Nintendo warfare
Jemima Khan visits Islamabad to hear about the terrible civilian death toll of US drone strikes.
By Jemima Khan Published 23 November 2011
Two weeks ago, in Pakistan, I met a boy called Tariq who, at 16, is a year older than my son. He was a fanatical footballer, like my boy, though more politicised, like everyone in Pakistan from rickshaw wallahs to university lecturers. Political apathy is the preserve of countries that are not on the brink.
Tariq and I were both in Islamabad for the same reason: to attend a conference, organised by Clive Stafford Smith of the legal aid charity Reprieve, on the covert use of drones by the CIA in Pakistan's tribal area. Three days later Tariq was dead.
He died alongside his 12-year-old cousin, Waheed, both victims of one of the drones he was protesting about. Stafford Smith believes that a tracking device was put on his car by a CIA informant at the conference in Islamabad. There are 800,000 people living in the north-western region of Waziristan: the odds of hitting one of the 80 delegates, Stafford-Smith points out, was therefore one in 10,000.
Barack Obama has argued that the use of drone technology is the best way of targeting militants while minimising civilian casualties. Under his administration, the use of drones has increased tenfold - it is easier to eliminate terrorist suspects than to detain them. Yet an official US statement claimed there have been no "non-combatant deaths" as a result.
The delegates, tribal elders, the families of victims of drone strikes and Tariq had come from Waziristan to dispute that. They descended on Islamabad - a riot of beige, with biblical beards - armed with gruesome photographs of women and children blown to pieces among debris and missile parts stamped with serial numbers and the US flag.
At the conference, Samiullah Jan, 17, just out of college, was represented only by his ID card, retrieved from the rubble of his home. Another teenager, a 16-year-old boy called Saadullah, hobbled in on prosthetic limbs: he had lost his legs and his sight two years earlier. "I used to dream of being a doctor" he told us. "Now I can't even go to school. I'm not even human."
The US's drone war remains a classified CIA program. There is no reliable information. One reason for the jirga [meeting] was to appeal to people from the tribal area, which is closed to journalists, to collect evidence from drone strikes. We distributed digital cameras so that in the future they can document strikes.
This new "Nintendo warfare" is having a devastating effect on nuclear-armed Pakistan. A recent Pew poll found that 97 per cent of Pakistanis viewed drones negatively and 69 per cent view the US as their greatest enemy, which makes Obama's joke at the White House Correspondents' Ball all the more thoughtless. His message to boys with designs on his daughters: "I have two words for you . . . Predator drones. You will never see it coming."
Another problem was highlighted at the jirga by a tribal elder, Mir Jan, who said: "We don't know who to trust any more". Pakistan has always pulsated with conspiracy theories but these days there are good reasons for paranoia. WikiLeaks exposed the fact that the Pakistan government has lied about giving permission to the US to strike Waziristan. Blackwater mercenaries operate all over Pakistan; while a Save the Children doctor, offering the polio vaccine in Osama Bin Laden's hideout, Abbottabad, turned out to be a CIA informant. Then there was Raymond Davis, the "diplomat" who shot two Pakistanis and whose colleague then ran over a third, who was later revealed to be a CIA agent. It is increasingly unsafe for aid workers, diplomats and journalists to work in Pakistan.
Special relationship
On the subject of conspiracy theories, it was unfortunate that my trip to Pakistan coincided with a political rally in Lahore held by my ex-husband, Imran Khan. Local politicians, threatened by his recent surge in popularity, made incendiary public statements about my visit. These included "it is un-Islamic to have a good relationship with your ex" and "it was part of a Zionist conspiracy"(I thought we'd knocked that one on the head a decade ago - there can't be many who receive both virulent anti-Semitic and Islamophobic abuse on Twitter).
The debate about my presence threatened to overshadow the far more important discussions about drones and even elicited a Facebook page: "We Pakistanis apologise to Jemima Khan for mudslugging [sic] by politicians."
It made no difference. Imran's rally was a game-changer: more than 100,000 people showed up on the streets of Lahore to show their support and, after 15 years of being ridiculed by Pakistan's political and social elites, Imran is now a real contender.
There are costs, though. In the old days, Imran had one old, grizzled chowkidar guarding the gate of his house. "I trust Allah to protect me," he would say to his more cautious friends. I note that these days he has reluctantly agreed to travel at all times with ten armed guards. There's a saying of the Prophet's, which is an old favourite of mine: "Have faith in Allah - but tether your camel."
Jemima Khan is associate editor of the NS
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists


51 comments
"The drone is a wonderful weapon against islamofascists and should be used more often and ought to be awarded the Nobel Prize for Peace."
would you limit the use of drones, exclusively for killing Islamofascists? or, can you think of a few more groups that deserve the exact same treatment?
go on, who else is on your list?
Nintendo games have a common message of accepting 'beings' from different cultures. Look at the legend of zelda ocarina of time,majoras mask or even the latest incarnation for the wii " skyward sword".
The hero, link, must travel his world to defeat the evil lord by harnesing his inner spiritual development only by travelling to different cultural worlds and gathering knowledge of himself and his world by meeting these beings.
Nintendo warfare is a very misleading title for your article ms khan, should have been called ' modern warfare: 1, 2,3 and 4 etc
Jackass the Islamist fanatic obviously has great fears about being taken out by a drone.
But no-one can deny that there would be no drones if there were no Taliban.
Ergo ... if the people of Pakistan were to remove the Taliban from their midst there would be no drone attacks anywhere in Pakistan.
Or is it a case of the Taliban have rights but the West has no right to defend itself?
@Frederick
"Jackass"
congratulations! you are the 10th poster this week who uses that 'hilarious' spelling of my username. and our prize.....? your very own new username;
Fredprick.
no need to thank me Fredprick. really no need.
so what of your contribution Fredprick? you write;
"the Islamist fanatic obviously has great fears about being taken out by a drone."
wow, how dumb are you? unless you think drones should be used to take out western secularists who view all religion with equal disdain?
how weird you are Fredprick. the clue is in my real username btw, but likely you're too thick to figure out from that what nationality i am.
go on, prove me wrong Fredprick, where am i from?
No drones if no talibans? Do you forget where all this bullshit originated?
Rights? Did you not think of rights when raymond davis was sent back home after what he did and afia siddiqui was left to die in the american jail house.
Are you kidding me, are you people for real?
I pray to God obama and whoever else doesnt have a mind big enough to see what the american government has done to the world, watches their loved ones die like tariq and millions of other men women and children. Unless you ignorant people sitting in your lounges writing these comments experience these things you cannot understand it.
Because ms.khan has seen it she knows. Why should she not start with and speak about Pakistan? She lived there, her childrens' father belongs to that country.
Dont talk about such complexed things when your common sense is not in place.
Ms khan will be loved in pakistan more for being a humanitarian than for being imran khans wife, as was your princess of wales, diana.
Humanity. It comes before east and west and taliban.
Jackass you are an Islamist asshole either based in some cave in Pakistan or an Islamist ghetto in Tower Hamlets. It doesn't really matter.
Well said Jemima. You have raised an important message about an issue that Pakistan's often-hypocritical, liberal elite is by and large silent about. Good to see that you are still engaged with the country, and embarrassed by the narrow mindedness of your detractors in Pakistan. They just dont know any better. Imran Khan is Pakistan's best hope and the thoughts and prayers of sincere Pakistanis are with him, all the way.
You are absolutely correct...and we pakistanis thank you for your efforts...u r doing what most of us should do against drone attacks.......Once again thanks for your efforts.
@Ian
"No you called me a turd"
because.......? do try and keep up dear. no? it's not difficult. i called you a turd only because you referred to the author using the phrase 'spoilt rich bitch'.
that makes you a turd. and rather than withdrawing the comment, you try and wriggle out using mealy mouthed semantics.
that makes you a slippery turd. fact.
"Where is this mighty Muslim voice against terror in any form?"
as ever you demand something bizarre. you appear to demand that at a rally specifically about US drone attacks, one of the main talking points should be to renounce all violence of all types if it involves any Muslim. can't you see how stupid a demand that is?
fact; Muslims leaders have condemned violence in the past. 9/11 was condemned by many Muslims. fact.
"Yep I remember Gaza post 9/11 , and if drones are brutal and indiscriminate, heck what would you call 747's?"
Gaza is not the centre of the Muslim world, and they do not speak for all Muslims. only a turd would think that mentioning Gaza's reaction to 9/11 proved anything about Muslims in general.
here are the facts about 9/11 and Muslim leaders. stop being such a turd and read it. it is a poll carried out by Gallup, you have heard of them, no?
http://www.pensitoreview.com/2008/02/27/poll-majority-muslims-worldwide-...
and Muslim scholars, Councils and other groups also condemned 9/11 as against their religion.
http://islam.about.com/cs/currentevents/a/9_11statements.htm
you can read can't you?