Mehdi Hasan

Mehdi Hasan’s polemical take on politics, economics and foreign affairs

Syndicate contentRSS

Noam Chomsky and his Israeli opponents

Quote of the day!

Professor Noam Chomsky, the world-famous political and intellectual dissident once described in the Guardian as "one of the ten most quoted sources in the humanities -- along with Shakespeare and the Bible", has been barred by the Israeli government from lecturing in the occupied West Bank.

From ABC News:

Israeli authorities admitted today that they erred by denying renowned left-wing, US intellectual Noam Chomsky entry into Israeli-controlled territory.

After hours of questioning by Israeli officials at a border crossing between Jordan and the occupied Palestinian West Bank he was forced to return to the Jordanian capital Amman.

A linguist and political activist with a track record of criticizing Israeli policy, Chomsky had been scheduled to deliver two lectures at the Palestinian University of Bir Zeit. He was also due to meet Palestinian Prime Minister Salaam Fayyed and other officials from the Palestinian Authority.

Chomsky told the Israeli daily Haaretz in a telephone interview that he thought the decision had been taken because of his political views and because he was only visiting a Palestinian college and not an Israeli one as well.

But for me, the best quotation of all comes from the piece in the Guardian (quoting the prof on al-Jazeera):

He told al-Jazeera television that the immigration official who interviewed him had made it clear that "the government of Israel doesn't like the kinds of things I say, which puts them into the same category as every other government in the world".

43 comments

Richard W. Symonds's picture

"He is a fearless, formidable, totally independent voice. He does something which is really quite simple but highly unusual. He tells the truth.”

Harold Pinter Introduces Noam Chomsky. St. Pauls Cathedral, London, 2002

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Dicky squeeks '' Harold Pinter.''

Another donut.

Richard W. Symonds's picture

Your arrogant, ignorant stupidity is getting a little tiresome, AAH.

But if it's a form of therapy for you to express yourself in such a way, may you soon be healed.

clem the gem's picture

AAH, are you sure you dont need a hug? Not even a little one? Was it a bad day?

Whilst defending Chomskys right as an author and academic, and his rights to protest and travel, he is not always right - no-one is.

At least he is right vis-avis the "truthers" out there. Apparently has interesting views on linguistics...

Richard W. Symonds's picture

Yes indeed, Clem the Gem, Chomsky certainly "has interesting views on linguistics" - he revolutionised the subject.

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Dicky

If you cant handle the truth, thats your problem, deal with it, kid.

Richard W. Symonds's picture

"Either you repeat the same conventional doctrines everybody is saying, or else you say something true, and it will sound like it's from Neptune"

Noam Chomsky

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Dicky

That sounds something out of a Christmas cracker.

davidtownhill's picture

Chomsky is an inspiration and the man that made me question the mainstream view. His books are insightful and more than a little disturbing in their presentation of the truth. The world needs a lot more people like him.

Richard W. Symonds's picture

The world also needs a lot more people to read him...

Sciamachy's picture

AAH - What specifically is your problem with Prof. Chomsky?

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Dicky squeels ''Your arrogant, ignorant stupidity''

Very intolerant of other peoples views, arent you Dicky ?

Me thinks you are a BNP supporter.

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Dicky says ''Chomsky can be compared to William 'Haw-Haw' Joyce.''

Well done lad, I knew you could do it.

David Walker's picture

What a knob. And I don't mean that as a compliment.

mitchy's picture

Chomsky's ability to cut through the bullshit and lies we're fed by the self-styled 'elites' is second to none. The man's a sage.

As for you, Abdul, you're a troll aren't you? Grow the f**k up mate, noone's interested in your silly wee posts. Find another website more sympathetic to your level of debate, like CBeebies or something.

Remember good people, don't feed the trolls.

Mohammad's picture

Lol! Abdul Amir Hassan, if you don't have a point to make, please bugger off. At least the others who criticise Mehdi usually have a point. You just ramble nonsensically...

Mehdi: So much for freedom of speech and all that old tripe, eh? How hypocritical are the Israeli government...ban the man from their country because he'll expose them.

Richard W. Symonds's picture

If you believe in freedom of speech, you believe in freedom of speech for views you don't like. Goebbels was in favor of freedom of speech for views he liked. So was Stalin. If you're in favor of freedom of speech, that means you're in favor of freedom of speech precisely for views you despise.

If we don't believe in free expression for people we despise,
we don't believe in it at all.

Noam Chomsky

Alexander Ward's picture

Noam Chomsky is my hero.

Daragh McDowell's picture

Now if only Mehdi could find some way to blame this on Clegg and those treasonous Lib Dems...

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Noam Chomsky is a Donut.

Nuff said.

I hope and pray that this doesnt become another Medhi fan club sooook fest

Dear God, I dont think I could cope if that happened again.

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Daragh

Very witty.

tomhagen's picture

FAO Abdul Amir Hasan

I don't often comment on the actions of internet imbeciles but you are quite possibly one of the most arbitrary, insulting, crude, incoherent and uninformed posters I have ever come across. And I follow CiF.

Anyway its good that Mehdi Hasan's writing now has the following that it does, he is very good.

But I do think he needs to reassess his ConDem position, what other options were there for a strong government?

Daragh McDowell's picture

Well Mehdi's not going to get himself on QT snarking about Chomsky...

Sean Brennan's picture

Noam speaks truth to power

His writings on US and Israeli foreign policy are always brilliant.

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

'' you are quite possibly one of the most arbitrary, insulting, crude, incoherent and uninformed posters I have ever come across.''

Thanks for the compliment Tom, much appreciated, its nice to have a fan.

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Mohammad

'' if you don't have a point to make,You just ramble nonsensically, bugger off''

Is it because ah is brown ?

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

mitchy squeels'' no one's interested in your silly wee posts.''

I do not converse with Scottish drunks.

And with that, you are dismissed.

Paul Rigby's picture

For a very different view of Chomsky, supporter of both the Warren Report and Zelikow's 9/11 whitewash, try here:

http://www.deeppoliticsforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2576

Daragh McDowell's picture

@Paul Rigby

So... you don't like Chomsky because he doesn't believe that the US government conspired to commit the 9/11 attacks - a conspiracy that would require the support, silence, and total commitment of tens of thousands of individuals, all recruited, screened and vetted in total secrecy from hundreds of different walks of life.

I've been indulging in a bit of Mehdi bashing over the past couple of days, but can I ask our sponsor to tell the 9/11 'Truthers' and assorted looney tunes to bugger off?

thinkov's picture

vindictive evil from the vilest country on earth

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Thinkov

I wouldnt call Medhi that

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

My dear conspiratorial friend Medhi, there is no cover-up

I think you've been reading too many Enid Blyton thrillers

Gnome was banned because he's just a boring old fart, thems the facts.

Mrs Nobody's picture

Noam Chomsky is one of the few voices of truth in the world. Long may he live.

Richard W. Symonds's picture

"Very sad to see what’s happening to I####l" - C

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

''Long may he live.''

Gnome is 87, he's in Gods waiting room, Luv.

Richard W. Symonds's picture

Chomsky has just been compared to William 'Haw-Haw' Joyce.

This is not just morally sick, but lethally dangerous, as he (& his daughter) are in the Middle East.

thinkov's picture

aah

I meant you !

you are quite some keyboard warrior ,what drives you?

writeoff's picture

Abdul will get bored. But then maybe not, if he thinks Enid Blyton writes thrillers. Chomsky rocks. Good quote Mehdi. Says it all.

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

write off

The Famous 5 , the secret 7. Everyone a thriller !

So There !!

ibgbt226m9p9's picture

Thinkov, squeeks ''what drives you?''

Im on a God given mission to fight the racism, sexism, homophobia, BNP, anti semitism, that spews out of the New Statesman.

Chris's picture

So much for the "only democracy in the M.E." and freedom of speech. At least Chomsky has a good sense of humour, even though this kind of treatment must be frustrating.

thinkov's picture

blimey aah that's quite your most misguided rant yet

I speak in a low voice btw

Alexander Ward's picture

Abdul Amir Hassan - He's 81, get your facts right.

Also, the New Statesman is a political journal of the left, not of the right. What are you talking about?

Latest tweets