Cultural Capital

Reflections on books and the arts from the New Statesman culture desk

Syndicate contentRSS

Haiti: some context

Slavoj Žižek on people power.

Haiti, the poorest nation in the western hemisphere, is one of those countries that only makes the news when it is struck by disaster. But despite the images of desperation that are now zooming around the globe -- not to mention the periodic stories of abject poverty that filter out of the country -- its people are not passive victims.

This is a good moment -- after you have donated to the relief effort -- to reread Slavoj Žižek's review of Peter Hallward's Damming the Flood: Haiti, Aristide and the Politics of Containment, which we first published in 2008. Žižek traces Haiti's predicament, from the French Revolution to the downfall of Jean-Bertrand Aristide in 2004. These two passages are salient:

The Lavalas movement has won every free presidential election since 1990, but it has twice been the victim of US-sponsored military coups.

and

Haiti was an exception from the very beginning, from its revolutionary fight against slavery, which ended in independence in January 1804. "Only in Haiti," Hallward notes, "was the declaration of human freedom universally consistent. Only in Haiti was this declaration sustained at all costs, in direct opposition to the social order and economic logic of the day" . . . Denounced by Talleyrand as "a horrible spectacle for all white nations", the "mere existence of an independent Haiti" was itself an intolerable threat to the slave-owning status quo. Haiti thus had to be made an exemplary case of economic failure, to dissuade other countries from taking the same path.

Read the full review here.

3 comments

Brian's picture

Okay... so fast forward 200 years... why have we 1st of all continued to punish Haiti? And Now, why all of a sudden such out pourings of help greater than those for our very own hurricane Katrina victims. what's in bag of tricks for Haiti???

Mimi Sheller's picture

Also crucial is the fact that in 2004, on the 200th anniversary of Haiti's independence, President Aristide called upon the French government to repay the 150 million francs that were extracted from Haiti between 1825 and 1922 as compensation to French plantation and slave "owners" who lost their "property" during the revolution. Economists calculated the present day value as 21 billion US dollars. This was the first time that a European government received a formal request in respect of reparations for slavery. One month later, Haiti was invaded by a French-led military force with US support, which deposed President Aristide, effectively kidnapped him and forcibly removed him from the country. An interim president was put in place, President Latortue, one of whose first acts was to withdraw the request for reparations, relieving the French Assembly of any legal requirement to discuss the matter. These are some of the reasons that Haiti is so poor today, and immediate payment of these reparations (that are arguably owed to Haiti under the UN Charter Article 45 on Crimes against Humanity) would be the first step towards rebuilding the country. Allowing Aristide to return to Haiti and his party Lavalas to participate in the elections would be the next step.

no name's picture

y continue to punish --> to make Haiti desperate and agree unconditionally to US and Other foreign powers Demands Thus more dking of its Land and its People. one possibility is that there is a need to buid plant that are Not
environmentally friendly and can not be built in the US, but Haiti is only about 90 miles away - fairly close. Also it is the 3rd largest landmass in the Caribbean, so there is a lot of space to build all sorts of manufacturing without having to follow US codes (remember H are poor and "dum"). So if it's controlled by the US, they will be able to do whatever they feel like, as they did in Cuba pre-rev. Anyone with a Conscience should Protest!!

Read this article: http://www.a-w-i-p.com/index.php/2010/01/18/why-the-us-owes-haiti-billio...

Latest tweets