Reviewing politics
and culture since 1913

Can politicans find consensus on social care?

The need for reform is widely acknowledged, but agreement on how to deliver and fund it remains elusive

Ellie Chowns – Westminster leader, Green Party

Successive governments have treated social care as a political football for too long, while ordinary families have paid the price for their failure to act. People are left without the support they need, unpaid carers are stretched to breaking point and care workers remain undervalued.

This cannot go on. If we are serious about delivering lasting change, MPs from across the political spectrum must put party aside and work together for the greater good.

To do that, we need to change the perception of cross-party collaboration from a “nice to have” to an “essential”. The Casey Commission provided a starting point for cross-party discussions, but meetings have been few and far between. Genuine progress requires a commitment to regular and substantive conversations, alongside willingness to work constructively with all voices. Crucially, people who use social care services, unpaid carers and those working in the sector must also help shape solutions.

The first priority should be to find consensus on a fair, sustainable funding model that pools the risk of needing care, rather than leaving individuals exposed to potentially ruinous costs.

Gift a New Statesman subscription for only £2

We see in the example of the NHS how a system funded by us all benefits us all in turn; there is no reason why social care could not follow a similar model. And we must ensure any funding model also serves to properly value the paid care workforce and unpaid carers on whom the system depends.

Parties will naturally disagree on details, but that cannot become an excuse for indefinite delay. We owe it to everyone who relies on social care to find common ground, agree a clear direction and finally start delivering the genuine change
they deserve.

Damian Hinds MP – Shadow secretary of state for health and social care, Conservative Party

As Britain’s population ages, the question of social care is becoming increasingly pressing. Conservatives recognise the scale of this challenge and will engage constructively to deliver meaningful improvements, but serious reform requires more than speeches, press releases and headlines.

Select and enter your email address Your weekly guide to the best writing on ideas, politics, books and culture every Saturday. The best way to sign up for The Saturday Read is via saturdayread.substack.com The New Statesman's quick and essential guide to the news and politics of the day. The best way to sign up for Morning Call is via morningcall.substack.com
Visit our privacy Policy for more information about our services, how Progressive Media Investments may use, process and share your personal data, including information on your rights in respect of your personal data and how you can unsubscribe from future marketing communications.
THANK YOU

I was surprised, after Andy Burnham repeatedly stressed the importance of cross-party cooperation, that he decided to announce his social care proposals unilaterally at Labour Party Conference. There was no debate or discussion. There was no coherent funding plan. And there were no measurable targets for how this would work in practice. Instead, the new Prime Minister homed in on pensioners with plans to scrap the triple lock.

He could have laid out plans to tackle the growing problem of people who can work instead of being reliant on the taxpayer, but he chose to go after people who have worked hard all their lives. He could at least have told pensioners exactly how their money would deliver better social care. But the speech was light on detail and neglected the glaring hole in the government’s sums. The public deserve transparency about plans on this scale, but they aren’t getting it. This raises concerns that the Chancellor will announce yet more tax hikes at the Budget.

The Conservatives are clear: Labour must not fund a new social care service by raising taxes. If they want to raise funds, they must do it by cutting spending. We are willing to work across party lines to deliver better outcomes for the public. But meaningful reform requires honesty about the scale of the challenge and the cost involved. All we have had so far from Labour is financially reckless policy. Labour must be transparent about the billions required for their plans and explain how this will be funded without further tax rises.

Simon Bottery – Senior fellow, social care, The King’s Fund

Members and politicians from most parties agree that wide reform of social care is needed. Consensus is by no means impossible.

Surprisingly diverse politicians have argued for better access to publicly funded care. When the Prime Minister speaks of care “free at the point of use”, he uses the same policy language as the Greens and similar to that of the Lib Dems.

For the Conservatives, there is no clear policy line, but figures like Jacob Rees-Mogg and Damian Green have also called for at least some care to be free at the point of use. Reform’s Danny Kruger has written in favour of free personal care at home.

Admittedly, the devil can be in the detail. There is no consensus about exactly what should be free, under what circumstances and when.

Yet these nuances are surely not irreconcilable if parties wanted genuinely to find common ground. It is not hard to imagine a system like that in other comparable countries where some care is free to all but the better-off must contribute. At The King’s Fund, we have published work setting out what this detail should look like.

Agreement on funding a better system is harder, though, because it exposes differing political philosophies.

Some still argue for voluntary private insurance; others for a tax on wealth or inheritance – a “death tax” to its detractors.

The conversation effectively pushed concern about the latter in the 2010 election. Labour and other opposition parties used fears of a “dementia tax” in 2017 to similar effect.

The reality is that we will all need to pay, which is unpalatable to some. Should we forget cross-party talks then? No. Agreement on direction of travel is possible; the public can then decide who to believe on the detail and its funding.

Sojan Joseph – Labour MP and chair of the APPG on Adult Social Care

Every party has treated social care as a ‘political football’, using cheap slogans to attack opponents’ plans. Jeremy Corbyn branded Theresa May’s policy a “dementia tax” in 2017. In 2010, David Cameron used “death tax” to undermine Gordon Brown’s plans. Now, Ed Davey, a longtime care advocate, is point scoring over the triple lock reforms helping fund Labour’s social care plans, to some Liberal Democrat backbenchers’ dismay.

As the Adult Social Care APPG Chair, I work across parties, with people with lived experience and advocacy groups. I am optimistic we can move beyond point scoring and fix this.

Before becoming an MP, I worked in the NHS for 22 years. I saw austerity cut services to the bone. They have not fully recovered. Last year, my local hospital, where I previously worked, was so overcrowded that patients were treated in a
coffee shop. To end corridor care, we must tackle delayed discharge caused by inadequate social care, including insufficient community capacity and poor coordination.

I was delighted the Prime Minister made this link at Party Conference and welcome Labour’s long-term plans and Casey Review. However, we do need action now.

Labour must deliver our commitment to create a National Care Service, free at the point of use, providing the dignity and security people deserve. We must find common ground because we cannot fix the NHS and build a healthcare system fit for the future until we fix social care.

Content from our partners
The missing utility: Delivering heat ownership into local hands
Boehringer Ingelheim: Time to breathe new life into lung health
Don’t take the biscuit