Why the UK should boycott Euro 2012 in Ukraine
Cameron should join Merkel and take a stand on political repression.
By Denis MacShane Published 02 May 2012 12:42
Does Roy Hodgson speak Ukrainian? The question arises as England’s new multilingual manager now faces the horror problem of all sports bureaucracy – namely whether England should play in Ukraine given the alarming reports about political repression there.
Last October, I asked David Cameron about the harsh treatment of the former Ukrainian prime minister, Yulia Tymoshenko. She had been placed on a political show trial by the current Ukrainian president, Viktor Yanokuvych, her deadly life-long rival. The charge was poor administration of the complex energy dossier from the time Ms Tymoshenko was prime minister.
The Prime Minister’s reply was robust. Cameron said “‘We completely agree that the treatment of Mrs Tymoshenko, whom I have met on previous occasions, is absolutely disgraceful. The Ukrainians need to know that if they leave the situation as it is, it will severely affect their relationship not only with the UK but with the European Union.”
So will Cameron now join other European leaders and take a stand on the ill-treatment of Ms Tymoshenko who is now suffering from severe health problems as Yanukovych regime increase pressure on her? Hillary Clinton has now expressed concern about Ms Tymoshenko’s health as well as the continuing prosecution by the Yanukovych clique of the former prime minister’s aides and associates.
Not content with winning power Yanukovich is determined to take revenge on anyone who challenged him in his years of opposition after the Orange Revolution. In Ms Tymoshenko he rightly sees a serious opponent. But the Ukrainian ruler like his friend, Vladimir Putin, whose inauguration as Russian president next Monday will be greeted by protests, refuses to abide by the normal rules of Council of Europe member states and accept that an opposition should exist as part of democratic politics. Politics is personal in Russia and Ukraine and where better to dump a political opponent than in prison.
The question for us is: will Cameron live up to his word? Will the treatment of Ms Tymosenko “severely affect” the UK-Ukraine relationship as he told the Commons six months ago? Many of his fellow centre-right leaders in Europe think so. Angela Merkel has said she will not go to the Euro 2012 contest as long as the Ukrainians continue to hold Ms Tymoshenko in prison in dire conditions. She is joined by the EU Commission President, Jose Manuel Barroso and Cameron’s close political Eurosceptic ally, Vaclav Klaus, the president of the Czech Republic. The presidents of Austria and Germany have also said they will boycott the Ukraine matches.
It is a problem for England as all the first round matches are being played in Ukraine even if the team themselves are going to stay in Poland for the contest. The real responsibility lies with UEFA who should threaten to relocate the matches out of Ukraine if Ms Tymoshenko is not released and allowed to have proper medical care.
But as with the Bahrain F1 Grand Prix, the wilful blindness of sports organisers to how they can end up boosting repressive regimes should be examined. In 1938 the England football team in Germany were ordered to give the Hitler salute by the Football Association. Whatever their bleating about not getting involved in politics, the 3 Lions will be used by Yanukovich to boost his repressive regime Today, while William Hague and Cameron wallow in their (perfectly correct) denunciations of Syria they are silent on Bahrain. In China, Cameron refused to mention the name of Liu Xiaobo, the Nobel Peace Laureate who is rotting in the Chinese gulag. At least Mrs Thatcher raised the case of Andrei Sakharov and Malcolm Rifkind when a junior FCO minister in the 1980s went to Poland and expressed support for the banned Solidarity trade union.
Today, Britain’s foreign policy has all but given up on human rights. Instead William Hague’s mercantilism -- trade above democracy and human rights -- prevails. Almost certainly the Hague mercantilist wing of the British state regret that Cameron was so forthright in his support for Yulia Tymoshenko in the Commons. But the Prime Minister should stick to his position and join Angela Merkel and other EU leaders in boycotting Euro 2012. It may be too much to ask Hodgson and Wayne Rooney to take a stand. But how wonderful if England’s political-sporting nexus could speak for freedom and decency rather than hiding behind the lie that sport and politics should not mix.
Denis MacShane is MP for Rotherham and former Europe Minister. Follow him at @denismacshane and www.denismacshane.com
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists



















11 comments
The current MEGAcriminal yanukovich' regime in Ukraine is backed by mafia. Their so-called government was formed by coup d'etat, by violation of Constitution of Ukraine (Article 83 p.6); since then it's a constant violation of Law, Freedom, Human Rights and Democracy itself. Would you like the same dictatorship in the UK? alongside with some footfall show?
So not only boycotting Euro2012 in Ukraine, but first of all BOYCOTT & SANCTIONS against anti-constitutional, criminal regime of Ukraine!
Matches chedulled for Ukraine should be moved to Poland and Germany.
Should not the rest of Europe (and the civilized component of the 'internatiosal community') also boycott the London Olympics unless the British agree to reverse the horror continuing to be inflicted on the Chagos Islanders - who are still waiting to go back home? Or is the need of the US for its Diego Garcia base greater than the rights of the Chaggosians infamously evicted by Britain? What do you think, Mr Denis Macshane?
As a country, we do business with every corrupt dictatorship on the planet, until they have nothing we want, or we decide to take what we want by force and depose them. We happily trade with any country regardless of their stance on human rights, as long as they are powerful. We were instrumental in setting up a signifnicant number of these despotic regimes, and then supporting them. Our own record on human rights only looks ok because of what we compare it to. There is no morality in politics apart from what you can get away with. History is a catologue of abuse of people by governments - either "for the national good" , or because of predjudice, or to protect vested interests.
And now you want the UK to boycott Euro 2012 because of political repression?
Wow - I can only salute your stance against this great injustice, and will sleep better knowing the conscience and morality of our nation is so well protected by people like you.
However, as an MP, and a former Minister, you are part of the problem. Pretending to be part of the solution is disingenuous and typical of the contempt
you display towards everyone not in your corrupt little club.
In what respect is this a 'horror problem' for Roy?
Roy won't waste two seconds on it. He's a football manager, not a statesman.
So MacShane supports someone who has been found guilty of corruption. No surprise there.
If he is so concerned about the welfare of prisoners then perhaps he should be complaining about what happens at the ICTY.
Corruptions big inthe Ukraine. If you want something done or if the police stop you there's only one thing to do, and that's hand over some money.
But I can't help look at what's been happening here with News Int, and their dealings with the political establishment and police in the UK.
Another reminder that we have to fight for what's right!
One point to remember - Yanukovich was not the President at the time Euro 2012 was awarded to Poland-Ukraine. What he has done since the beginning of his presidency has demanded this reaction for a long time. Funny how it's only now everyone is waking up to this.
Secondly, please read this press release from the Association of Ukrainians in Great Britain on this topic: http://www.augb.co.uk/news-page.php?id=839
At least a boycott will save Ingerland their blushes !
That comment was muurder the noo, DCI Taggart.
This Taggart be Inglish... to his truncheon !
It's nothing to do with David Cameron, He is the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, not England, we haven't got a Prime Minister to organise a boycott. Being that we are the only country of the UK to qualify yet again it should be a purely English decision. I vote we go to cheer on Roy and the lads!!!!!!!!!