Registered user login:

Who recognises Kosovo?

Syed Hamad Ali

Published 28 July 2008

Kosovo's declaration of independence happened months ago but many countries have yet to recognise its new status as a nation in its own right

It was back on 17 February 2008 that the global media last shone the spotlight on Kosovo in the wake of its declaration of independence.

Since then there has almost been an eerie silence as the country strives for global recognition. Okay, not silence but it does seem to have gone on the backburner as issues like Afghanistan and China's manic Olympics shot to the fore.

Then last month the Wall Street Journal ran a piece about Kosovo under the title "Europe's unlikely charmer". For the intrepid traveller who makes the journey, the article notes “breathtaking mountains” and the “unspoiled medieval architecture” and makes recommendations about which hotels to stay in.

For Kosovo (or Kosova as it is known in the Albanian language) is a member of an elite, not to say, exclusive club. It's fiercely pro-US yet the vast bulk of its two million population is Muslim.

Such is the Kosovars love affair with Uncle Sam that a visitor to Kosovo will discover that it has what is reportedly the world's second largest replica of the Statue of Liberty, an avenue named after Bill Clinton and even a restaurant called Hillary.

The Kosovars' devotion stems from being rescued from potential genocide back in 1999. But as American holiday-makers rush to pack their bags and head for sunny Pristina [Kosovo’s capital], the rest of the world - or at least the larger part of it - is yet to recognize this new nation. This includes Russia, China, India, Africa, Central Asia and most of Latin America and the Middle East.

According to Betim Deva and Genc Kastrati, representatives for Kosovo Thanks You, a website that religiously keeps track of who has recognised their country: “The number of visitors to our website correlates with political developments. When a recognition occurs, the number of visitors grows. There were days when we received thousands of emails with various information and feedback.”

So far the Kosovars are making slow process. Of the 192 member states of the United Nations only 43 have recognized Kosovo.

And keeping track of recognition is no easy business. At Kosovo Thanks You the management team calls the whole process “Independence 2.0” and employs an extensive support network to help: “The network helps us with prediction of the recognitions based on various diplomatic sources and individuals.” This involves contacting embassies and foreign ministries to verify information.

So the question is, how much longer can recognition take? Dr Rick Fawn is senior lecturer of International Relations at the University of St Andrews with an expertise in Eastern Europe and Russia. “I doubt Kosovo will get full recognition in the near future,” he says. “Russia has too much at stake to change its position.”

Russia, a UN Security Council member has stood firmly by its long-term ally Serbia in defiance of Western powers it fears to be encroaching ever more boldly into its European and Central Asian spheres of influence. The Serbian President had warned even prior to the declaration of independence that his country would “never recognise an independent Kosovo” and continues to regard it as a “southern province”.

But Kosovo now has a flag, its own national anthem and only last month the Kosovars came up with their very first constitution. Surely Serbia cannot indefinitely ignore what’s happened?

“Kosovo is now involved in regional activities and Serbia will have to accept that,” says Fawn. “Increasing pressure on Serbia by the EU will show nominal - not official - recognition of Kosovo in some activities by virtue of EU and Western-led regional initiatives for the Balkans as a whole.”

But the most remarkable aspect has been the virtual lack of recognition Kosovo has received from the Middle East – save if one counts EU-aspiring Turkey. It is surprising because 90 per cent of Kosovars are Muslim. So perhaps the reluctance has more to do with regional alliances, such as the Russians' support of Iran, and of course fears of secessionist Kurdish and other movements.

And it's not just Middle Eastern nations that fear what independence could mean for their federation. “Kosovo has recognition from all the main western players, save a few that have some recognition or separatist issues of their own like Spain, Cyprus and Slovakia,” says Fawn. “But note that Canada and the UK - with separatist issues - still recognize Kosovo.”

However Kosovo has not been totally shunned by the Islamic nations. Looking outside of the Middle East, Afghanistan was one of the first to offer its recognition. Bangladesh, Malaysia, Pakistan, Qatar and Saudi Arabia are all listed under 'Countries that will recognize Kosovo' on Kosovo Thanks You.

Once those countries take the plunge others may follow in a domino fashion.

“We understand the recognition process is slow in itself,” say Deva and Kastrati. “This is a political process that requires time and clarity, something that is happening as we speak. In due time more countries will have recognized our Republic. It will take years for this process to conclude – same as with other countries around the world.”

And there are signs of hope already including messages of solidarity from people in Serbia and Russia. One such message on the website’s Wall of Independence was from Ivana in Belgrade, Serbia: “Dear neighbours, I would really like to congratulate you for independence. Finally, that happened... Hope one day we will be good neighbours and friends.”

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

18 comments from readers

Philobiblos
28 July 2008 at 17:47

This is a sad articleto appear in a publication such as yours: flogging an entity imposed on the same rationale as Hitler's (who supported hornery minorities as wedge against presumed Russian influence). You will have to reconsider when Scotland spins off into independence (talking with it most offshore oil rights). Meanwhile, we in the Balkans are stuck with a non-state, the only institutions of which are the clan and organized crime, with economic base of drug smuggling, human trafficking and even exporting of human organs. It is not clear who in Kosovo thanks you, other than the likes of Haradinaj (escaped war crimes trial as most of the prosecution witnesses were killed) or Thaci, labeled a terrorist by the very State Dept. that went on to recognize him!...

leo
29 July 2008 at 00:37

Philobiblos,

The entire state of Kosova thanks the West along with Albania and all Albanians across the world.

Clearly, you must be of greek origin as you don't seem to have a problem with the genocide that was in the making in Kosova. Furthermore, the Greek government has been torturing ethnic Albanians in Greece. Want proof? Visit youtube.com and type in 'Greek torture' and you shall see for yourself.

Who should thank the West? Anyone who favor peace and prosperity.

Sue
29 July 2008 at 07:26

The name Kosovo, not Kosova, is in itself a "Serbian" word, not Albanian. Kosovo means to scythe. The poor Serbian farmers of the past used "Scythe's" to harvest their crops in "Kosovo" before the invention of modern day machinery was even developed. The Serbian farmers worked their land by hand and named their "Holy Land" where Serbians originated from Kosovo! This whole ordeal as far as who does Kosovo rightfully belong to could be very easily settled by using some common sense. Kosovo really is a Serbian word and can be proven by simply looking up the word "Scythe" in the English/Serbian dictionary. Wars all over the world can be avoided if only common sense is used and people would think out problem situations before acting on them with guns and bombs. Life is very short and politics only cause our short time on this planet to be complicated. It only takes some thought before one opens their mouths and starts a war.

nickBouer
29 July 2008 at 08:14

Nick

Well Mr. or Mrs. Sue whom ever you may be you almost made me cry with your nostalgic anecdote but you Serbs or Serb lovers should read a little bit of history not make it up as you please. Kosovo has, is and always belong to its people who are Albanian Kosovars and all those who wish to live peacefully in Republic of Kosovo. For you Sue have you considered becoming a diplomat, good job! You wish to eliminate all the wars by looking in the dictionary. What an inelegant individual you are.

nimh
29 July 2008 at 13:51

Interesting article. But why is it headed under the Middle East section? Last I checked Kosovo was very much in Europe.. ;-)

Admin
29 July 2008 at 17:28

nimh - mistake on our part now rectified. The default category is the first one you assign and we just didn't assign in the right order. Thanks for flagging it up...

Sumar
29 July 2008 at 17:45

It is mostly NATO and countries under the sway of NATO power that have recognized Kosovo

The word Kosovo has roots in the Serbian language, just as Sue stated. The word Kosova also has roots in the Serbian language pertaining to the bird "Kos".

Ancient history of who was there first has little to do with actual reality, or else the Native Americans would have claim to the total area of USA and Canada. This obviously isn't going to happen.

The only possible claim of separation the people of Kosovo might have, is if they had a referendum in which all citizens of Serbia were allowed to vote, this is the legal way.

This did not happen, the Kosovo parliament made the decision for all the people in Serbia, that Serbia can do without Kosovo. Illegal.

This is the reality, not some pseudo-nationalistic view of the world where every tiny group of people can pick and choose what territory belongs to them.

If the 'State of Kosovo' cannot separate legally, then it should be ready to do it by way of war, and to retain the sovereignty of its borders ON ITS OWN after the war. Unfortunately they cannot do this and rely on the protection of NATO, which does not make them an 'Independent State', it makes them a NATO base in Europe.

I say tiny because there are cities with bigger populations, and the police forces in these cities can defeat Kosovo and annex it. Its really not self sustaining.

Beaty
29 July 2008 at 23:55

www.savekosovo.org

Who is Hashim Thaci? (Albanin rebel PM)

"It is known that in 1995 Mr. Thaci, together with his crony Mr. Haradinaj, met in Tirana with Osama bin-Laden to plan the jihad against Serbs in Kosovo. Americans should keep in mind that the terrorist reach of the KLA is not confined to Serbia but already has reached American shores with the barely averted plot by jihad terrorists, four of whom are Albanian Muslims from the Kosovo region, to attack Fort Dix in New Jersey and kill American servicemen.

"Perhaps most appalling is Mr. Thaci's role with respect to horrifying reports that organs destined for the illegal trade in organs for transplant were torn from live Serbian prisoners of the KLA. Some of the Serbian victims, after having one kidney cut out, were returned to confinement with fellow captives pending the lethal surgical removal of their other organs, waiting in knowing dread of the fate prepared for them! As documented by U.N. former war crimes prosecutor Carla Del Ponte -- someone who hardly can be accused of having a pro-Serb bias -- these reports are specific and credible and cry out for immediate investigation. The U.S.-based advocacy organization Human Rights Watch has written to Mr. Thaci with their concerns about this matter, which he has dismissed with cavalier indifference. This is hardly surprising, given that these atrocities were committed by his KLA minions, for whose actions he bears command responsibility. Indeed, in light of Mr. Thaci's criminal proclivities, is it not more than likely he himself profited from this gruesome trade?

Arber
30 July 2008 at 15:09

Peace to all from Kosova. It is very sad that so many people still live in the dark of ignorance. Words have no values, but facts do. Here are some facts for you: 1. Around 1 million Albanian people were put to trains and sent to Albania and Macedonia. Since one of you mention Hitler, does this remind you of anything that happen during WW two? 2. Serbia lost Croatia, Bosnia, Herzegovina. Macedonia, Montenegro, and Kosova, but fought and committed massacres to keep them. 3. It is the Serbs that continue to go to Hague for their 20th century barbarian crimes. The whole free world knows that Kosova was the victim and Serbia was the country that committed genocide, aperantly the only ones that don't know yet are the serbs. Kosova will live in peace, because historicly Albanian people never fought a country other than on defence, but you will never see kosova again.

Peace,

Arber

Arber
30 July 2008 at 15:14

Forgot one more thing. Lord bless the U.S.A and Kosova for always being freedom countries.

knave
30 July 2008 at 15:20

Where is kosova ?

nawawimohamad
31 July 2008 at 08:31

Kosovons are either too naive or simply stupid to trust the US. The US is more interested in annoying Russia then really care about Kosovo. The sad thing about the Kosovons is that they have not realise that they have been jilted by the US!

Toni
31 July 2008 at 12:09

The only possible claim of separation the people of Kosovo might have, is if they had a referendum in which all citizens of Serbia were allowed to vote, this is the legal way.

This did not happen, the Kosovo parliament made the decision for all the people in Serbia, that Serbia can do without Kosovo. Illegal.

This is like asking for a referendum the whole ex-Austro-Hungarian Empire if Croatia, Slovenia or Bosnia can be independent.

Conflicts are not always solved by war. Look how north African states got independence from France. They did not have to go to war with the French Army. They would have never won that. Todays civilization is at least that advanced to not allow an entire nation to suffer on the heels of another one.

If someone doubts that Kosovo Albanians were suffering under Yugoslavian-Serbian regime then clearly there is no point to discuss further.

The only alternatives to independence might be:

total border separation along ethnic lines ( a really bad option)

Serbia - Kosova confederation where all ethnic group would have the same rights.

and everyone knows that Serbian governments have never considered such options.

PLEURAT
31 July 2008 at 13:32

a comment for Sue; your name sounds english but i can only say you you have diped your hand in the deep and dark serbian bag of misinformation.alighten your thoughts with some true history,there is no proof that the albanians did't live as far north as Nish(Nissus) and the serbs on the other hand we all know where they come from,and i can suggest many places but in true history from somewhere in between Carpathian mountains and Russian steeps so let's cut the bulls..t and there is no shorter life than when you live a misinformed life.

Arber
31 July 2008 at 14:54

Below is a link with documented Serbian crimes to civilians in Kosova. This is my last attempt to explain to the Serbs and war lovers what massacres the Serbs have done in Kosova through out the years. Look at the pictures and for those of you that support Serbia, see yourself in the mirror. One more thing, the day that Serbia will see Kosova again will only happen if there are no Albanian left alive in this world. Peace and Lord bless the U.S, Kosova and the rest of the free world.

http://www.alb-net.com/warcrimes-img/warcrimes.htm

Samuel
03 August 2008 at 23:03

"But Kosovo now has a flag, its own national anthem and only last month the Kosovars came up with their very first constitution. Surely Serbia cannot indefinitely ignore what’s happened?"

Compelling. Has Kosovo learned to say "Daddy" yet?

www.beyazrenkler.org
08 August 2008 at 15:56

Meanwhile, we in the Balkans are stuck with a non-state, the only institutions of which are the clan and organized crime, with economic base of drug smuggling, human trafficking and even exporting of human organs

www.beyazrenkler.org
08 August 2008 at 15:58

The Serbian farmers worked their land by hand and named their "Holy Land" where Serbians originated from Kosovo! This whole ordeal as far as who does Kosovo rightfully belong to could be very easily settled by using some common sense. Kosovo really is a Serbian word and can be proven by simply looking up the word "Scythe" in the English/Serbian dictionary.

This did not happen, the Kosovo parliament made the decision for all the people in Serbia, that Serbia can do without Kosovo. Illegal.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

Read More

Vote!

Should the third runway at Heathrow go ahead?