Saudi Arabia executes "sorcerer"
The kingdom's zero-tolerance attitude to psychics contrasts with our own more laissez-faire approach
By Nelson Jones Published 20 September 2011 16:56
Sally Morgan, aka "Psychic Sally", a popular television clairvoyant, finds herself in a spot of bother today. After one of her shows in Dublin, an audience member described how she had heard a man hidden in a small room at the back of the theatre passing on information about people in the audience. Professor Chris French reports:
Sue believes, not unreasonably, that the man was feeding information to Sally through an earpiece attached to her microphone. For example, the voice would say something like "David, pain in the back, passed quickly" and a few seconds later Sally would claim to have the spirit of a "David" on stage who -- you'll never guess -- suffered from back pain and passed quickly.
Morgan has denied everything. Perhaps, though, she should consider herself fortunate to have no only disillusioned audience members and professional sceptics to deal with. In Saudi Arabia, a man has just been beheaded for doing far less.
Abdul Hamid Bin Hussein Bin Moustafa al-Fakki, from Sudan, was convicted in 2007 of the crime of sorcery. According to Amnesty International, which appealed for clemency, he was approached by a member of the religious police, the Mutawa'een, who requested a spell to persuade his father to go back to his first wife, the man's mother. Al-Fakki agreed to cast the spell for the sum of 6,000 riyals (around £1,000) but was arrested after handing over the fruit of his labours: nine pieces of paper with codes written on them with saffron. The Mutawa'een had written down the serial numbers of the banknotes with which Al-Fakki was paid.
However worthless the spell, death by beheading seems a bit harsh.The case is not an isolated one. Ali Sibat, a Labenese national whose "crime" seems to have consisted of telling fortunes on satellite TV, was arrested while on pilgrimage in Medina in 2008. He came close to being executed last year. International pressure seems to have won him a last-minute reprieve but he remains in prison on death row. His case has been highlighted by Human Rights Watch.
Then there's Fawza Falih, detained by religious police in 2005 and allegedly beaten and forced to fingerprint a confession that she could not read. She was accused of making a man impotent by means of magic. The only evidence was the man's testimony but an appeal court upheld the death sentence as being in the public interest. She was still on death row when she died last year, her health broken. She is said to have "choked on her food".
The decision to execute al-Fikki, the first time a "sorcerer" has been decapitated since 2007 (when the guilty man was also convicted of adultery and desecrating a Quran), may mark a new phase in a clampdown against witchcraft in the kingdom that has been in going on for some time now. In early 2009, leading Arabic newspaper Asharq Al-Awsat reported that the Committee for the Promotion of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice -- the body that oversees the religious police -- had launched a new strategy. Previous cases had "revealed the spread of witchcraft and magic throughout the country" and thus the inadequacy of the current laws. The new plans were intended to produce a more coherent approach
by making legal and regulatory determinations, as well as clarify the burden of evidence for magic and witchcraft cases as being scientific and practical, while also increasing the number of those involved incombating such cases.
They sought, among other things, a scientific definition to magical practices, and a model in order to help uncover such practices. " A joint taskforce was set up embracing the religious police and security agencies, encouraging them to work more closely together in the campaign against sorcery." The experts were anxious "to protect the public from communication and television channels that promote magic" partly through a publicity campaign warning about the dangers -- and also expressed concerns about the internet.
Despite all this pseudo-rationalism, the disturbing fact remains that, in the 21st century, a key western ally is still executing people for a wholly imaginary crime. Even Psychic Sally doesn't deserve that.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















20 comments
John Woods, so what your saying is 20-30 million muslims in Europe are engaging in "girl-circumcising, forced marriage arranging, bus blowing up, superstitious under age girl grooming fruitcakes".
Your ignorance and bigotry is astounding.
Muppet still stands but can I add stupid wanker. Thanks.
So sue me.
Such appalling racism.
Who are we to judge their culture; however primitive it may appear to us?
Chanting "Blessed Be!" gets your head cut off in Saudi Arabia?
Why weren't there mass protests over all the world like there were for that guy in Georgia?
Double standard? Or just not as many points to be scored?
The Non-Conformist/"Progressive" conscience really is the most ridiculous and pitiful group.
I am not judging their culture, barbaric as it is. I have no objectin to moslems beheading other moslems in moslem countries. It aint my business. Problem is, if we keep importing millions of these crazies, it wil soon be OUR culture.
I am a Muslim. I don't attend mosque always, but I do pray sometimes and I don't and wouldn't behead sorcerers. My Dad reads coffee grounds and his party trick is to tell fortunes. He's a Muslim too.
I am British and grateful for the beautiful multi-ethnic and diverse culture that we share. I believe in social democracy, in giving what you can and taking no more than you need. I believe in freedom of expression, of thought, and judging others by their actions. These principles are mine and I do not believe that they are incompatible with Islam, far from it in fact.
It is not racist to say that beheading a man is barbaric, regardless, and I would invite judgement on that. I would also invite judgement on societies that would denounce such behaviour in public but support such regimes economically in private.
I think it is also self evidently prejudiced, and I would argue misguided, to say that millions of people are all the same because of something so utterly deplorable that has happened in Saudi.
John Woods, I suspect I will not convince you but few "Muslims" hold the barbaric views you imply all Muslims hold and those that do, I would argue that Islam is not the cause of them but used an excuse to do harm as many religions and beliefs do sadly.
I would contest that "primitive" and ignorant, even barbaric behaviour and views, are sadly widespread through all faiths and peoples of the globe.
Or more succinctly, WE are the problem and only when we start seeing each other as equally deserving of humanity, life, and liberty will we stand a chance of saving ourselves.
I can't imagine JK Rowling will be invited to Saudi for a book signing.
@ Hashim Hassam:
" I would also invite judgement on societies that would denounce such behaviour in public but support such regimes economically in private."
Absolute direct hit -- so true, and so sickening. Immediately brings to mind the footage of President Bush holding hands with Saudi Arabia's Prince Abdullah.
The Saudis can behead each other all they want -- the real moral outrage is that our western leaders haven't the character, vision, or intellect to find a way out of their relationship with them.
After all, beheading someone for sorcery violates OUR values, not theirs. So what's our excuse? We flush all of our values right down the toilet in exchange for $1/gallon cheaper oil.
Western support for Saudi Arabia is what's disgusting and morally repugnant.
And we have let 20-30 million of these people into Europe. Wunnerful.
Well, have you asked Mehdi Hasan where he stands on the subject of beheading sorcerers?
This is an absolute disgrace.
And we're selling armaments to these people? A curse on the House of Saud.
They keep a lot of us Brits employed, buy a load of our security hardware, own nearly all of London, our Industries and our governments.
@ john woods.
I wasnt aware that 20-30 million saudis had emigrated to europe...
What a muppet!
@hashim Hassan
While I fully agree with you on all your ethical points, I must point out that you obviously do not understand your own religion very well if you think your principles are not incompatible with Islam.
Also, the majority of Muslims do hold barbaric, intolerant views and I would argue that Islam is the cause.
Whacky old geezers with beards can be dangerous for your health. And we suck up to them as civilised. "Oh it's their belief ..." "Oh it's shit belief if someone is decapitated with a sword (?) on such a charge. Oil the great god of keeping from telling these guys to take a running jump.
Crazygoatfucker writes:
How DARE you put "sorcerer" in inverted commas? This is a calculated insult to the religion of peace!!!
All us Islamonazi goatfuckers KNOW he was a sorcerer!!!
There is a Fatwa against you and your publishers!!!
So they won't be staging 'Blithe Spirit' at the British Council in Mecca then?
The more I hear about Saudi the more I wold wish and hope that the Arab Spring flow and gush and wash away that feudal monarchy.
Has Jones ascertained the views of his colleague Mehdi Hassan on executing sorcerers? Woulda thought he'd be all in favour.
Adam, you know perfectly well that I was not just referring to Saudis but to the 57 other varieties of girl-circumcising, forced marriage arranging, bus blowing up, superstitious under age girl grooming fruitcakes who follow the teachings of a certain 7th century paedophile, slave trading, camel shagging lunatic