Why our parliament is literally beyond satire
Comedy shows are banned from using Commons footage.
By Helen Lewis Published 27 July 2011 13:25
Just last week, I was writing about the relative health of satire in the US and UK and now comes a rather striking example of something the Americans can do and we can't.
It's already a source of chagrin to many lovers of The Daily Show with Jon Stewart that More4 shows only a weekly round-up edition, rather than the four nightly episodes that are produced by the team. But this week, even the "Global Edition" didn't make it on to British TV screens -- and the 4OD webpage lists the online version as being "unavailable".
Blogger Chris Spyrou noticed it and brought it to the attention of the TV writer Graham Linehan, who asked Channel 4 about it. A tweet from Channel 4 Insider -- the broadcaster's official presence on Twitter -- called it "compliance problems".
The full reason, tweeted a short while later, was this: "We are prevented by parliamentary rules from broadcasting parliamentary proceedings in a comedic or satrical context."
The user @fiatpanda later uncovered this response to a Freedom of Information request from Channel 4, which stated:
Guidelines on the use of the pictures are less prescriptive. They do specify that no extracts from parliamentary proceedings may be used in comedy shows or other light entertainment, such as political satire. But broadcasters are allowed to include parliamentary items in magazine programmes containing musical or humourous features, provided the reports are kept separate.
So there you have it. The Americans can make fun of what happens in our parliament but we can't. And, in case you're wondering, I've seen what I assume is the "banned" clip and it's gentle ribbing at most -- and has something important to say about democracy and the accountability of elected officials.
In it, Jon Stewart expresses his admiration for David Cameron "taking on all comers" during the Commons questions on the hacking scandal, in contrast to the rather anaemic questions that American leaders face.
After showing Ed Miliband, Ann Clwyd, Tom Watson and others giving Cameron some tough words, Jon Stewart remarks: "That's awesome! That's your CSPAN? That's f***ing awesome . . . I know how I'd respond to that kind of questioning [he cowers]. I bet the Prime Minister never had a chance!"
The tape then cuts back to the Commons, where Cameron tells the House his opponents were clearly "hoping for some great allegation to add to their fevered conspiracy theories. I'm just disappointed for them that they didn't get one".
After a couple more clips of a bullish PM, Jon Stewart notes: "England is awesome. That guy killed it. Remember when someone yelled "You lie!" at our State of the Union and everyone was like 'What has become of us as a people?' This is the Prime Minister of England, down in the pit, taking on all comers . . . This guy cut short a foreign trip for the privilege of it."
What US politics needs, Stewart concludes, is for Americans to "start drinking some motherf***ing tea and eating some motherf***ing finger sandwiches".
To follow Helen on Twitter, click here.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















22 comments
anim3snipe
sadt3ars
animeonlye
nsf7
3solat
mnoms
magicians4all
animexyt
mexyt
delegnet
anim3snipe
sadt3ars
animeonlye
nsf7
3sola
mnoms
magicians4all
animexyt
mexyt
delegnet
@Ed Paton-Williams
Definitely don't look at my Twitter feed (@helenlewis) or that of @DavidAllenGreen.
Can anyone find a link to a video of this? I'm trying and so far failing. I think it might take a proxy in America to watch it on the Daily Show's website.
John Bercow is quite capable of sending himself up, without any help from satitists, thank you.
And Dave survived a grilling for 3 hours on the hacking scandal and took 100 questions from all comers. Quite a feat for any PM.
Thanks Helen. An 'I am Spartacus' style campaign is needed here I think. We'd rightly condemn other states for censoring the showing of tv programmes if they satirised or criticised that country's parliament. Absolutely ridiculous.
So the old story is true - they can't take ridicule.
When you can't take criticism, ban it.
As someone who commutes between the US and the UK I'm good and sick of losing half the TV shows I like to watch in both places. A BBC license fee paid should grant global access - it would massively swell the UK coffers - and as it why Jon Stewart isn't on UK TV it's a complete mystery as it's arguably America's best TV show, period.
"We are prevented by parliamentary rules from broadcasting parliamentary proceedings in a comedic or satirical context." It's tempting to say they don't want the competition because they do it so well themselves. But of course I don't really mean that.
As an American, I find it incredibly ironic that the nation which produced George Orwell allows this to happen. Are the British people really so complacent?
Yes, we British are ridiculously thin-skinned. It's genetic - that's why we needed you chaps to get us through WWII.
We know this though, don't we? Remember the whole 'Cake' scandal that the brilliant Chris Morris used in Brass Eye? This is no better than dubbing the IRA or the pervasive restrictions of photography in local council meetings. It is completely unacceptable.
Good article - thanks for the coverage. I wrote something here http://bit.ly/nBnv9v which tells you who is in charge of defining the broadcasting rules and how to tell them what you think.
Things haven't changed much from the days of Gilbert and Sullivan. Ken Clarke is still the dozy flushed bucholic Lord Chancellor, Danny Alexander is still the eminence grise that brought about the Coalition singlehanded and the PM is still the toff with the tintin quiff and not from the lower middle classes.
This is just an anachronism, like the ban on footage from the house that lasted into the 80s. I doubt it would take much pressure to get it lifted. But it's a good opportunity to disillusion people and encourage apathy, making a right-wing agenda easier to enact, isn't it?
This kind of parodying is as old as old comedy. Dumbass UK politicians.
." The Americans can make fun of what happens in our Parliament, but we can't."
Quite normal.
Who could compete with the comedians of Westminster-champions in clownery.?
I found it pretty funny how Britain's Daily Show blackout has reduced the author of this article to literally describe the proceedings of the episode. Like book readings that make you wonder if the audience is unable to read for themselves.
Btw, the Daily Show streams legally in Singapore. Why is it blocked there?
@fiatpanda
Thanks for the link!
@MAKootage
Thank you, I live to be useful...
I am a big fan of Jon Stewart and I was lucky enough to see the episode in question (I wont say how) I cant believe they didn't show it on More4.
As Helen says it was more of a gentle ribbing than a dig at us, this is entirely Jon's style and why he appeals to so many.
One has to wonder why, if we cant make fun of the nonsense in the commons, that MP's are allowed to appear on shows like Have I Got News For You.
At a time when our politicians are largely regarded as jokes we should perhaps reconsider the law which stops us mocking them?