The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Cameron's speech will have pleased the Tories - but few others

The Prime Minister spoke as if he inhabited an alternate reality.

David Cameron delivers his speech. Photograph: Getty Images.
David Cameron delivers his speech at the Conservative Party conference in Birmingham. Photograph: Getty Images/

David Cameron's speech was the most defensive he has delivered since becoming Conservative leader. In an address devoid of policy announcements, he confronted head on the strongest arguments against his government. To the charge that its obsession with austerity had tipped Britain back into recession, he replied: "our deficit reduction plan is not an alternative to a growth plan: it’s the very foundation of our growth plan." To the charge that the Tories were, once again, the party of the rich, he insisted that the abolition of the 50p tax rate would help, not hurt, the poorest. "When people earn money, it’s their money.  Not the government’s money: their money," he declared with the conviction of a true Thatcherite.

The hall lapped it up, but Cameron's speech will have fallen flat in most of the country. The Prime Minister frequently spoke as if he inhabited an alternate reality in which the country wasn't in recession, a million young people weren't unemployed, and living standards weren't falling at the fastest rate since 1920s. Warning that it was "sink or swim" time for Britain, Cameron presented himself as a man confronting hard truths. But he avoided the truth that, without a change of course, the UK faces years of anaemic growth. We were reminded again that the deficit had been reduced by a quarter and that a million new private sector jobs had been created (although 196,000 of these were simply reclassified from the public sector). But the government's failure to deliver growth, indeed, its success in delivering recession, means that borrowing has increased by 22% this year, while, after falling in recent months, unemployment is forecast to rise in 2013.

Continuing his casual relationship with reality, the Prime Minister spoke as the leader of an imaginary Conservative government, not a coalition. The only mention the Liberal Democrats received was when he reminded the hall that they had promised to cut NHS spending at the last election. But his speech did little to advance the quest for a Tory majority. If he is to succeed where he failed in 2010, Cameron needs to persuade an increasingly sceptical electorate that he has a plan for growth and that he can govern for the many, not just the few. He did neither today. 

22 comments

India's picture

I hope you’re prediction about the next election is right. Entrepreneurialism isn’t achieved by spreading by fear or by installing uniforms in schools. Did Steve Jobs wear a suit? More on Cameron and the ‘Rise of the Darwinian Knight’ at Indiabourke blogspot.

Indu Pendent's picture

"its not where you have come from that matters its where you are going".
- How more opposite to Labour could you get?

Labour's legacy is that half of all adults leave school without GCSE maths and english despite all the spin and billions of borrowing spent manipulating voters to keep Labour in power. Life chances of millions of people ruined by leveling down. The party does not care about people - it cares only about propelling a small political elite to power .

Herbert's picture

You realise this rant is totally oxymoronic I assume.

Dancing Dean's picture

Definition from the Cambridge dictionary of the word conservative -

often not liking or trusting change, especially sudden change........... If you are conservative in your appearance, you usually do not like fashionable or modern clothes or hairstyles.'

Oh shit its gona be a slow and bumpy ride people try and have a laugh eh :-)

Barrie J's picture

In the hall, his speech would have been enthusiastically received by an assortment of swivel eyed loons, the undead and those suffering from early and advanced senile dementia.
Outside, those largely irrelevant keyboard rattlers of the media.
A good and growing proportion of the rest of the country are however more concerned with their falling living standards, the ability to keep or get a job, the future of the Health Service, food price inflation, the cost of fuel, the declining value of their money and pensions, keeping warm and secure, getting a place for their children at the school of their choice, etc., etc., etc.
Yeah, Dave and his mob of miracle workers are doing just fine.

emilbus's picture

Cameron: 'When people earn money, it's their money'. But what exactly is the relationship between 'earnings' and labour? The tory philosophy is not just simplistic but selfish.

emilbus's picture

Cameron: 'When people earn money, it's their money'. But what exactly is the relationship between 'earnings' and labour? The tory philosophy is not just simplistic but selfish.

Stuart Eels's picture

Call me Dave has just shown himself to be as inept as Clegg and Miliband.

DAVIDASLINDSAY, you petty little man I would far rather read Dan Hodges comments than your self important dross zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Davidaslindsay's picture

Thank you for this. Elsewhere, the public school and bitter old Blairite line from the huddle is obvious enough on this. Dan Hodges, you know who you are. But I for one fell asleep during this speech. I bet that I was not the only one. Let's wait for the polls and then the upcoming by-elections (you know, real votes) shall we? We all know what they are going to say.

Michael Dixon's picture

I am afraid this article indicates that the New Statesman is a political magazine that is totally unable to give a balanced appraisal of a leading politician not connected to the Labour Party.

As a non-Labour supporter I have just been persuaded reading this not to resume my subscription from a few years past. Political debate and opposing views to mine yes and any time, but simplistic propaganda such as this no thank you.

angst's picture

"a million new private sector jobs had been created (although 196,000 of these were simply reclassified from the public sector)"

George, are you implying that Blair/brown never fudged the employment figures in their time in government? Brown seemed to think his figures were good, no more boom and bust he said, because we can boom forever, forget economics thats just for newbies like David Blanchflower, although David himself would like to think that all his predictions would have prevented this mess Labour left behind - and that sums up the Labour economic policy. Never trust Labour with money.

The economy and Europe are the battlegrounds in the next election and Ed offers nothing in these areas. Labour just aren't electable.

Quattro Man's picture

Fantastic speech from our leader, makes me proud to be British, poor old Red Ed, once again, been made to look like the second rate student politician he is.

Well done Dave, a stunning, inspiring speech, sets the foundation for us to rebuild our great country from the ruins left by the last government.

In our hour of need, Britain has once again chosen wisely.

PS. Best bit for me, "Labour has one notion...borrow"....luv it, sums them up perfectly.

LesHop's picture

Your being sarky aren't you. If not tell me why you think Ed is second rate compared to Cameron.Do you mean he is not an accomplished liar like our man of the people and he Camercon really cares about ordinary people,you know the ones trying to get the jobs that have vanished because everyone is frightened to spend because this shower has filled them with fear for their future and their jobs or are one of them, insulated from the real world and reality.

Quattro Man's picture

Complete nonsense, my 17 year old son went to the local state school, decided he wanted a job a month ago, went on Directgov jobs website, within a week had 3 job offers.....there are 1000's of jobs out there, I was amazed, we live out in the sticks....of course none for lazy losers who keep moaning about everything.

He was so encouraged be this deluge of job offers he decided, hey I can do anything...I would like to crew on a boat and sail the Atlantic...I said, you are crazy...but he registered with an appropriate agency, within 24hours he had been offered a paid crewing job and is currently sailing the Atlantic.

Stop moaning, get out there and take advantage of all the opportunity.

Thank you David for giving us hope after the long dark Labour years of lies, debt and deceit.

Whoosh oleander's picture

Get back to Central Office,no silly me you are still there.

postageincluded's picture

Defensive, yes, but with nods in all directions to the factions, largely defending his own position in the party.

Bill Kruse's picture

On the subject of growth, why do we need it? We need it because we have a banking system which perpetually takes out more than it puts in, a state of affairs which is impossible to maintain for long. Maintaining the banking system is costing us so dear we can't afford it any more, and that's what all our politicians, bar a handful, are refusing to face. Dave's got nothing to say on this subject but then, his father's money came from banking. He's the enemy and he knows. His time's run out, he knows that too. Hence his irrelevant speech today. The only way he could have made it relevant was to confess his way of life, the British Establishment's way of life, is over.

Bill Kruse's picture

On the subject of growth, why do we need it? We need it because we have a banking system which perpetually takes out more than it puts in, a state of affairs which is impossible to maintain for long. Maintaining the banking system is costing us so dear we can't afford it any more, and that's what all our politicians, bar a handful, are refusing to face. Dave's got nothing to say on this subject but then, his father's money came from banking. He's the enemy and he knows. His time's run out, he knows that too. Hence his irrelevant speech today. The only way he could have made it relevant was to confess his way of life, the British Establishment's way of life, is over.

Paul Hancock's picture

"The hall lapped it up, but Cameron's speech will have fallen flat in most of the country"

I live in most of the country. I am not a Tory. Yet I enjoyed the speech. Does that make me sceptical too?

Funny, but no person, let alone a politician, will ever win over EVERYONE. So split government again next election

Indu Pendent's picture

George

Do you think Labour should adopt Clinton Plan A economics -- fiscal tightening when everyone is saying it is the wrong thing?

Or should Labour, like Hilter, borrow enormously to manipulate voters? Just like the last government did. Just like Ed Balls plans to.

JimK's picture

"We were reminded again that the deficit had been reduced by a quarter" Which isn't even true, hell Newsnight pointed out the fiction of it on Monday night.

kenelmist's picture

Yes more like 2%.

Latest tweets