Osborne's speech: long on politics, short on growth
The Chancellor launched attack after attack on Labour, but where was the plan for growth?
By George Eaton Published 08 October 2012 13:13
When George Osborne addressed the Conservative conference he did so as his party's chief election strategist, not as Chancellor. His speech was long on politics, but staggeringly short on growth (indeed, the word didn't appear) and jobs.
As ever, one could not fault his chutzpah. He declared that the country must not "divide one group against another" before casually demonising welfare claimants as scroungers, "sleeping off a life on benefits". He insisted that everyone had been too optimistic about growth, forgetting those economists - Paul Krugman, Robert Skidelsky, our own David Blanchflower - who warned that his obsession with austerity would tip the country back into recession. And, for the first time since he abolished the 50p tax rate on earnings over £150,000, he uttered the words "we're all in it together". In one of his many assaults on Labour, Osborne declared, "All this talk about something for something and they've learned nothing about anything", but with the country back in recession (the only G20 country, with the exception of Italy, to be so) and borrowing up by 22% so far this year, it was he who gave the appearance of having learned nothing.
Faced with a crisis of demand, the government needs to stimulate growth through tax cuts and higher infrastructure spending. It could take advantage of the ultra-low interest rates that Osborne is so fond of boasting of and borrow for an emergency stimulus. But all the Chancellor offered was a fiendishly complex new scheme allowing workers to acquire shares in their companies in exchange for giving up employment rights. In Britain, already the third most deregulated labour market in the developed world, it is not excessive regulation or "red tape" that is constraining growth. But the Chancellor, blind to the need to revive "animal spirits", still acts as if it is.
He unambiguously ruled out a "mansion tax", vowing that "this party of home ownership will have no truck with it". Yet just 3.1% of homes are worth more than £1m and the tax, as proposed by Vince Cable, would only apply to those twice this amount. In rejecting higher property taxes, Osborne has missed an opportunity to prove that he really is more concerned about "the squeezed middle" than squeezed millionaires. His priority, he said, would be to further reduce "aggressive tax avoidance", but making the rich pay taxes they're meant to be paying anyway is not the same as raising taxes on them. If the Lib Dems are to avoid further humiliation, they will need something more in return for signing up to an additional £10bn of punitive welfare cuts.
As Osborne spoke, it became clear that David Cameron had contracted out the job of attacking Ed Miliband to his Chancellor. Evidently unsettled by the Labour leader's bravura speech, Osborne declared that it was "risible" to pretend that you can become a party of "one nation" just by repeating the phrase, and that Miliband, masquerading as a centrist, was, in reality, "moving to the left". But in his refusal to adopt a more balanced deficit reduction strategy and in his defence of the wealthy, it is the Chancellor who has vacated the centre ground and his party that has relinquished any claim to be a party of "one nation". Today's speech did nothing to correct those errors.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















9 comments
No matter what they say, their words will only turn into deeds if the Freemasons approve it. The whole of the south coast is run by these people and Osborne is trying to deflect blame when he talkes about scroungers. At least those are honest scroungers, unlike the thousands of non-job civil servants who continue to dream up pointless schemes. In Lyme Regis - and I suspect many towns and villages - they have a 'Trust' which has never done anything and is duplicated in effect by the Local Plan. The Trust does however employ self-replicating bureaucrats, and has visits, and visits to, other self-replicating parasitic bureaucrats.
Now that we have the example of Greece, we should rip up the contracts of these non-job parasites before they do any more damage.
Where's Labour's plan?
Utter rubbish from the Chancellor, borrowing more then last year, and blaming Miliband for not mentioning the deficit.
He hasn't got the guts to admit Plan A has failed miserable, no economic growth, job creation propped up record part time workers, and deficits as far as the eye can see.
I take it Gideon is going to be honest with the country, and explain how much he will have to borrow post 2015?
Dreadful little man.
Literal translation from the german language Communist Manifesto is "Proletarians of all countries unite". After listening to his speech I cannot decide if I am an Andrew Mitchell pleb a Gideon prole or a Flashman t**t. What I do know is that Gideon seems to come effortlessly first in the sneer sweepstakes by at least a thick head and curled lip.
Keep going Ed, this lot have no moral anchorage. Their anchor will drag soon enough.
The country craves for the Ted Miliband-Balls-Brown axis to get us out of this mess.
They should regroup and lead us, as they did from 2005 onwards and help restore the order they had created now being wrecked by the coalition in 29 months.
The days of queues outside banks, money wasted on useless projects, bankers who were knighted and feted, the stinking rich mentality of Mandelson.
We yearn for those days to return. Get Gordon out of retirement.
One thing that Gideons bloviating confirmed was, Flashman and the rest of the Nasty party are rattled by Ed Miliband!, attack after attack, Miliband and Labour will take this as a compliment!.
Gideon also played to the Tory gallery by his usual scapegoating of EVERYONE on benefits!, "We`re all in this together", as 'Plebs', we should all know our place!!.
What is there to say about this vacuous and noxious idiot?
Rather like bubonic plague he will run his course, do very real and lasting damage to Britain and its population and thankfully, also to the Tory Party.
Apparently, he's such a clever stategist.
the deeper problem is how do we have a vibrant export sectors, good we can sell abroad? US style incubators that allow new ideas to flourish and venture capital that is willing to help companies grow and not look for the short term buck. Companies like Facebook are nurtured and whole eco-system and valuable cluster is developed.
Where are the answers from UK politicians, there is no real answer!
The longer the Tories are in power the clearer it is who they stand for and what they represnt; privilege and favours for those who already have with bullying and repression for the weak and the needy. Gideon's 'management' of the economy has proved they are no longer just the nasty party they are the bumbling incompetent nasty party. They should never see power again.