The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Is it over for Obama and the Democrats?

It might just be too soon to write off the president and his party.

It's not about him -- it's what he stands for. Two thirds of Americans don't have an issue with President Obama as a person -- it's not that they really think he's aloof, or too remote, or any of the other stuff which is supposed to be behind his fall in the polls.

It's just that the vast numbers of middle-of-the-road voters across the country are proving more centre-right than centre-left. Health care was one thing - but what's not going down well, it seems, is the President's handling of the economy - from the banking bail out to the still-rising numbers out of work.

When the economy is doing badly - history shows people tend to blame the party in power. And the latest survey show just one third of Americans think Barack Obama has been a "very good" or a "good" president: the rest consider him merely average, or downright "poor".

It's useful ammunition for the GOP, of course: House minority leader John Boehner is making his first major speech of the campaign in Ohio, where he'll focus on jobs: as an aide put it - "the November election will be a referendum on President Obama and Washington Democrats' job killing record." And RNC chairman Michael Steele bashed out an instant response to the jobless figures: "President Obama and his left wing allies on Capitol Hill have spent trillions of taxpayer dollars with nothing to show for it but a mountain of crippling debt and chronic joblessness."

So just over three weeks before the midterms - how should the Democrats fight back? The good news for the party is that barely anyone (just 22%, apparently) - thinks Sarah Palin would make an effective president.

And key election strategist David Plouffe, who's back running Obama's "Organising for America" campaign, has insisted voters are still open to the arguments - claiming large numbers are being put off the Republicans by the success of Tea party candidates.

President Obama himself - and the First Lady, Michelle (now officially the "World's Most Powerful Woman"...whey-hey...) - are out there whipping up enthusiasm on the campaign trail. Even Joe Biden's been sent out on the road, campaigning for 18 candidates in 23 cities across the country - with 18 more events in his busy diary before election day.

And there's a decidely populist tone coming from many Democrats - a direct pitch to working families - hitting Republicans by bashing corporate America, outsourcing of jobs, and the minimum wage.

Yesterday President Obama used his veto to block a bill that sneaked through Congress last week - which critics say would have made it easier for lenders to evict people who missed their mortgage payments. There are legal moves going on in at least ten states to extend a voluntary freeze on foreclosures - with calls for a moratorium across the country.

Union officials from the AFL-CIO have put out literature in Illinois, Oregon and Minnesota, accusing Republican gubernatorial candidates of opposing an increase in the minimum wage - while highlighting other Republican candidates who've proposed doing away with federal minimum wage regulations altogether.

And Democrats in many districts are pushing the message that they're on the side of ordinary workers - a message that pollsters say has been going down well with focus groups. In at least six close-fought Senatorial contests, like California and Indiana - they're putting out campaign ads attacking the Republicans over their record on outsourcing - like this, from Barbara Boxer: "Carly Fiorina laid off 30,000 workers. Fiorina shipped jobs to China."

Not that the Republicans are taking this quietly: a collection of lobbyists from big business called Club Fox Growth is splurging millions on ads in toss-up states which depict Democrats as "out of touch with the financial plight of average Americans." Look at the level of campaign spending, in fact, and you'd be forgiven for thinking the recession never happened...television spending by outside interest groups, says the New York Times, has more than doubled the amount spent at this stage in the 2006 midterms.

But is any of this - from hard cash to populist ads - galvanising people to the polls, and overcoming that much-documented 'enthusisasm gap' among those voters who so optimistically swept Barack Obama into power?

The most recent survey by Pew Research at first looks alarmist - under its banner headline 'Lagging Youth Enthusiasm Could Hurt Democrats in 2010'. But read a little closer - and the numbers are rather more hopeful for the party. Younger voters, it says, are far more supportive of the President than any other age group. 58% of the so called 'Millennial' generation still approve of how he's doing. Of course optimism is the preserve of the young. And three weeks isn't long to turn things around. But still - it might just be too soon to write off Obama - and those "left wing allies on Capitol Hill" - just yet.

Felicity Spector is chief writer and American politics expert for Channel 4 News.

31 comments

jie4v7i14's picture

To sound controversial, maybe the republican run institusions in the US are using and playing the black-thing hidden under-skin racism to undermine what the Democrats are trying to do?

Bit like Torys with the working classes here in Britland, 1977-79 and 2007-10?

Daragh McDowell's picture

Memo to all Journalists:

1) Every US President since Johnson (excepting Bush II who was still on his 9/11 High)has seen his party take significant losses during his first mid-terms.

2) Obama is significantly more popular than Clinton, Reagan or Carter during comparable points in their respective administrations. The fact that he is holding steady in the mid to high 40's during the worst recession in US history since the 1930s is a near miraculous example of political resilience, not a sign of weakness.

3) Above all, the GOP remains significantly less popular in general and on just about every issue than the Democrats.

The mid-term results will have more to do with America having a terrible electoral system, an unbelievably flawed political process, and a crappy media than anything Obama has, could, should or would do.

jack blake's picture

It is shocking to watch the American stupidity as they reinstall the same people who ran he economy into the ground.They talk o socialism is so ignorant as to be beyond belief. regulation is what it is: regulation, not socialism. Most countries int he world have some aspects of socialism in their economies and do better than we do. Our education system is below that of most developed countries; our health "system" is a joke where millions cannot afford any coverage or pay for coverage not worth paying for;the rich leach off of the tax role and have socialism for themselves. The stupidity of the Americans cannot even distinguish between the notion of a policy and an emergency act which staved off (this far) a Depression like the one the Republicans brought about in the 1920's. As far as FDR goes, imbeciles: he saved capitalism friom itself. Try reading (If you can read) Conrad Black's biography of him , written by a man who thought he was going to expose the FDR myth and found out that he was as he says,"The great man of the 20th century."

Marcus's picture

If the US economy falls over again it will be over for him. The Democratic Party will go on though.

jie4v7i14's picture

Republican tea-party speechwriter giving an excuse for one of their front-line soldieressess faux-pas on live tv, alledgedly(!)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JaSvXLct4o

thinkov's picture

great piece by gary younge in todays Guardian

Republicans are just rich powerful truth alterers

bravely going where credibility has never been before

Sam's picture

Jesus man. I can understand British media covering presidential elections in America (although would be nice if they didn't dedicate so much time to it) but really, why is there so much reporting about mid term elections?

It's pretty undignified the way the British media fawns over America.

fairplay's picture

the rats are deserting the sinking ship.

emanuel, axelrod and summers all leaving. what does that tell you?

Luddite's picture

Obama WHO?

Corcaighrebel's picture

He was written off months ago by Gore Vidal and others.

Novermber will be a watershed for the US as a whole, gifted to Republicans.

Jenny's picture

The comments from liberals (like this author) are funny. They concoct all these little scenarios where there heroes (left wing hacks to most Americans) just might survive. This election will be a tsunami...70+11 at least.

Richard L. Kent, esq.'s picture

"The mid-term results will have more to do with America having a terrible electoral system, an unbelievably flawed political process, and a crappy media than anything Obama has, could, should or would do."

Keep believing that. Push for more socialized medicine and greater government ownership of business and seizure of guns. Please. Particularly for the next four weeks. I promise you it will do wonders for the United States. Really.

swatantra's picture

Its by no means over, in fact the great adventure is still in its infancy. Obama will be one of the Greats when he eventually steps down in 6 years time. They'll carve an image of him on Mt Vernon to join the other 4 Greats.
The election of Obahma was the day America came of age. And gained respect in the community of Nations.
Before, Americans were unloved even hated. Obama restored faith in the USA from the people of the world.
He is more loved by the outside world than perhaps native Americans, but thats the way it goes. Americans never appreciate heir great Presidents.

MinRkist's picture

It is true that the dominent party will be trounced in November.
This is a good thing, not only for the U.S. but for the world. FDR had 4 terms to screw with the American economy. The Keynesian incompetants will be stopped in less than 4 weeks.

jie4v7i14's picture

swantantra, makes me laugh how far Dakota is from Washington D of pathetic C, it really does. So did the great brit Hitchcock.

RK's picture

@swatantra nandanwar.

God is dead. Allah is dead. Bhagwan is dead. What you call God in Socialism? Ok. Obama is dead. Well almost.

jie4v7i14's picture

..put it..., North by North West?

jie4v7i14's picture

Alf,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRfmTpmIUwo

Neal Kaye's picture

More "Whistlin' past the graveyard" articles from the libs. Independent voters have woken up to the fact that Obama, Pelosi and Reid are dedicated Fabian Socialists (we conservatives knew this all along), and they don't like it one bit. The Dems are going to be crushed in November and Obama has/will become a one-term, lame-duck President. All your Pollyanna articles aren't going to obviate these facts.

GoHillary2012's picture

FDR in his 1st midterms (1934) actually saw the Dems gain seats. The economy was still poor but Americans respected his leadership after his "100 days of action" with the New Deal and other programmes.

Contrast that to Obama - 2 years on from his great 2008 victory he is now seen as the "Emperor who has no clothes"!

Solution for the Dems after this years midterms is to dump Obama for 2012 and go with Hillary instead - as they probably now wish they had done back in 2008!

PhilDuval's picture

@ MinRkist, RK & Neal Kaye

Please can you tell me how you would have regulated the financial industry before the Lehman Brothers crash?

Can you also tell me what you would have done after the crash when the entire economic system was about to collapse?

And finally what would you do for the 30 million Americans who not only have no medical insurance but also need government food stamps?

jie4v7i14's picture

modern day Alf, by Falken tyres, Pikes Peak in Colorado, climbing, in the modern sense of the word,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2y3OFf0ArU

jeremiah's picture

I don't think it is over for Obama. In fact having a right wing nutjob Congress in 2012 may help him get re-elected.

Obama and the Democrats face the same test that Clinton did in 1994. He lost the Elections that year badly, just like Obama will lose this year.

Obama needs a vindictive right wing demagouge to be elected House speaker, just like Gingrich.

With a right wing Congress Obama can tack back to the centre over the next two years. He can then paint the "TEA Party Congress" as extremists come 2012.

Queendarara's picture

PLZ VISIT BLOG.......M NEW BLOGGER..........I NEED U...................

http://topfashionblog4pk.blogspot.com/

jie4v7i14's picture

Hey, Gram may have a song to get you through this Barack,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3cToJxub3c

jie4v7i14's picture

ever so Little Feat,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDp3Grz28mE

triedeinsursE's picture

The closest he will get to Mt Vernon is a pair of concrete boots.

triedeinsursE's picture

2) Obama is significantly more popular than Carter!!!!!!!

Now that's a classic.

jie4v7i14's picture

Where's Mount Rushmore Buckskins, tell'us where it is, to sort god and proper my damned life out. Which Dakota bro?

jie4v7i14's picture

Buckskins, a brit caught singing beautiful Russian, right in the middle of the supposedly called, cold war. He sings like a flying lark, you might agree, Buckskins,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jEYsHm0KoMA

Titus77's picture

Win or lose, conservatives are the worst of America. They are greedy, shameless liars.

Latest tweets