Support 100 years of independent journalism.

  1. Culture
16 October 2017updated 05 Aug 2021 7:27am

Daniel Mendelsohn’s memoir describes a son’s mission to understand his father

An Odyssey shows that if any subject can dissolve their differences, it is Classics.

By Daisy Dunn

When his elderly father comes to stay, Daniel Mendelsohn buys instant coffee. The 81-year-old has made his feelings about the Nespresso machine abundantly clear. Jay Mendelsohn, a mathematician, is the kind of man who wears cologne with “a smell as synthetic as that of dry-cleaning fluid” and fails to notice when people scorn his table manners. To his classicist son’s perpetual embarrassment, he pronounces Ovid as “Ohvid” and, worst of all, thinks that Homer’s Odysseus is a wimp.

There’s a moment early on in the Odyssey when Athena says, “Few men resemble their fathers. Few sons are better, most are worse…” The elderly Nestor says something similar in the Iliad when he describes how much mightier men were in previous generations. This Homeric idea lies at the heart of Daniel Mendelsohn’s memoir of his father’s final months. Only, neither Mendelsohn can quite agree that it’s true.

The book begins with the elderly Jay enrolling on the Odyssey course that his son teaches at an American liberal arts college. Surrounded by students a quarter of his age, he quickly acquires a reputation for his contrarian views. Odysseus, a mighty hero? He loses his men, cheats on his wife and spends years weeping on the shores of Calypso’s island. “I was in the army,” says Jay, “and I knew some guys who were real heroes. And I can tell you, nobody cried.”

Naturally, Daniel feels that he’s fighting a losing battle. Teaching his father initially seems to teach him only how little they have in common. Jay is a scientist through and through. He can tell strangers that his wife is beautiful, but never his wife, who sums him up simply as “undemonstrative”. Daniel is open, artistic and gay, with two sons and a female “parenting partner”.

If any subject can dissolve their differences, it is Classics. As Mendelsohn recalls, Friedrich August Wolf, the late-18th-century German philologist who proposed that the Homeric epics were composed orally and only later written down, made a strong case for classifying the interpretation of Greek and Latin texts as a science. Mendelsohn’s lecture room becomes the place where science and the humanities engage in battle.

Sign up for The New Statesman’s newsletters Tick the boxes of the newsletters you would like to receive. Quick and essential guide to domestic and global politics from the New Statesman's politics team. The New Statesman’s global affairs newsletter, every Monday and Friday. The best of the New Statesman, delivered to your inbox every weekday morning. A handy, three-minute glance at the week ahead in companies, markets, regulation and investment, landing in your inbox every Monday morning. Our weekly culture newsletter – from books and art to pop culture and memes – sent every Friday. A weekly round-up of some of the best articles featured in the most recent issue of the New Statesman, sent each Saturday. A weekly dig into the New Statesman’s archive of over 100 years of stellar and influential journalism, sent each Wednesday. Sign up to receive information regarding NS events, subscription offers & product updates.
I consent to New Statesman Media Group collecting my details provided via this form in accordance with the Privacy Policy

From this Iliad-like setting, the narrative proceeds to its sequel when the two Mendelsohns embark on a “Retracing the Odyssey” cruise. In one of his enjoyable etymological digressions, Mendelsohn reminds us that the word “travel” is a cousin of “travail” (“painful or laborious effort”), which derives from the medieval Latin word trepalium, meaning “instrument of torture”. Odysseus’s journey is torturous indeed, his name bearing echoes of odune, the ancient Greek for “pain”.

The Mendelsohns’ journey falls short of an odyssey in this sense. But everyone who embarks on an Odyssean quest must fail in his own way. In The Mighty Dead: Why Homer Matters (2014), Adam Nicolson interwove literary criticism with a gripping account of his own odyssey. Harry Mount’s Odyssey (2015) used an exploration of Odysseus’s islands as an opportunity to laugh at himself as he failed to match the hero’s feats. For the Mendelsohns, failure comes in having to turn back before reaching Ithaca when the Corinth Canal is closed. The author doesn’t fail to achieve Odysseus’s heroism so much as regress by framing himself as Telemachus, the hero’s son.

The book that results from this journey describes a son’s questioning, sentimental, often touching mission to understand his father. At times, Mendelsohn overestimates the interest of his parents’ words. A “funny exchange” that he relates to his class runs as follows: “So the other day I asked my mom, how does it feel to be so old? And she said, ‘It’s so strange. Every morning I look in the mirror and think, who is this old woman staring at me? Inside, I’m still 16!

Content from our partners
Why modelling matters: its role in future healthcare challenges
Helping children be safer, smarter, happier internet explorers
Power to the people

The appeal of the book lies in the lacunae between Mendelsohn’s understanding of his father and ours. The “complicated shame” he feels about Jay is often hopelessly misplaced. Far from being “put off” by his father’s “gruff attitude towards the text and confused by his evident disdain for my teaching of it”, Mendelsohn’s students see past the things that irritate him, not least the old man’s appearance (a “bald and withered old man hunched in the corner”, scruffy in a “baggy white sweater”).

Mendelsohn, Jr, emerges as the exception to Athena’s rule that sons are inferior to their fathers. In a thoroughly Odyssean conceit, he questions what it takes to recognise the qualities of one’s kin. Can a son see himself in a father who dresses like a beggar? Can he recognise a father he has never met? Can a son ever know his father at all? It is to Mendelsohn’s credit that he poses these questions before it is too late.

Daisy Dunn is the author of “Catullus’ Bedspread” and “The Poems of Catullus: A New Translation” (William Collins)

An Odyssey: A Father, a Son and an Epic
Daniel Mendelsohn
William Collins, 304pp, £18.99

This article appears in the 11 Oct 2017 issue of the New Statesman, How May crumbled