Nicky Woolf in America

The view from Middle America

Syndicate contentRSS

How the fighting talk fizzled from Mitt Romney's Republican Party

The GOP has allowed the Democrats to seize their ideological heartland - patriotism and defence.

Mitt Romney
Mitt Romney didn't use words like "soldier", "terror" or "safe" once in his convention speech. Photograph: Getty Images

Mitt Romney is in Ohio again, his fifteenth trip to this state this year. He pledged yesterday at a campaign rally in Mansfield, about three hours east of Hicksville, to protect the military from coming budgetary cuts to defence, known as the “sequestration”. He was undermined by the fact that a majority of congressional republicans – his running-mate Paul Ryan included – voted in favour of it.

This is the latest in a series of similar embarrassments for the Romney campaign. The Grand Old Party, as the Republicans are known, has been comprehensively outflanked and routed on the subject of the military, and are ceding vast swathes of territory on what just eight years ago was their home ground: patriotism and defence.

The evidence is clearest in the candidates' speeches to their national conventions. In his acceptance speech in 2004, George W Bush used the words “troops,” “Iraq,” “Afghanistan,” “battle,” “soldier,” “terror” and “safe,” and their derivatives (safety, terrorist, terrorism and so on) a total of 58 times – fifty-eight – to John Kerry's 11.

This pattern reversed in the 2008 election. John McCain used the above words just nine times in his acceptance speech, while Obama used them 29 times – though the effect of this was somewhat lightened by McCain's own war record, on which his campaign dwelt incessantly.

This reversal is even more dramatic in the conventions just past. While Obama did tone down the fighting talk, using those words above just 11 times, Mitt Romney did not use any of them. Not even once.

Remember that this is the presidential nominee from the party of George W Bush, the party that forged the neo-conservatism of Karl Rove and Dick Cheney; remember also that this is the party that coined the phrase “war on terror”.

Not once did this man who wants to be elected Commander-in-Chief of the world's most powerful military mention the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan; not once did he mention terrorism, or war. Veterans and soldiers merited not one single solitary mention. Ryan, too, failed to hint at even the existence of any of these things in his speech.

John McCain was a war veteran; in fact he had a long and distinguished military career. Mitt Romney is not, and nor is this a deficit his running-mate fills; indeed, as mentioned before, Ryan voted in favour of sequestration of the military budget.

The Democrats are planting banners and occupying what used to be the Republicans' ideological heartland. Perhaps their party leadership simply got complacent, unable to conceive that the Democrats could steal a march on them in this way. Perhaps the rise in influence of the Tea Party on the far right, with their small-government and big-God ideals, has something to do with it. More likely is that, given the Romney-Ryan ticket's paucity of foreign policy heft, their campaign tacticians are scared of bringing up the subject and allowing the President to play his trump card: the killing of Osama Bin Laden in May 2011.

The Obama campaign has just brought out a new poster which says :“Sarah Palin said she could see Russia from Alaska; Mitt Romney talks like he's only seen Russia by watching Rocky IV”. They are also firing broadsides into Romney's pledges to protect military spending while reducing the deficit; this was the bullseye of Bill Clinton's barnstorming “arithmetic” line in his speech last week.

Yesterday in his Ohio rally, Romney ran to one of the few remaining Republican safe zones left – religion – pledging to keep God in the public sphere and in his party's platform - a thinly-veiled reference to the Democrats' omission of the word from theirs. But, in front of a military crowd, the blow failed to land.

Today is 9/11, the anniversary of the day that changed America – and American foreign policy – forever. Today will be a day of solemnity and remembrance for both campaigns, and for the nation. Romney is spending the day in Reno, Nevada, addressing the National Guard Association conference alongside a brace of generals. But it seems like too little, too late. Those horrific attacks, eleven years ago today, lit a fire deep in the belly of this country. It seems to have fizzled and died in the belly of the Republican Party.

21 comments

Raven's picture

Quoting the Washington Post: "According to a recent Public Policy Poll, 31 percent of Ohioans are not sure whether Mitt Romney or Barack Obama was more responsible for killing Osama bin Laden. In fact, 15 percent of Republicans were convinced that Romney was more responsible." wapo.st/Q9DsZJ

John Cheese's picture

Guess he has to mention Libya & Israel today due to Barry 0 screwing the pooch...I'm smelling peanuts again...

Ted Schrey     Montreal's picture

Yes, well, there's Hicksvilles all over rural America, let's not be too sensitive, shall we?

hugh markey's picture

Isn't it time that political attack ad aired on TV by LBJ was dusted off and used yet again. In 1964 the little girl plucking off the petals of a daisy whilst hesitantly counting them and backed by the eerily echoey missile countdown cooled a lot of hotheads.
Then there was only the Soviet missile monsters to worry the US electorate. Now the Presidential Challenger's fellow Americans have the Chinese and Russian rocket forces to face off.
Let's see how hard they are? Got a feelin' Gabby Hayes is right ="Deep down these sidewinders is yellar!" And since 'Nam how many times has Uncle Sam called 'uncle'?
And Gosh Darn it - it won LBJ the election.

Dude Cowboy

Talkin' 's Cheap

Herbert's picture

'... patriotism and defence...'

Surely it's 'militarism and offence' and nothing really to boast about.

jankaas's picture

perhaps the real reason Romney is completely avoiding war references is because he was a draft dodger.

rather than accept his obligation to be drafted into the armed forces he escaped to France to do very very important missionary work for the Mormon Church. as if French people needed missionary zeal to assist them....
and how long did Romney hide away? 2.5 years, when the normal lentgh of a Mormon mission is 6 to 18 months.

he then dodged the draft further by claiming academic deferment for another 3 years. the man is as yellow as they get.

so you have a double whammy; draft dodger and he loves France and all it represents.

man's a total buffoon and a liability on most issues.

John Cheese's picture

Guess you're as mad at BJ Clinton for the same thing then, correctamundo?

Fred a Monty's picture

Focus, friend of truth and logic. Mr. Clinton is not running this election. Who cares who sucked his dick?

We're dealing with a different election.

Focus.

John Cheese's picture

Spoken like a true lefty libbie Demoncrat...hey, let me know when you speak again to John (definitely not my baby) Edwards, you know, the turd that the Dems were 3 sec away from nominating

Herbert's picture

Perhaps he was working for the CIA, like that other draft dodger Bill 'Suck on this, sucker' Clinton.

Fred a Monty's picture

Again, focus. Who cares about this Clinton character? You're stuck, can't think of a current reply. Unless you want me to dredge up 100 years of political history, come up with something new.

I can bash history as well as the next.

You wanna talk Mormon history? Wanna talk baptismal of Ann's Frank?

Wanna?

John Cheese's picture

How about this half-monty: GD America & white devils? Starts his campaign in domestic terrorist Bill Ayers home. Not proud of our country? Is that OK for our President? Non-vetted. Shielded. Fake Social Security number. Locked down collegiate records. All of them. All real-time, this administration. Is that current enough? We have a turd living in dreamland & one that's in over his head. He's going to lose.

Fred a Monty's picture

I love Mitt and his little puppet. They baptized my entire family after they were dead.

John Cheese's picture

Slandering the mormon is not far off from Obama's warning about "slandering the prophet of islam"... better watch out half monty!

jankaas's picture

and your point being what exactly Herbert?

Old Guy From Ohio's picture

"three hours west of Hicksville."
Nice. Thanks for the ad hominen jab at 11,000,000 people who vote for the more progressive candidate about 50% of the time.

Nicky Woolf's picture

 

I'm sorry - it wasn't meant as an ad hominem attack. As Terrance says, I am currently based in Hicksville, in Defiance county, but I can see why the name - and perhaps the choice of place - might raise your hackles slightly.
 
Essentially I jabbed my finger in the map where I wanted to go. Hicksville is almost exactly in the middle of the square formed by Chicago, Detroit, Indianapolis and Columbus. The name of the county - Defiance - I liked, and I must admit that the name of the town tickled me a little too. I realise that this particular county is Republican territory, but I also realise that Ohio is a complex political entity, and that not far away from me are very different areas with very different makeups and political outlook - and I am looking forward to exploring the whole state, and understanding the election campaign here as it develops.
Old Guy From Ohio's picture

Sorry for the overreaction, and thank you for the gracious clarification. And as to the directional clarification, yes, not being familiar with the actual Hicksville on the Indiana border, I figured you were just coming to the usual conclusion of "well, I've crossed the Allegheny mountains and have left civilization."

Terrance Farquit's picture

Um. I think it's Hicksville, Ohio they are talking about. About three hours west of Mansfield (despite the piece implying east). And where the correspondant is based for the Election. Not an ad hominem. Or am i missing something?

Nicky Woolf's picture

Oops, you're absolutely right - I got east and west reversed. I'll correct it now.

Herbert's picture

There's also a Hicksville in New York State. Try Wiki.

Latest tweets