Support 100 years of independent journalism.

  1. Culture
15 July 2015updated 14 Sep 2021 3:10pm

Farce, philosophy and fantasy: body-swap films have the perfect cinematic formula

Body-swap storylines are the perfect premise for filmic fun, so why is the most recent offering in the genre, Self/Less, so disappointing?

By Ryan Gilbey

Body-swap stories have always been reliable currency in cinema. No wonder – one of the things for which the medium is best equipped is placing us effortlessly in other people’s shoes and behind other pairs of eyes.

It isn’t much of a leap from there to speculate on what it might feel like to inhabit an entirely different skin.

The new thriller Self/Less stars Ben Kingsley as a dying industrialist who pays $250m to undergo a procedure called “shedding.” What this means in practice is that his body, and a body into which his consciousness is about to be decanted, are each placed inside neighbouring machines that resemble giant illuminated tumble dryers.

When Damian wakes up and looks in the mirror, he sees a new, younger man named Edward (Ryan Reynolds), though inside he is still his old self. Asked if he’s happy with his replacement form, he says: “It has that new body smell.”

That car metaphor turns up again when he finds that unfamiliar memories are impinging on his thoughts. “You thought you were buying a new car,” says his doctor. “Turns out it has a few miles on the clock.”

Sign up for The New Statesman’s newsletters Tick the boxes of the newsletters you would like to receive. Quick and essential guide to domestic and global politics from the New Statesman's politics team. A weekly newsletter helping you fit together the pieces of the global economic slowdown. The New Statesman’s global affairs newsletter, every Monday and Friday. The best of the New Statesman, delivered to your inbox every weekday morning. The New Statesman’s weekly environment email on the politics, business and culture of the climate and nature crises - in your inbox every Thursday. Our weekly culture newsletter – from books and art to pop culture and memes – sent every Friday. A weekly round-up of some of the best articles featured in the most recent issue of the New Statesman, sent each Saturday. A newsletter showcasing the finest writing from the ideas section and the NS archive, covering political ideas, philosophy, criticism and intellectual history - sent every Wednesday. Sign up to receive information regarding NS events, subscription offers & product updates.

That’s putting it mildly. Damian is in danger of being overwhelmed from the inside by Edward, who once had his own life, memories and family.

Content from our partners
How to create a responsible form of “buy now, pay later”
“Unions are helping improve conditions for drivers like me”
Transport is the core of levelling up

It’s a premise that owes much to the body-swap sub-genre, and in particular the disquieting 1967 thriller Seconds, starring Rock Hudson. But it’s easily one of the weakest renderings of a format that has shown itself in the past to be all but foolproof.

The director Tarsem Singh usually throws everything – including, but not limited to, the kitchen sink – at his movies. His best film, The Fall, and his battiest one, The Cell, drench the eye in beauty and colour without forsaking human intimacy.

Why, then, is Self/Less such a plain Jane? Perhaps Singh feels he has touched on this subject before and is therefore trying to distinguish new work from old.

Both The Cell and The Fall have their own points of overlap with Self/Less. In The Cell, a psychologist (Jennifer Lopez) enters the mind of a serial killer (Vincent D’Onofrio) – and takes us with her.

And in The Fall, a hospitalised stunt-man (Lee Pace) improvises a fantasy story for a little girl in exchange for morphine from the medicine cabinet: large chunks of that movie, too, take place inside the main character’s head.

In stripping down Self/Less to its bare bones, making everything from production design to performances frill-free, there’s no danger of trespassing on the past, whether it’s Singh’s previous work or any of the movies that have employed a similar scenario.

Even that slash in the title recalls the punctuation of the most delirious of all body-swap (or, in this case, physiognomy-swap) pictures: Face/ Off, in which John Travolta and Nicolas Cage undergo a face transplant and then spend the rest of the movie impersonating one another (which turns out to be much more fun for Travolta than it is for Cage).

So successful is Self/Less in distancing itself from its influences that by the time Edward is wandering around a New Orleans junkyard, the sight of plaster body parts from old Mardi Gras float displays piled high behind him doesn’t seem at all like the in-joke it could have been.

It was only at that point that it occurred to me how little history Self/Less owns up to. It does what Damian’s doctors were unable to do: it creates a clean slate, a complete break from the past. What’s missing is a personality of its own. A viewer could be forgiven for feeling envious of Damian, his head buzzing with woozy, action-packed hallucinations.

Also absent from Self/Less is a sense of the giddy fun that might come with surrendering your identity. It’s fair enough that the movie didn’t want to play the Face/ Off game and have Reynolds do a feature-length Ben Kingsley impression (though that idea sounds nigh-on irresistible to me). But that wouldn’t have been the only option.

Comedy is often the first port of call for the body-swap movie: it’s pure farce, being caught in someone else’s wrapping and having to pass yourself off as them. There’s no shortage of comic shenanigans when the mother and daughter exchange lives in Freaky Friday (whether it’s the 1977 one with Jodie Foster and Barbara Harris, or the 2003 remake with Jamie Lee Curtis and Lindsay Lohan).

Steve Martin is at his most dexterous trying not to show that the spirit of Lily Tomlin is writhing around within him throughout the joyous All of Me. Tom Hanks gave a complex and funny performance as a child trapped in a man’s body in Big, while the teen market has been treated in recent years to the likes of 17 Again and 13 Going On 30.

Existential dread would have been another route for Self/Less to take. In David Lynch’s Lost Highway, a murderer simply vanishes from his prison cell, replaced without explanation by a young mechanic. In Kieslowski’s The Double Life of Veronique, two women (both played by Irène Jacob) who have never met experience a kind of amorphous synchronicity of emotion.

But you can have it both ways. My favourite example of this narrative species is the 1993 curiosity Suture, which combines the comic and the philosophical in the tale of two identical brothers (played by Dennis Haysbert and Michael Harris, the former black, the latter white) whose identities become confused after an accident.

You’re not meant to take too seriously any film that features a character named Dr Renee Descartes, or a scene in which a man sustains serious facial burns while Ring of Fire plays on the soundtrack. If I was laughing during Self/Less, it was only the memory of Suture that had me in stitches.

Self/Less is released on Friday.