Labour turns on Cable over "capitulation" to the Tories
Chuka Umunna says reforms to employment law are an attack on workers' rights.
By George Eaton Published 14 September 2012 9:12
Last week, Vince Cable was eulogised by Ed Balls as the Lib Dem who could no almost wrong. "Vince has distinguished himself by always making the argument about what's right for Britain," he said, as he beamed at the Business Secretary, sat beside him on Andrew Marr's sofa.
But Balls's colleague Chuka Umunna, the shadow business secretary, isn't feeling so charitable towards Cable. Earlier this morning, Umunna took to Twitter to criticise the Business Secretary's reforms to employment law as an attack on workers' rights. He added that Ming Campbell, who has questioned Cable's textual relations with Labour, should worry more about "Cable's capitulation to Fallon, Hancock and co. on employment law"
Vince Cable's employment law proposals today water down the rights at work of every employee in the UK
— Chuka Umunna (@ChukaUmunna) September 14, 2012
While Cable will today formally reject calls for the introduction of "no-fault dismissal" or fire-at-will (a proposal that emanated from Tory donor Adrian Beecroft's now-infamous report on employment law), he will announce a significant cut in the cap on unfair dismissal payouts. The current £72,000 limit is expected to be reduced to an employee's annual salary, or another lower figure. In addition, employment tribunals will be sped up, so that costs are reduced and weak cases thrown out more swiftly. Though you wouldn't know it from the right's response, 80 per cent of Beecroft's recommendations have been adopted or put out to consultation.
Continuing his assault on Cable, Umunna declared, "We're not in a recession because of the rights our constituents have at work - its cos of the govt's failed economic plan." The Business Secretary, of course, wouldn't disagree. During his appearance on Marr last week, he sagely observed, "The problem of growth is that we have a very serious shortage of demand. It's nothing to do with those supply side measures basically. It's a demand issue."
As a result, suspicion persists among the Tories that Cable's heart isn't really in it. But whatever the Business Secretary's true feelings, a third successive quarter of recession persuaded the coalition partners to strike a grand bargain on growth. You give us supply-side reform, and we'll give you a small business bank (a measure that allowed Cable to hail the end of "pure laissez-faire" economics).
Umunna's decision to respond with an attack of rare ferocity suggests that not everyone in Labour is so keen to lure the Business Sectetary from the Tories' clutches.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















13 comments
Balls has stated that jobs will always come before pay, the unions may have made a song and dance about it, but that is the correct path to improving the balance in the economy. we need to spend extra public cash on infrastructure investments the economy badly needs rather than more benefits, wages and services. Cable is just as pragmatic as Balls.
It all depends what parameters your working to and your faith in markets. People like yourself believe in taking more from already poor. Others believe that wealth is too polarised and that the system is rigged to favour wealthy and the only reasonable course of action is for government adopt a more progressive taxation system, take a more active role in industry , provide more varied employment opportunities instead of cutting the bottom tier of society loose and making already severe social problems very much worse.
Perhaps a little reality has intruded into Vince Cable's thinking?
After all, the man has spent years fighting FOR a bigger, more intrusive government. Battling tax evaders! LOL But when you're in coalition with a group with whose ideology you fundamentally disagree you have to compromise. The current crisis of the social welfare state implies that the steps toward the solution - real capitalism and greater personal liberty - will be playing a larger role in future.
Government meddling in the labour market SHOULD be in decline.
Perhaps Cable HAS come around...or perhaps some sense has merely been knocked into his head.
Old Vince has sure got gumption. Keeps wearing the 'hat'. Of course he's been advised it makes him look like a KGB agent. But will he be told? Noooo!
Just don't wear 'specs' with that headgear. Much too like Comrade Beria.
Double Agent
Old Vince has sure got gumption. Keeps wearing the 'hat'. Of course he's been advised it makes him look like a KGB agent. But will he be told? Noooo!
Just don't wear 'specs' with that headgear. Much too like Comrade Beria.
Double Agent
Cable is a spineless, unprincipled, useless, incompetent twat. What the fuck are Labour courting this charlatan for?
Because they're spineless, unprincipled, useless, incompetent twats. Birds of a feather etc.
Of course Vince Cable is working for Britain, but in Europe, just ask his wife - whom wants to help her homeland, he was spot 0n with the banking after it failed and aired his views during that failure.
Cable's fancy dress 'Morris dancing with Clegg's', the turned up trousers leg, the funny handshake turned-up trousers.
Funny last time I went past the Duke of Kent's Lodge there were funny men getting out of a failed car and asked me for a lift. They were all dressed alike him.
Beware of old politicians that give your children chocolate before they rape your country.
Seems Cable has never before worked for Tory slave-masters - but well, he has changed , and indeed is making fascist multinational importers and billionaires richer.those that fleece all and have VAT free offices in Europe and abroad.
Internal Chimney stack cleaning for children his next political offering.
Do not worry Labour have not a clue as to what is going on! I worry though!
Dave Cameron, if Europe was for fair trading - how can they have offices there that make British companies exempt for taxes?.
If you get back from horse-riding with Murdoch and do another deal, as on your three lost days in Oxford-shire with your Dominatrix for Newt Binternational then let us know!
Umunna is right in this case. I don't know why Cable gets this reputation for principle.
He forwarded something close to Labour's plans prior to the election then has argued consistently for the Tories plan post election. He was a major part of the tuition fees fiasco.
He's not a man of strong principle and the Labour leadership are wrong to think otherwise. He's enjoying the limelight and power and would like more should the opportunity arise.
In a sense he's worse. He knows better and has backed this vile government.
At-will employment is a loathsome and common feature of American labour relations. Recommend googling the wikipedia page on it, as well as other sources.
Cable is a sheep in sheep's clothing.
I was employed earlier this year by a high street bank via an employment agency and told the job would last 12 weeks and I would get plenty of advance warning when the assignment would end. After 5 weeks I was told I would be finished that same day as the volume of work had been over-estimated. As far as my experience of work is concerned we already have a hire and fire culture now.
I was employed earlier this year by a high street bank via an employment agency and told the job would last 12 weeks and I would get plenty of advance warning when the assignment would end. After 5 weeks I was told I would be finished that same day as the volume of work had been over-estimated. As far as my experience of work is concerned we already have a hire and fire culture now.