Six reasons why Cameron is wrong on the economy
It is increasingly clear that the PM is out of his depth and out of touch. This is "nothing for noth
By David Blanchflower Published 22 November 2011 12:05
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists





















123 comments
1%.. Your Labour Party's housing record is appalling.. Under Labour we had nine Housing Ministers in 13 year's. Housebuilding also plummeted to its lowest level since the 1920s First-time buyer numbers collapsed to their lowest level since the 1970s.. The number of affordable homes available fell by 200,000.. Local authority waiting lists nearly doubled. Ed Miliband admitted social housing wasn't he said 'important to Labour' "We refused to prioritise the building of new social housing" and if you don't believe me 1% here a direst quote from your Ed Ball's...Ed Balls says Labour got it wrong on housing: "Labour’s plans were too cautious…[we] got it wrong... We were late in recognising the importance of building more homes and more affordable homes." Your Caroline Flint also conceded Labour failed on affordable housing: "I accept that we didn’t [build enough affordable homes]."
I look forward to your spluttering reply.. I'm off down the club...
·
·
·
I've just read Danny Dorling's books 'So you think you know about Britain' and 'Injustice'. If there was ever an agenda to aim the next national and local policy discussion at, here it is but there's no evidence that the Coalition, or local/national Labour understands about inequality and the aggressive and destructive consequences of the current government. They are getting away with murder (NHS, Education, and as DB has shown, Finance, to name but three) and I see no effective response from the official opposition, nor indeed from any of the genuine Lib Dems.
Inbrew, your vidiprinter has malfunctioned.
Matthew Fox 1 (Bozo555 og) Bozo555 0
That is the correct scoreline.
Another bad day for the right, the economic growth that Osborne and his apologists where bragging about, was fuelled by government spending.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-15870030
Unfortunately Labour are finished as a real alternative. They sold us down the river once too often. A new progressive force has to come from an alternative route.
Luddite, the Tories sold off 200,000 council houses.
Instead of going on a bender, why don't you do some research Luddite.
Only six? Britain fought two world wars to keep the Germans in their place and yet it's plucky little Britain on the outside looking in.
The British electorate had its chance. They've never had it so bad and yet they expect Gordon Brown to come back and save them. Cheap money for the bankers - cuts for the rest of us.
They fell for al those 'promises' and now they can hardly believe the state we're in.
Suckers
Matthew: I don't need to do research because 1%... I live in the real world... I know that the Tories did, it's what Labour didn't do that interests me... By the way 1%... my parent's bought one of them 'council houses' it was the best investment my father ever made.. So 1%.. what is your opinion on the landslide victory in Spain of the conservative-right.. I look forward to your spluttering reply.. I'm back from the club... matthew fox, it's a working men's club, i know you wouldn't understand, it's where working people go to chill-out.. and net-work and make money...
I think we all need to realise, here is that the fundamentals of globalism is ruined. I dont know why you people dont realise that resources are running out, to such an extent that I dont think that recession levels will stay
The 'something for nothing economics' remark made by Cameron goes along with the trend of the bankers and rich elite of rewriting history of the financial crisis, and reassingning blame away from the sub prime mortgage affair and onto 'governments spending too much money to win popularity' as a Goldman Sachs banker said recently.
According to this idea, the global economic system was imperilled by too much spending on schools, hospitals, police and welfare and had nothing to do with deregulation, or money making schemes thought up in Goldman Sachs and Lehman Brothers.
Luddite, what is your opinion on the collaspe of the Centre-Right Government in Italy?
Silivio was a card carrying Thatcherite, no wonder he had to go.
It didn't take long for you to get thrown out of the club did it Luddite, I take it you swore at the other members and staff?
Of course your disinterested, it undermines your argument.
What is a Net-work? Poor Luddite, can't even spell network, which is strange, considering all the swear words he uses.
I'm a Tory and think Prime Minister David Cameron give a fantastic speech and our leader will lead us out of trouble.
David,
There was one comment in Cameron's speech I wonder if you could answer please?
I heard a claim that this recession was unique and exempt from Keynes theories of spending to recover because it was a debt-induced recession. Are the sovereign debts much worse this time than in previous recessions? If they are would that be an argument against Keynes?
Chris Garman
matthew fox: Look here 1% there's a couple of differences between me and thee.. I care about working people, but don't pity them, and the other difference is i don't sleep with sheep...
rob andersen: "are there ANY MEN in the left anymore"
You've got Matthew, but he's turning his attentions to ducks.. that must be illegal... but what the hell... you can't be judgmental..
Why did it take so long..
Silvio?.. is a political gangster
It's a working men's club, we don't have staff we have members...
Net-working is what working people do.. check your own spellings.
1% Thy hasn't a glue lad...typical lefty all spout and no fucking bottle..
Indu, how do you know which is investment and which is expense? At the end of the end of the day if the investment does not yield returns they are expense and adds to real deficit.
At one end, keeping people doing something productive as against idling away is a good goal, the problem is that too many government agencies provide non-productive idling away.
As a national program we have very little easy investment opportunity which is also productive.
The problem with UK is that both in left and right, the masses have occupied themselves into unproductive services whereas when you compare it with Germany, they have real economy backed up by solid engineering skills.
Compare that with UK where for example we have Banking services in which is basically fake skill. What would be investment look like in Banking? On other hand we have Public Sector and associated services which again not transferable to tangible assets.
Also all these Nuclear Plants etc are huge risks as demonstrated by Japan and politically not feasible.
The main problem is that Britain has lost its competitive advantage and unless we rebuild it, I see very little way by which we will get the prosperity of 20th Century back until rest of the world catches up
One of the main reasons that Italy is now in trouble it is in my Jehovah witnessing friend is because it has no growth to help pay off its huge debt. It faces austerity, no growth, and thus, no future.
The current round of QE scheduled to last till june 2012 I think.
You want QE squared? There's a balence between printing money and there being external buyers of the debt, or are you saying just run the printing presses hot? because u then risk a currency crisis... and inflation is over 5% after all(fact).
That's the thing with economics mr Blanchflower, when you come to the real world, away from a textbook, there are other factors and variables to consider.
SO FAR:
UK has grown manufacturing (fact) , created half a million private sector jobs (fact), Interest rates are super low (fact) so we're not wasting money on debt interest(fact) and this can be redirected towards the economy (housebuilding programme, and what surprises lay ahead on the 29th??). These are all facts. We currently have a QE target of 275 Billion (yes billion )pounds sir (fact)... why not run that round of QE and see how the global sytem can cope with that? Just an idea.
I know it's difficult for 'economists' who read about theories all day in textbooks to understand that time is as important an ingredient in economics as it is in cooking, but jeapordising what we've got for your cry of 'print more, print more, print more' which is what you're saying, well do u think it's that easy to run economies- just print money to create wealth?? Surely you have an instinct somewhere that tells u that printing money in itself isn't an absolute answer? Do you consider that the global debt crisis is detracting peoples attention so much that the problems we're storing for ourselves by printing is glossed over since there are much more immediate fires to put out?
The problem, the real problem mr blanchflower is that you hail from a generation of academics who are seeing the rules of economics re-written before their very eyes. the world is also on the cusp of a supercycle in which asia now is to be included in the equations- a restructuring in the global order of things which impacts on traditional economic models e.g. the BOE has only recently raelised that raising rates dosen't necessarily lower inflation anymore since the asians will buy the commodities ALMOST irrespective- it remains to be seen whether they have a chieved a critical mass within themselves, i don't think they can avoid our slow down unless germans allow printing. You see french bonds today mr Blanchflower?? ain't so bad here as in a LOT of other places.
Low rates please, manufactiring growth yes thanks, realtively stabler markets, yes thx, property market that's bumping along fine thx very much- If u really wanted to create havock for Tories u would be better off pointing out the enormity of the debt Uk has, it's almost as though the markets have forgotten that one.
Why isn't the tax system being reformed? the codes are insanely complex- seriously nutty.
Some employment laws are a joke, employees agree to that in some cases.
Health and safety needs to be slashed- and I don't mean make the workplace dangerous, just the nonsense laws that resulted from corporations lobbying there MP's...
Local govt needs akick up the arse- 40% of rent again is paid as business rates is ludicrous- utter nonsense from councils.
@matt
Foxy, does typing make your pads sore? Like after you have played sonic for while chasing the hedgehog.
No typo my friend,
Foxy 0.00000 Mike at least 1
I've listened to both your responses. Your fall away in a light breeze - yours are substanceless like mist.
Even Tony Blair thinks Labour did not do enough to control rampant house prices. You would have to be 0.1% to think interest rates was not a strongly correlated factor with private house asset prices.
Seriously foxy, do you really think low interest rates does not tend to push up prices relative to higher rates? Exactly. You.ve been flogging a dead horse.
Lets keep score (Foxy's a loser)
- Dagenham Fiesta
- House prices
- Legarde and pensions
Daniel
Ah I see finally what you're trying to say... it's not the debt that's the problem it's the growth... yes yes i gettit now- if they grow they can pay off the debt- right, with u now, got it.
I thought they had structural issues , luckily i caught your chat.
One thing though- if we weren't all so needy of this growth to pay off the debt, I wonder what alternative we would currently be living?
matthew fox
I'm off to work 1%.. Just looking at a ******* Solicitors STAMP DUTY AUTHERORITY PURCHASE TRANSACTION form. It appears my wife wants me to sign it.. 'Stamp-Duty' more f**king tax.. bloody hell 1% cages are so expensive these days... Enjoy your pointless day and try keeping off the meths you know what it does to your complexion..