Now we have the truth about Hillsborough, it is time for justice
The report proves that it was the fans who were the real heroes on the day.
By Steve Rotheram Published 12 September 2012 17:17
A national tragedy requires a national response. At such a time, it is the responsibility of the Prime Minister to speak to Britain, for Britain. It is a task that only the Prime Minister can fulfil and its symbolism has a profound effect on those directly and indirectly associated with the tragedy. Today, the Prime Minister delivered, for the families, survivors, and the city of Liverpool.
Hillsborough will always be synonymous with one of the biggest losses of British life in any one day since the end of the Second World War. In the 23 years that have passed, two very different stories have emerged about that day, and three key elements have haunted those associated with it. The failure of the authorities to help protect people. The attempt to blame the fans. And the doubt cast on the original Coroner's Inquest.
The real version of events was told today and I am confident it will become known simply as ‘the truth’. It is a version of events that depicts the carnage at Hillsborough through the eyes of the survivors and the families of the victims. It makes clear that whilst the police froze and did nothing, the fans reacted and saved many more lives.
The second version, which has now been proven to be false, was told through the eyes of a warped media. The Sun newspaper despicably produced a headline that suggested Liverpool fans had stolen money from the dead, had urinated on the "brave cops" who were trying to save lives and had been drunk and ticketless. As the Prime Minister said, "This was clearly wrong."
Today's report has shocked the nation. 96 deaths, of which 41 could and should have survived if those responsible for our safety had done their jobs. 164 police officer statements amended, 116 negative comments removed from witness statements, and a 23 year campaign for truth and justice.
It proved, once and for all, that it was the fans who were the real heroes on the day and that the police, press and politicians, conspired to instigate a cover up that would smear a city and its people, whilst allowing the guilty to evade responsibility for their deadly mistakes. Liverpool has been exonerated. The guilt for the deaths lies squarely at the door of South Yorkshire Police, who made catastrophic mistakes and unashamedly sought to deflect the blame onto the fans.
The Hillsborough families cannot accept the Coroner’s verdict of "accidental death" and some have never even picked up the death certificates for their loved ones. It has been proved that some victims were alive well past the 3.15pm cut off and that if the authorities had acted quicker, more people would have survived. After today’s publication, the families will be appealing for the Attorney General to make an application to the High Court for the inquests to be reopened and a new cause of death to be determined.
Hillsborough was a tragedy that transcends party politics and unites parliament and the country. So whilst the overwhelming majority of Merseyside fundamentally disagrees with the Prime Minister’s politics and the direction he is taking the country, today we are eternally grateful.
His apology will not be met with celebrations on Merseyside. Instead, there will simply be dignified remembrance from a city that will no longer be a lone voice in a sea of ignorance and scepticism. Whilst for some, the true horror of 15 April 1989 has been eclipsed by the passage of time. For others, today’s news will see the conclusion of half our 23 year cause. Now that the truth has been ascertained, it is time for justice to be delivered.
Steve Rotheram is Labour MP for Liverpool Walton.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















14 comments
The House of Commons passed a motion on the 17th October 2011 in which they declared that it was the will of parliament to release all Government documentation to the panel, unredacted and without censor. They were therefore given the right to all the papers without the need for subpoenas to be issued.
1. Why was it necessary for South Yorks Police to treat the arrival of Liverpool fans like a military operation?
2. Why was no one killed at the Forest end of the stadium?
3. How is it that thousands of other matches took place at Hillsborough since Victorian times without anyone getting killed?
4. Why was it necessary to erect the barriers and railings in the first place?
5. Why is it that I can go to a rugby match and see three cops on duty, even if both home and away fans have both been drinking?
6. Why did 50,000 Liverpool fans turn up when they KNEW there only half that number of tickets?
Answers on a postcard.
It`s obvious you think `96` wasn`t enough, and after all, it was only "drunken scousers", so they deserved it, because it was all their own fault!!.
You represent the Kelvin Mackenzie mentality!, was you there?, did you lose a member of your family, or a friend?, or as is the norm with people like you, you got your information from `The Scum`?.
Can you imagine it taking 23 years, and counting, to finally start getting answers and the truth, if 96 people were crushed to death at Wimbledon, Twickenham or Royal Ascot?, i think we all know the answer to that one?.
It`s obvious you`re just an attention seeker who hides behind your PC, nevermind!!.
I have no doubt that Steve Rotherham M.P. is a man of
integrity, however,many of the public see the default position of the police and politicians as quick to deceive.
He must be aware that both those bodies have never previously been held in such contempt.
A closer investigation of the police handling of the miners' strike of 1984/85 would reveal their employment of a similar level of mendacity.
At the time their duplicity was reinforced by much of the media, even the BBC admitted to film 'getting mixed up in the editing.'
Nothing changes and don't think an apology by a Prime Minister is going radically alter things either.
The 'expenses scandal' showed us what our politicians are
and Hillsborough is just another notch on a bent copper's bedpost.
Apart from all the usual suspects in this nauseous cover up, the one person who had a major input in helping create the myth that the "drunken, ticketless" Liverpool fans were to blame for this tragedy, was, THATCHER!, along with the thug Ingham, This nasty, selfish, bitter person, should, along with all of the others, be held to account!!, i don`t care that she`s now a drooling old lady, just like she didn`t care about all of the victims!!.
Kelvin Mackenzie, the then editor of `The Scum`, should also be held to account for his knowingly `UNTRUTH` headlines regarding the victims at Hillsborough, he helped perpetuate the cover up which went to the very top, including his idol THATCHER!, this self publicist, and gutless coward, should go and join that other gutless coward, Murdoch, on his vomit churning Fox News, they`re used to telling lies and spreading hate!!., his insincere apology, as usual, goes down like a cup of cold sick, here in Liverpool!.
There must be lots of people in authority pooping themselves this morning, rightly so!, and those who`ve retired with big pensions and honours!, your numbers are up!, your JUSTICE is coming.
There were many more victims of hillsborough, the mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters, and children of the victims, they`ve had to live with the knowledge that their loved ones died a gruesome death, and that their loved ones had their characters destroyed, to help cover up the criminal incompetence of the Police, Ambulance, F.A, and the Thatcher govt, along with the help of vermin like Kelvin Mackenzie!.
Er, look, I for one am extremely puzzled here. The "Independent Panel" is not a judicial body, had no right to call witnesses or subpeona those who refused to attend, had no legal right to see the records, and was run by a bishop and some luvvies rather than an independent judge. How and where exactly did they come by the evidence which they purport to rely on? And how exactly did Call Me Dave manage to read and digest it that quickly that he w as able to make a speech on it within half an hour of it coming out? And how can anyone rely on this document to take legal action? Sounds like another MugPherson Report to me.
You're not puzzled you're stupid. We live in a world where the police, the banks, and to some extent the political system are criminal organisations.
This should be the model to follow whenever the great & good throw crap at the public.
No Bill23, he's not stupid, going from his other comments over the last few months. He's a very unpleasant troll, who thinks it's funny to revel in the pain and misery of others.
I have to disagree with you about the political system as well, Thatcher after all knew everything about it at the time.
When is someone (a Merseyside MP perhaps?) gonna apologise to the Belgian and Italian people for Heysel? Rhetorical question. One obvious point from a first perusal of the Report (which will no doubt soon become a secular bible on Merseyside) - they admit that 50,000 Liverpool fans turned up that day: there were only about 25,000 places for them.
Lets hope the families get their targets, they deserve that these filthy laggard morons that prevented summary justice at the time - think they got off with it;do not!
Patnick should be stripped of his knighthood and Mackenzie should face prison
1996 John Major
Tony Blair and Scouse wife and lawyer Cherie Boothe.
Gordon Brown
Now David Cameron has been asked to apologize for their lack of substance.
Seems the fans were made the scapegoats, indeed bodies had false medical reports made and police seems to have made alterations to statements.
I hope all involved that never done anything and allowed the subversion of justice and the manslaughter and indeed assisted manslaughter, bordering on murder be allowed to renounce their pensions, their houses and their honours for duties to State, you know all the golden gongs for duties and lauded titles.
Even though a Mancunian I wish that those available at the very top to be stripped of all their resources, and all police and medical staff that put forward details other than those that were legal. Indeed many deserve prison.
Well, he would say that wouldnt he? He wants to be re elected.
Well said. I hope that aay subsequent enquiry will not just focus on the disgraceful behaviour of the police, but also that of Sir Irvine Patnick and Kelvin Mackenzie.