Freedom is not about allowing people to do things that you approve of. Freedom is about protecting peoples’ rights to do things you find distasteful.
So said Jon Caldara, president of the Independence Institute at its 10th Annual Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms Party last Saturday.
The ATF party – “the most fun, most politically incorrect event of the year” – invites members of the public to “celebrate the perks of adulthood” by partaking in a “PETA-friendly clay pigeon shoot followed by a clubhouse luncheon complete with whiskey and cigars in one of the last places available to smokers – the outside”.
“This year the forum focuses on personal liberties and gun rights. Participants discuss government regulation of tobacco, food and drink, and are critical of what some speakers call the “Nanny State”. Other topics include the New York City ban on trans fats, Mayor Bloomberg’s proposed ban on certain soft drink sizes, global warming and this year’s presidential campaign.
It would be easy to dismiss an event where one of the speakers, David Matosko, considers global warming “an aggressive hoax” as yet another case-in-point to the sheer lunacy of the American ‘right’. But much more lucid speakers, such as David Kopel, the Institute’s Research Director, point to some unpalatable truths about the hypocrisy and intolerance that plague both sides of the partisan fence.
Kopel begins by criticising Mayor Bloomberg’s Mayors Against Illegal Guns as a powerful lobby for the prohibition of guns in general, rather than simply the prohibition of illegal guns. He goes on to state that the there are 19 members of the group “who have left office for felony convictions, or are under indictment (…). Mayor Bloomberg’s organisation has a much higher crime rate than people who have permits to carry guns for lawful protection. I think in the interest of truth in advertising that the proper way to refer to this group is Illegal Mayors Against Guns.”.
The tongue-in-cheek tone of the party is later sobered by Kopel’s call to divert Colorado tax money from unconstitutional “corporate welfare” to more grassroots community projects. In particular reference to the Aurora shooting this summer, the speaker calls for more investment in mental health services.
He later highlights the glaring hypocrisy of a country that has banned smoking in films, but emphatically glorifies violent gun misuse. Kopel argues that violence is indisputably condoned, but the key is to encourage a responsible gun sports culture:
We are not only on the pro-choice side, we are on the pro-life side as well. What we do every day is to fight for those lifesaving values of safety responsibly.
The underlying ethos of the ATP is best summarised by Caldara himself – in many places, a liberal accepting gun culture is as socially unacceptable as being against same-sex marriage. In this sense, the ATP stands as an attack to the tribal, divisive, and outright illogical divide that keeps the USA in gridlock.
As with so much in contemporary American politics, the gun control issue is not about reason and dispassionate analysis of the facts. It’s about emotional assertion and rhetorical bullying amid an atmosphere of mutual incomprehension.