The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Miliband at his best and at his boldest

The Labour leader delivered his most confident and effective speech to date.

Labour leader Ed Miliband delivers his speech to delegates.
Labour leader Ed Miliband acknowledges the applause as he delivers his speech to delegates at the Labour conference in Manchester. Photograph: Getty Images.

"Ed speaks human", his supporters used to say, and today Ed Milband proved that he can. Speaking without notes for more than an hour, this was the best and most relaxed speech he has delivered since becoming Labour leader. The jokes were funny, the message was hopeful, and the attack lines were lethal. Returning repeatedly to the theme of "one nation", he suggested that while David Cameron had failed to live up to this tradition, he could. His "faith" (the other leitmotif) was, he said, not a religious one, but one that the religious would recognise all the same. It was defined by the belief that "we have a duty to leave the world a better place".

From there, he argued that the Tories, both heartless and hopeless, were set to leave Britain a worse place. The government's biggest mistakes - the NHS reorganisation ("you can't trust the Tories with the NHS"), the abolition of the 50p tax rate, the devotion to austerity - were all ruthlessly recalled. As, inevitably, was Andrew Mitchell's run-in with the police. But while the Lib Dems sought to make light of the incident ("my fellow plebs," Danny Alexander quipped), Miliband angrily brandished it as evidence of why the Tories could never be a "one nation" government.

Fears that the speech would be jargonistic and wonkish were dispatched ("predistribution" was nowhere to be found) as the Labour leader expressed himself in clear, accessible terms. "If the medicine's not working," he said of the economy, "you need to change the medicine. And you need to change the doctor too." And he vowed that while Labour would be forced to take tough decisions in office, he would never cut taxes for the richest, while raising them for the poorest - "those with the broadest shoulders will always bear the greatest burden." He could not wish for a more potent dividing line with Cameron's party.

But while Miliband was clearer than ever about his differences with the Tories, he also extended an olive branch to their supporters. In one of the most effective passages, he declared that he understood why they voted Conservative and why they "turned away from the last Labour government". But now that the country was back in recession and borrowing more than last year, Cameron no longer deserved the benefit of the doubt. With an eye to the right, Miliband also acknowledged that a Labour government would have to cut spending - "we've got to live within our means" - and declared that, while he would do everything possible to help the unemployed, those who could work had a "responsibility" to do so. As for the Lib Dems, Miliband, more in sorrow than in anger, lamented that the party behind the 1909 People's Budget had supported the "millionaire's budget" of 2012.

While light on policy, the speech successfully outlined a vision of a fairer, more generous society. The banks would "serve the country", rather than the country serving the banks, the "free market" in the NHS would end, and the "two nations" - the rich and the rest - would be brought together. Displaying his new-found confidence, Miliband recalled his "predators and producers" refrain, adding that "one year on, people know what I was talking about".

After this speech, the Tories will no longer be able to console themselves with the thought that while Labour rides high, Miliband is unelectable. Once seen as a drag on his party, the Labour leader will now be recognised as an asset.

13 comments

Davidaslindsay's picture

The death of Eric Hobsbawm has created a vacancy in the Order of Companions of Honour.

Especially after today, it ought to go to the former Foreign Secretary, David Miliband.

Bless.

Julia Michell's picture

Agreed x

Michael Dixon's picture

He has improved as a public speaker, as he should. Vision for the country-par for the course that you would get from any leader of any Party whether you agree with them or not, articulate and logical.

Policy? Nothing

Humility for th countless mistakes Labnour made in government. None

Apologies for watching the bankers destroy our country on their watch. Nothing.

hugh markey's picture

Enough already! No more coded language! Such link words as - alien, dweeb, immigrant, nerd, dork, geek, techie, weird, offbeat, peculiar, fratricidal - yes,, we know what you mean. They pose the question - "Isn't he.................?"

Ever since Ed Milliband was elected Labour Leader, this herd of elephants or prejudices has been in corner of the political parlour. A not is as good as a wink - yes, we know what you mean.

Thankfully Ed and the Labour Party have spiked the guns of the right's massed artillery.

In choosing Disraeli, Queen Victoria's and Society's darling and not forgetting his exceptional ability as a politician and Prime Minister. the Labour Party has brought the matter out into the open.

Other of the Jewish persuasion have also proved themselves in the world of politics.

After all wasn't it the Saatchi Brothers who dreamt up that killer-attack ad - " Labour Isn't Working!"
It wasn't a question of asking what school they went to? The Brothers crystallized the Tory message and hey boom Mrs Thatcher was PM. They could do the job!

Take Oliver Letwin merchant banker and Master of Tory Election Campaigns, when he is not boarding the wrong train or shooting the breeze, is still central to Conservative Policy. A wonk, indeed!

Michael Howard, Prince of Darkness and soft target for Jeremy Paxman, even got within striking distance of mercurial Tony Blair.

And in eighties Nigel Lawson did the house-keeping budget for Mrs Thatcher's government. He was also supposed to watch the money supply - M something.

And the Royals won't have a bad word said against the Rothschilds.

Sticks and Stones

k

Lynda's picture

I want to be part of the "One Nation" Ed Miliband talks about and I believe he will do his best to achieve if if we elect him. That is our task get elected and get on with it. The Country cannot go on as it has under the Coalition the sooner we can have an election the better.

Amergin's picture

You are right, of course but before then there is Nov 15th when many elections are taking place. Labour party workers should be out on the streets of Corby, for instance telling the voters not to just vote Labour but to vote in droves, thousands and elect the Labour candidate in with a huge majority. That would be not just a vote for labour but a massive shout of protest at the coalition and let their anger go ringing down the corridors of Westminster and Downing Street. What they must not do is stay at home because of complacency or disenchantment. Make them listen.

Rev Graeme Hancocks's picture

Well said.

plain john snith's picture

Your colleague Rafael Behr has already put himself forward for the Order of the Brown Nose: why are you duplicating effort?

Rev Graeme Hancocks's picture

I always believed Ed Milliband to be a very able person but had some nagging doubts about whether he would be able to would ever be able to break through and connect to "ordinary voters", especially given that the hostility of much of the media. Those doubts were completely removed by this speech - articulate, humane, witty, charismatic and intelligent. He can beat Cameron. He can be PM. No doubts now.

Wonder how long it will be before the tory and central office trolls will get here to rubbish the speech and make it appear as if the entire nation is united in also thinking it rubbish? See they have been active elsewhere. See there has already been when highly intelligent and thought through comment! Give them a couple of hours, I'm sure they will get here eventually.

Bolshie Dave's picture

And as iuf by magic Calumity turned up

Callumity's picture

Ed the Red Tory.

Amergin's picture

Even the Tories who are well into hatchet jobs in partnership with their media pals, have stopped using the " Red Ed" smear. Do try to keep up. They have moved onto Geek and Wonk now. Silly playground name-calling

Callumity's picture

Ed the Red Tory.

Latest tweets