire to contribute to the thinking of "a clear ideological argument in the manifesto", and in his hope that his resignation claim -- that Brown's leadership makes a Tory victory "more, not less" likely -- is proved wrong. He should even, despite the slight sense of frustration, be believed when he says: "I'm happy where I am now."
This is for two reasons. First, Purnell is -- contrary to conventional wisdom -- highly unlikely to run for the leadership. This is because he is preparing to back the near-certain candidacy of his close ally and friend David Miliband. But second, because -- like Miliband -- he is a much more complicated Labour figure than his vacuous "Blairite" label suggests.
Purnell has many enemies, including some on the left, as almost all the comments under my CiF piece showed. But he is nothing if not honest. His resignation last June -- agree with it or not -- was one of the few brave and clear acts among the many moves by the many rebels opposed to the status quo in Labour.
A year and a half or so ago, in the early days of Purnell being touted as a possible leader, I asked him about it and he said, again with honesty, "I've got a decision to make" about whether he wanted that kind of personal reassurance and scrutiny. So, in that context -- and bearing in mind that, as I have said, he is preparing to back David Miliband for the leadership -- his announcement today is not surprising.
Genuinely, he wants to do something else with his life. Purnell should be applauded for that, even by those cynics who can't get their heads round his latest move.
PS: Some news reports are claiming this is a "blow" to Gordon Brown and Labour because, the theory goes, Purnell has realised the party isn't going to win the election.
This doesn't quite work. If Purnell was ambitious, he would have waited until Labour loses and then stood as David Miliband's running mate, or claimed a key shadow cabinet role in opposition. Is it not just possible he is sick of Westminster, a very small world where he has spent almost all of his working life so far?
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















5 comments
He may be honest, no doubt; but I think he lacks judgment and his calculations are quite awkward. Giving up isnt the characteristics of a winner; is it? I like his bravity and his new found support for his party and hoping he will at least stay active to reach that goal. Otherwise, he will be making 3 mistakes that may cost him the future. He is a great guy
Timing is everything. Purnell has used the opportunity to stand down on the eve of the PM laying out the outline of the Labour Party's election strategy. To believe Purnell hasn't acted at this moment (or been advised to act) in order to cast a cloud over the proceedings is extremely naive.
Timing has not been one of Purnell's strongest points, evidenced by when he resigned, and nobody followed him.
I go along with the theory that he's just cheesed off with having spent most of his adult life in the Westminster bubble and has decided to get a proper job instead.
Good Riddance. This man may be "talented" but he is not Labour.
This is the man who amongst other mistakes advocated the total severing of the Labour from the Trade Union movement (who founded it).
Labour needs to start speaking for and to working class people. Otherwise it has no future and no right to bear the name...
Oh no not the loss of another Intellectual Giant of Blairism
Did you see the state of the flat he left, filthy disgusting; call for the Grime Fighters- should be known as James Persil. How about Demos being called Domestos.
Never read Demos, looked at a copy in a motorway service station of Progress ? Could not get passed the fourth paragraph- empowerment ? Geoff Mulgan- is this the level of intellectual 'debate' on the 'Left', As a lecturer in a Further and Higher college and among many many other areas I taught A Level Sociology - Mulgan is sub A Level not even reaching GCSE ?
Who pays these people; yeah, Persil get a proper job- try a call centre work £7 an hour -do something productive but he we have to pay stamp duty and could end up on the dole work for your benefits subject of Paul Greggs (Bristol University) ideas of 'conditionality' lie detector tests; be subject to a Maoist re-education programme (House of Commons select commitee on Benefits March), fines etc
Anyway bored now hears a clue where where the Left should start:
Review t
The Road to Serfdom by F.A. Hayek;
The Mirror of the Past.K.Zilliacus;
Orwell's summary of his review
'Captitalism leads to dole queues, the scramble for markets, and war.
Collectivism leads to concentration camps,leader worship, and war. There is no way out of this unless a planned economy can somehow be combined with the freedom of the intellect, which can only happen if the concept of right and wrong is restored to politics'. Then try Alisdiar McIntyre After Virtue and the impossibility of 'management' because it has no predictive capacity and must rely upon coercion or some moral code- concepts of right and wrong-that should keep Persil busy in between Call centre calls oh dear there aren't any breaks - never mind - just get out of our face!
Post new comment